A lot have already been named:
Dak, Smoot, Norwood, Dixon, Keefer, JJ Johnson, Vick Ballard, Dicenzo Miller (arguably not quite the same as the other RBs on this list, but can't call him average), Porkchop (I think the name is what made fans take notice), Fletcher Cox, Chris Jones, Jonathan Banks, Darius Slay (argument could be made that fans were largely indifferent b/c Banks got all the publicity), Simmons (I guess maybe you could put him in fans divided for the handful of fainting goats that have never seen girls beat the **** out of other girls), Denico Autry, Preston (might could put both of these with SLay as ones fans probably didn't appreciate like they should?). I'm sure there are tons of others I'm forgetting. Most good players are loved by fans.
Might need another square for fans were indifferent to/unaware of for a few good players that just weren't appreciated for whatever reason; and probably lots of OL would go there too.
