Stakes are too high. Braun/Lujan CANNOT lead us into the New Stadium world

AdamOnFirst

Sophomore
Nov 29, 2021
8,206
106
48
I was at the game on Saturday but then spent the weekend exploring Mississippi and Alabama (interesting places), so I'm arriving to the conversation late.

Saturday was an unmitigated disaster on and apparently off the field with uniform-gate. The team looked positively awful. Having said that...Tulane is also projected to win its conference and early projections have them in the playoffs - they are a good team; only time will tell how good.

To the naysayers, I would simply say/ask: do you want to be right or do you want to be happy? There are 11 games left. You can beat a drum loudly that Braun has to go - and for the record, I am not inherently averse to his dismissal if the team continues to look as bad as it did on Saturday...but I am certainly rooting for improvement.

What I would honestly ask of fellow NU fans here, at the risk of sounding like a blind and deaf polyanna: give him five more games - half a season. Calling for doomsday now on the public board and essentially rooting for it does none of us any good.

With this new era of college football...it's very gross to me that Northwestern is now a program where fans are calling for the head coach to be fired one game into his second actual season of hire, and that we'll get our pitchforks out about individual players when they're 20ish year old millionaires. The whole sport is on fire.
I don’t think anybody is saying it would be productive to fire him now, but I think we’re all expressing that what we’ve been getting isn’t acceptable and varying degrees of skepticism he’ll turn it around.
 

hdhntr1

Senior
Sep 5, 2006
35,728
448
83
Some people may prefer small towns but, stated flatly small towns like those that hist remote colleges are chronically shrinking in population and have been for years and the north shore of Chicago is not. To pretend it isn’t an advantage is silly.
For the bigger schools, most are in or around cities closer to 100-300/400 K range and not as backwater as you suggest. Those are nice size that are not as subject to that shrink and anchored to the Universities and often providing services to those Universities, Just look at the BIG, Cities include Columbus, Ann Arbor, Lansing, Madison, Iowa City, Bloomington IN, State College I could go on, (You got me on W Layfayette with 44K) Other conferences are often similar for the larger schools, Even the 70-80K towns and surrounding areas have enough holding them together to be interesting places to live, Just saying they have a choice of nice cities of various sizes. It isn't either a town of 20k or a megalopolis
 

EvanstonCat

Senior
May 29, 2001
50,569
590
73
Obviously he has a couple more months to turn this around, but it increasingly looks like the role he was hired for was his best fit at this point in his career. Capable P4 DC with the personal motivational chips to lead a team but more development on other points needed.
Frankly, given how our FCS OC is doing with his elevation to the B1G leagues, there is no clarity on how Braun may have fared as a P4 DC.
 

EvanstonCat

Senior
May 29, 2001
50,569
590
73
I was at the game on Saturday but then spent the weekend exploring Mississippi and Alabama (interesting places), so I'm arriving to the conversation late.

Saturday was an unmitigated disaster on and apparently off the field with uniform-gate. The team looked positively awful. Having said that...Tulane is also projected to win its conference and early projections have them in the playoffs - they are a good team; only time will tell how good.

To the naysayers, I would simply say/ask: do you want to be right or do you want to be happy? There are 11 games left. You can beat a drum loudly that Braun has to go - and for the record, I am not inherently averse to his dismissal if the team continues to look as bad as it did on Saturday...but I am certainly rooting for improvement.

What I would honestly ask of fellow NU fans here, at the risk of sounding like a blind and deaf polyanna: give him five more games - half a season. Calling for doomsday now on the public board and essentially rooting for it does none of us any good.

With this new era of college football...it's very gross to me that Northwestern is now a program where fans are calling for the head coach to be fired one game into his second actual season of hire, and that we'll get our pitchforks out about individual players when they're 20ish year old millionaires. The whole sport is on fire.
Sometimes, you just know after one game. Like we even knew after just one play with JON.
 

jensberg

Redshirt
Jul 28, 2006
2,679
10
38
Sometimes, you just know after one game. Like we even knew after just one play with JON.
As many have noted in this and other threads, the probability is strong that our coach will be gone after this year. Unfortunately, as has been mentioned as well, there will be a mass Exodus along with him and our ability to get a large number of transfers even with a high profile coach is doubtful. Could be a tough couple years.
 

Gatabowl

Redshirt
Nov 30, 2022
1,477
37
33
You are forgetting that that contract was not signed until after the 2020 season, and that was after he had been with NU as HC for 15 years and during that 15 years he had had numerous opportunities to go elsewhere but showed loyalty to NU. He had just had 5 of 6 BIG winning seasons. We had just gone to a second BIG Championship game in 3 years and also with the win over Auburn had gone to bowl games in 5 of 6 years and had won 4 straight bowl games so 2019 looked like an aberration. He had numerous potential suitors at that point including NFL teams, He was 25 games over 500 and even had a winning record in the BIG. And that was at NU with all the constraints that other programs did not have to deal with.

Like it or not, he had earned that contract and at that point, no need to look elsewhere. You can argue that it was longer than it needed to be but it was understandable given the circumstances and you cannot argue that he did not earn a contract extension. His first two years under that contract were disappointing. He had made a bad hire and some of the QBs we had counted on had not worked out, But after that second season, he corrected his mistakes and it looked like he again had set up the program for success
He had no reason to want to leave after getting that deal. He would not have gotten it elsewhere. The NU job involved no media or fan pressure. It was the cushiest situation in college sports. Fitz isn’t a bad guy but you act like we were paying him peanuts and he was doing us a favor by hanging around.
 

hdhntr1

Senior
Sep 5, 2006
35,728
448
83
He had no reason to want to leave after getting that deal. He would not have gotten it elsewhere. The NU job involved no media or fan pressure. It was the cushiest situation in college sports. Fitz isn’t a bad guy but you act like we were paying him peanuts and he was doing us a favor by hanging around.
I did not say he was getting paid peanuts or could have gotten that contract somewhere else(likely the cost of getting him to go elsewhere would have been expensive and contained many of those terms however) , but you made it sound like he had been coaching under those terms for a long time. He did not have that deal until the last couple years he was at NU. It was the 5 to 10 years before that that he stayed at NU even though he could likely have done much better elsewhere. In fact there were numerous opportunities including in the pro ranks, He was not poorly paid prior to the new contract but there was a fair amount of uncertainty For example in 2018 he earned about $3.6 mill.. By the time he got the new contract he had earned the extension and at that point (because of the new contract) there was no point in looking elsewhere. But again, that did not occur until Jan 2021. It gave him the security to know he would be coaching his sons


But reality is in this new world and after what they did to him, you might find that a number or items you dislike about the Fitz contact will be required to land the top tier guy you think we have to have, (Lest than 7 year contract? See ya, Guaranteed salary at or above all but the blue bloods. Escalation clauses guarantees etc.) It will probably all be necessary, just to get the guy to come. Fitz put in 15 years before he got those terms but the new guy is likely to get them from day one
 
Last edited:

Gatabowl

Redshirt
Nov 30, 2022
1,477
37
33
I did not say he did but you made it sound like he had been coaching under those terms for a long time. He did not have that deal until the last couple years he was at NU. It was the 5 to 10 years before that that he stayed at NU even though he could likely have done much better elsewhere. In fact there were numerous opportunities including in the pro ranks, He was not poorly paid prior to the new contract but there was uncertainty For example in 2018 he earned about $3.6 mill.. By the time he got the new contract he had earned the extension and at that point (because of the new contract) there was no point in looking elsewhere. But again, that did not occur until Jan 2021

He had the best exit opportunities at the exact same time we gave him the big contract.

The point is, NU can be an attractive job. We have money to spend, we are in the P2, and there’s a level of pressure unheard of in the rest of the P2. Our fans are (too) patient.
 

hdhntr1

Senior
Sep 5, 2006
35,728
448
83
He had the best exit opportunities at the exact same time we gave him the big contract.

The point is, NU can be an attractive job. We have money to spend, we are in the P2, and there’s a level of pressure unheard of in the rest of the P2. Our fans are (too) patient.
We also have more constraints on that coaches ability to succeed than anywhere else, Whoever comes is betting their career on being able to succeed in one of the 4 or five most difficult scenerios in college FB. Only ones that come even close are Vanderbilt, Wake and maybe Stanford and Duke (although the ACC has some paths to success that are less daunting that what NU faces
 

xxxbobxxx

Sophomore
Mar 12, 2005
10,779
128
43
I don’t believe the 4 year guarantee of scholarships is mandated by the NCAA or even by NU. What other program in the country keeps the unproductive steak eaters for 4 years. It’s a different age, but a steak eater should never see a dime of revenue share and we should always be upfront with our performance reviews to players. Not sure they stick around if told they are unlikely to ever see the field. Either way, the Coaches recruited these players so if they have too many steak eaters and they are allowed to remain on the team, they are essentially creating a quick pink slip for themselves.
I am very curious to see how the courts will eventually handle one of these NIL contracts that’s for multiple years with a noncompete clause. Personally, I would write the early ones to make the noncompete applicable only in conference. If tested and successful, I might try to even expand it from there. But it seems to me that these NIL contract should span for more than one year to put some teeth into them.
 

xxxbobxxx

Sophomore
Mar 12, 2005
10,779
128
43
If Braun gets fired we better be able to bring in 30+ transfers as we will surely have a lot of guys transfer out. Like you always see with a coaching change.
You mean all the very poor athletes that a number of the people on this board claim are the reason that we have the results that we have?
 

hdhntr1

Senior
Sep 5, 2006
35,728
448
83
Frankly, given how our FCS OC is doing with his elevation to the B1G leagues, there is no clarity on how Braun may have fared as a P4 DC.
Remember we had a team of D coaches in place on D to support him. We really did not have that on O when Lujin was brought in
 

hdhntr1

Senior
Sep 5, 2006
35,728
448
83
As many have noted in this and other threads, the probability is strong that our coach will be gone after this year. Unfortunately, as has been mentioned as well, there will be a mass Exodus along with him and our ability to get a large number of transfers even with a high profile coach is doubtful. Could be a tough couple years.
Basically the combination could end up being a lost decade
 

hdhntr1

Senior
Sep 5, 2006
35,728
448
83
He had the best exit opportunities at the exact same time we gave him the big contract.

The point is, NU can be an attractive job. We have money to spend, we are in the P2, and there’s a level of pressure unheard of in the rest of the P2. Our fans are (too) patient.
And that is why he was given that contract
 

hdhntr1

Senior
Sep 5, 2006
35,728
448
83
Agree here. He’s in over his head. These other programs are hiring former HC from big programs and NFL coordinators with tons of experience. We are way behind everyone in terms of coaching and it’s very evident
Braun was the best alternative we had at the time and 2023 bought him at least a couple years,
 

hdhntr1

Senior
Sep 5, 2006
35,728
448
83
Does that mean they signed him to a five year contract? WTH were they thinking if that was the case? A guy who had nothing spectacular in his resume and matter of fact left the AD biz to join the NCAA. Let that sink in....
Pretty hard to get someone to move cross country for anything less. Generally for example the would not suggest you buy if you are not intendng to be there at least 5 years
 

hdhntr1

Senior
Sep 5, 2006
35,728
448
83
Dude, you are fine. It worked out for the best. I was making a point that the high academic standards were going to make it harder to get the 4-5 star kids. NU needs to compensate with a HC that has some imagination. From what I heard from family members, it sounded like Earle didn't think he could succeed with those constraints. Obviously he was wrong. It would have been cool if he got the NU job, but he did turn Colorado State around.
I doubt he had the constraints at Colorado State that he would have had at NU
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jaguar 88

hdhntr1

Senior
Sep 5, 2006
35,728
448
83
Agree. A lot of successful guys are that. I would say Barnett and Walker both fit that description. Ty Willingham and David Shaw would have. Cutcliffe and Elko did well at Duke too. They do exist.
Barnett went from OC to HC Walker took a step up in level. Both got significant promotions that might not have been available elsewhere
 

hdhntr1

Senior
Sep 5, 2006
35,728
448
83
You mean all the very poor athletes that a number of the people on this board claim are the reason that we have the results that we have?
Unfortunately, many of them might stick around because of the value of the degree. And that could limit the new coaches ability to bring in those transfers he needs
 

AdamOnFirst

Sophomore
Nov 29, 2021
8,206
106
48
Frankly, given how our FCS OC is doing with his elevation to the B1G leagues, there is no clarity on how Braun may have fared as a P4 DC.
You friggin people act like we’re the first school to grab an FCS coach. Jim friggin Tressel was an FCS coach too, my goodness
 
Aug 31, 2003
14,628
182
63
Unfortunately, many of them might stick around because of the value of the degree. And that could limit the new coaches ability to bring in those transfers he needs
That's what happened on Vassar on the basketball team. They could take away all his playing time but they could not force him to transfer.
 
Dec 10, 2018
465
624
93
Unfortunately, many of them might stick around because of the value of the degree. And that could limit the new coaches ability to bring in those transfers he needs

Great run here. I counted 11 posts in a row. Could be a new record for the Joe DiMaggio of Wildcat Report.
 

Styre

Junior
Oct 14, 2004
7,620
249
63
Last edited:
Aug 31, 2003
14,628
182
63
For that season, yes. They canceled his scholarship after the 2015-16 season and moved him to an academic scholarship for his final two years at NU.

The ironic part of it all was Collins didn't fill the 13th scholarship slot heading into either of those years.
I suspect that the 13th roster spot was never filled because Vassar's 4-year athletic scholarship was binding and guaranteed his free ride at the school and NU would have trouble making the legal claim that he had been moved to an academic scholarship. NU may call it what they wanted but actions speak louder than words.