It would be a shame to have to watch McCluster win this thing. I just don't see how you can choose a great half of one season over 4 years of tough running and breaking every school record possible for a RB. What say you?
They are both great players. Dixon is the workhorse, and McCluster is the big play guy and multi-dimensional. I'd prefer Dixon to win for obvious reasons, but I wouldn't think Dixon would be ripped off if McCluster won.