Don't get me wrong. I love the fact that we are going to a decent bowl this season, but in a perfect world, we should be in the "we need to win this one to lock up a bowl" phase.
If 615dawg was in charge, there would be a playoff. But if a playoff wasn't possible. I'd get rid of 20 bowls. Yep. 20. That's the only way that you would get the bowls back to a prestige that they once had. A 6-6 team should not sniff a bowl game in my opinion. Think about it. 70 out of 120 teams will be able to say that they went to a bowl game this year. Where's the prestige in that?
Here is my plan. There should be three tiers of bowls. The BCS (5 games), 6 Tier 1 Bowl Games and 4 Tier II Bowl Games. 30 teams. 25% of the teams should be able to say they had a good enough season to make a bowl game. The BCS standings are used past the BCS games as well. Here is the breakdown.
<span style="font-weight: bold;">BCS Games</span>
BCS National Championship: The No. 1 and No. 2 teams in the BCS.
Fiesta Bowl: Big 12 Champion vs. Big East champion/at-large
Rose Bowl: Big 10 Champion vs. Pac 10 Champion
Sugar Bowl: SEC Champion vs. Big East champion/at-large
Orange Bowl: ACC Champion vs. Big East champion/at-large
The Big East has no permanent home, but rotates among the Fiesta, Sugar and Orange Bowls. The other two are guaranteed an at-large pick, that must come from the top 12 in the BCS. If a non-AQ is in the top 6 of the BCS, they must be taken as an at-large. The conference champions that end up in the NC game default their spot to an at-large spot and draft No. 1 and No. 2, respectively. Here is how it would go down with this year's current BCS/conference standings.
BCS National Championship: Oregon vs. Auburn
Fiesta Bowl: Nebraska (Big 12 champ) vs. TCU (first pick in the draft) no Big East qualifier in top 12 of BCS
Rose Bowl: Wisconsin (Big 10 champ) vs. Stanford (second pick in the draft)
Sugar Bowl: LSU (third pick in draft) vs. Boise State (fifth pick in the draft)
Orange Bowl: Virginia Tech vs. Ohio State (fourth pick in the draft)
Tier I Bowl Games. Six games. Each has one conference tie-in, based on history. Teams must come from the BCS Top 25. Note: If I were in charge, corporate sponsors would be sponsors, not bowl titles.
Citrus Bowl: Top remaining SEC team (Alabama #11) vs. at-large
Peach Bowl: Top remaining ACC team (Miami #24) vs. at-large
Cotton Bowl: Top remaining Big 12 team (Oklahoma State #10) vs. at-large
Hall of Fame (Outback for you youngens) Bowl: Top remaining Big 10 team (Michigan State #12) vs. at-large
Gator Bowl: Top remaining Big East team (no qualifier in BCS Top 25) vs. at-large
Holiday Bowl: Top remaining Pac 10 team (Arizona #22) vs. at-large
So the draft order looks (and my picks) like this:
Gator Bowl (because no Big East qualifier): Arkansas (vs. Florida State)
Peach Bowl: Oklahoma (vs. Miami)
Holiday: Missouri (vs. Arizona)
Hall of Fame: South Carolina (vs. Michigan State)
Citrus: Texas A&M (vs. Alabama)
Cotton: Iowa (vs. Oklahoma State)
Gator (regular at-large pick) : Florida State (vs. Arkansas)
Tier II Bowls. Four bowls. No tie-ins. The three BCS Top 25 teams (in this case, Nevada, Mississippi State and Utah) must be selected before anyone in the at-large pool, which includes teams ranked in either poll but not in the BCS Top 25 (Northwestern), conference champions (Pittsburgh, Central Florida, Northern Illinois, Florida International) or any FBS team with the same number of wins (7) as the lowest BCS team (Maryland, NC State, Syracuse, Michigan, Southern Miss, Tulsa, Navy, Temple, San Diego State, Air Force, Hawaii). A team cannot be picked if its conference champion has not been picked (e.g. UCF must be picked before USM or Tulsa is on the board). There are 14 teams available for 5 bowl slots.
The four Tier II Bowls are the Alamo, Sun, Liberty and Tangerine (Champs Sports) Bowls. They are randomly assigned a draft order, which rotates.
Alamo (#1 and #8 picks)
Sun (#2 and #7 picks)
Liberty (#3 and #6 picks)
Tangerine (#4 and #5 picks)
Possible draft
Alamo: Mississippi State vs. Maryland
Sun: Utah vs. Northwestern
Liberty: Nevada vs. Michigan
Tangerine: Pittsburgh vs. Central Florida
The remaining 11 bowl eligible teams (Northern Illinois, Florida International, NC State, Syracuse, Southern Miss, Tulsa, Navy, Temple, San Diego State, Air Force, Hawaii) can try again next year.
The following bowls cease to exist:
Military Bowl
Beef O Bradys Bowl
New Mexico Bowl
Compass Bowl
New Orleans Bowl
Godaddy.com Bowl
Poinsettia Bowl
Las Vegas Bowl
Armed Forces Bowl
Hawaii Bowl
Little Ceasers Pizza Bowl
TicketCity Bowl
Insight Bowl (considered heavily as a Tier II Bowl, Copper Bowl)
Fight Hunger Bowl
Pinstripe Bowl
Music City Bowl (also considered, loses on history to Liberty)
Independence Bowl
Meinike Car Care Bowl
If 615dawg was in charge, there would be a playoff. But if a playoff wasn't possible. I'd get rid of 20 bowls. Yep. 20. That's the only way that you would get the bowls back to a prestige that they once had. A 6-6 team should not sniff a bowl game in my opinion. Think about it. 70 out of 120 teams will be able to say that they went to a bowl game this year. Where's the prestige in that?
Here is my plan. There should be three tiers of bowls. The BCS (5 games), 6 Tier 1 Bowl Games and 4 Tier II Bowl Games. 30 teams. 25% of the teams should be able to say they had a good enough season to make a bowl game. The BCS standings are used past the BCS games as well. Here is the breakdown.
<span style="font-weight: bold;">BCS Games</span>
BCS National Championship: The No. 1 and No. 2 teams in the BCS.
Fiesta Bowl: Big 12 Champion vs. Big East champion/at-large
Rose Bowl: Big 10 Champion vs. Pac 10 Champion
Sugar Bowl: SEC Champion vs. Big East champion/at-large
Orange Bowl: ACC Champion vs. Big East champion/at-large
The Big East has no permanent home, but rotates among the Fiesta, Sugar and Orange Bowls. The other two are guaranteed an at-large pick, that must come from the top 12 in the BCS. If a non-AQ is in the top 6 of the BCS, they must be taken as an at-large. The conference champions that end up in the NC game default their spot to an at-large spot and draft No. 1 and No. 2, respectively. Here is how it would go down with this year's current BCS/conference standings.
BCS National Championship: Oregon vs. Auburn
Fiesta Bowl: Nebraska (Big 12 champ) vs. TCU (first pick in the draft) no Big East qualifier in top 12 of BCS
Rose Bowl: Wisconsin (Big 10 champ) vs. Stanford (second pick in the draft)
Sugar Bowl: LSU (third pick in draft) vs. Boise State (fifth pick in the draft)
Orange Bowl: Virginia Tech vs. Ohio State (fourth pick in the draft)
Tier I Bowl Games. Six games. Each has one conference tie-in, based on history. Teams must come from the BCS Top 25. Note: If I were in charge, corporate sponsors would be sponsors, not bowl titles.
Citrus Bowl: Top remaining SEC team (Alabama #11) vs. at-large
Peach Bowl: Top remaining ACC team (Miami #24) vs. at-large
Cotton Bowl: Top remaining Big 12 team (Oklahoma State #10) vs. at-large
Hall of Fame (Outback for you youngens) Bowl: Top remaining Big 10 team (Michigan State #12) vs. at-large
Gator Bowl: Top remaining Big East team (no qualifier in BCS Top 25) vs. at-large
Holiday Bowl: Top remaining Pac 10 team (Arizona #22) vs. at-large
So the draft order looks (and my picks) like this:
Gator Bowl (because no Big East qualifier): Arkansas (vs. Florida State)
Peach Bowl: Oklahoma (vs. Miami)
Holiday: Missouri (vs. Arizona)
Hall of Fame: South Carolina (vs. Michigan State)
Citrus: Texas A&M (vs. Alabama)
Cotton: Iowa (vs. Oklahoma State)
Gator (regular at-large pick) : Florida State (vs. Arkansas)
Tier II Bowls. Four bowls. No tie-ins. The three BCS Top 25 teams (in this case, Nevada, Mississippi State and Utah) must be selected before anyone in the at-large pool, which includes teams ranked in either poll but not in the BCS Top 25 (Northwestern), conference champions (Pittsburgh, Central Florida, Northern Illinois, Florida International) or any FBS team with the same number of wins (7) as the lowest BCS team (Maryland, NC State, Syracuse, Michigan, Southern Miss, Tulsa, Navy, Temple, San Diego State, Air Force, Hawaii). A team cannot be picked if its conference champion has not been picked (e.g. UCF must be picked before USM or Tulsa is on the board). There are 14 teams available for 5 bowl slots.
The four Tier II Bowls are the Alamo, Sun, Liberty and Tangerine (Champs Sports) Bowls. They are randomly assigned a draft order, which rotates.
Alamo (#1 and #8 picks)
Sun (#2 and #7 picks)
Liberty (#3 and #6 picks)
Tangerine (#4 and #5 picks)
Possible draft
Alamo: Mississippi State vs. Maryland
Sun: Utah vs. Northwestern
Liberty: Nevada vs. Michigan
Tangerine: Pittsburgh vs. Central Florida
The remaining 11 bowl eligible teams (Northern Illinois, Florida International, NC State, Syracuse, Southern Miss, Tulsa, Navy, Temple, San Diego State, Air Force, Hawaii) can try again next year.
The following bowls cease to exist:
Military Bowl
Beef O Bradys Bowl
New Mexico Bowl
Compass Bowl
New Orleans Bowl
Godaddy.com Bowl
Poinsettia Bowl
Las Vegas Bowl
Armed Forces Bowl
Hawaii Bowl
Little Ceasers Pizza Bowl
TicketCity Bowl
Insight Bowl (considered heavily as a Tier II Bowl, Copper Bowl)
Fight Hunger Bowl
Pinstripe Bowl
Music City Bowl (also considered, loses on history to Liberty)
Independence Bowl
Meinike Car Care Bowl