Search
Log in
Register
Teams
Teams
Fan Sites
Forums
Shows
College
College Football News
College Football Player Rankings
College Football Rankings
College Football Playoff
College Basketball News
Women's Sports
NIL
NIL News
NIL Valuation
NIL Deals
NIL Deal Tracker
Sports Business
Transfer Portal
Transfer Portal News
NCAA Transfer Portal
Transfer Portal Rankings
Transfer Portal Team Rankings
Recruiting
Football Recruiting
Basketball Recruiting
Database
Team Rankings
Player Rankings
Industry Comparison
Commitments
Recruiting Prediction Machine
High School
High School News
Schools
Rankings
Scores
Draft
NFL Draft
NFL Draft News
Draft By Stars
College Draft History
College Draft Totals
NBA Draft
NBA Draft News
Pro
NFL
NASCAR
NBA
Culture
Sports Betting
About
About
On3 App
Advertise
Press
FAQ
Contact
Get a profile. Be recruited.
New posts
Menu
Install the app
Install
On3:
The Battle of Death Valley: Why LSU-Clemson is the juiciest game this jam-packed Saturday
On3:
FOX, YouTube TV reach short-term extension amid carriage dispute
On3:
After NCAA uncertainty, Rahsul Faison’s waiver approval paves way for South Carolina debut
On3:
20-team Big Ten in 2030, Maryland AD says; Notre Dame will not budge on independence
On3:
The Rally: Nebraska takes on Lipscomb, No. 7 Kentucky in Nashville
Reply to thread
Forums
West Virginia
Mountaineer Message Board
TCU has a superior roster bc of its star QB. And WVU has a better roster than in 2011 bc of depth.
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Message
<blockquote data-quote="Samuel S" data-source="post: 129394297" data-attributes="member: 1754664"><p>A) Explain how player attrition is a recruiting failure after the player leaves 1 1/2 years into his career</p><p></p><p> The failure is having a roster with a sub-par starter and, evidently no 2nd stringer sufficiently developed to play midway through the season. I was obviously just offering, one very minimal way in which we could have reached this point without the dire QB situation we have. Obviously, there are many others.</p><p></p><p>B) Explain how Clint Trickett, who was recruited in 2014, wasn't a good recruiting move.</p><p></p><p> It was a good move in that it was a needed reaction to an obvious crisis at the position. Were we better with Trickett than we would have been without him? When the alternatives were limited to Childress and Millard, the answer is obvious. It's equally obvious that it would heve better short and long term to have recruited at least one good QB reruit with 5 years to play 4 during the 2012-14 recruiting campaingns. People who are not incredibly stupid, would not debate that point.</p><p></p><p></p><p>C) Explain how William Crest, in his 2nd year at WVU, is somehow considered a third-year player at WVU</p><p></p><p>Explain how my mistakenly saying 3rd instead of second, strengthens you ludicrous claim QB recruiting, retention and development has not been a failure.</p><p></p><p></p><p>you're in such a rush to bash Dana that you can't even form a decently accurate thought....</p><p></p><p>What is Bill Stewart's fault..............................</p><p></p><p>Not recruiting another QB in 2009 to go with Geno</p><p></p><p>Not addressing the QB attrition in 2010 prior to Dana arriving</p><p></p><p>Not recruiting a competent HS QB in 2011, instead opting to hand out a "favor" to Brian Athey and his family.</p><p></p><p> Because any problems under Stewart obviously did not become an on the field issue during the 2011-12 seasons and the stupid decision to go HCIW in the midst of 2011 recruiting obviously hamstringed both Stewart and Holgorsen for that class. I don't think it's fair to hold that class, in toto, against either because all the blame goes to Luck.</p><p></p><p>Geno played every game both years. It is pure speculation to say that he or any other coach other than Holgorsen would have been unable to have a competent QB in place in 2015. It's not speculation to say that Holgorsen has proven unable.</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="Samuel S, post: 129394297, member: 1754664"] A) Explain how player attrition is a recruiting failure after the player leaves 1 1/2 years into his career The failure is having a roster with a sub-par starter and, evidently no 2nd stringer sufficiently developed to play midway through the season. I was obviously just offering, one very minimal way in which we could have reached this point without the dire QB situation we have. Obviously, there are many others. B) Explain how Clint Trickett, who was recruited in 2014, wasn't a good recruiting move. It was a good move in that it was a needed reaction to an obvious crisis at the position. Were we better with Trickett than we would have been without him? When the alternatives were limited to Childress and Millard, the answer is obvious. It's equally obvious that it would heve better short and long term to have recruited at least one good QB reruit with 5 years to play 4 during the 2012-14 recruiting campaingns. People who are not incredibly stupid, would not debate that point. C) Explain how William Crest, in his 2nd year at WVU, is somehow considered a third-year player at WVU Explain how my mistakenly saying 3rd instead of second, strengthens you ludicrous claim QB recruiting, retention and development has not been a failure. you're in such a rush to bash Dana that you can't even form a decently accurate thought.... What is Bill Stewart's fault.............................. Not recruiting another QB in 2009 to go with Geno Not addressing the QB attrition in 2010 prior to Dana arriving Not recruiting a competent HS QB in 2011, instead opting to hand out a "favor" to Brian Athey and his family. Because any problems under Stewart obviously did not become an on the field issue during the 2011-12 seasons and the stupid decision to go HCIW in the midst of 2011 recruiting obviously hamstringed both Stewart and Holgorsen for that class. I don't think it's fair to hold that class, in toto, against either because all the blame goes to Luck. Geno played every game both years. It is pure speculation to say that he or any other coach other than Holgorsen would have been unable to have a competent QB in place in 2015. It's not speculation to say that Holgorsen has proven unable. [/QUOTE]
Insert quotes…
Name
Post reply
Forums
West Virginia
Mountaineer Message Board
TCU has a superior roster bc of its star QB. And WVU has a better roster than in 2011 bc of depth.
Top
Bottom