I'd put Wayne Gretzky up there. Michael Phelps, also.
Probably pretty hard to find a "team" athlete that's universally liked. Because chances are, some other teams fanbase hates them. but I'd bet Derek Jeter is up there. The Manning brothers are probably up there.
Yep. Bama fans mostly hate Bo.
Phelps is a good one. I'd add Arnie, if golfers count as athletes.