What's your all-time favorite thread?

guerinfbfan

Senior
Sep 25, 2005
3,845
609
0
It's time to start roaring up for high school football season now that only baseball stands between us and summer practice.

I wanted to see if we could conjure up some good conversation on what some of the all time great threads have been in Edgy history.

Personally, I am always a big fan of any of the "Pizza Wars".

Let' hear what you all think!
 

Voodoo Tatum 21

All-Conference
May 18, 2016
2,970
1,765
0
The Dark side Rankings and Ramblin's Rebuttal.

Last year the DSR was like a little leprechaun - I kept searching and waiting..... and then it would appear just every once in a while.
 

MWittman

Senior
Nov 22, 2004
6,689
954
0
I wanted to see if we could conjure up some good conversation on what some of the all time great threads have been in Edgy history.

Personally, I am always a big fan of any of the "Pizza Wars".

guerin:

Glad you returned..........

I've always enjoyed the DSR, Newt's "What did We Learn" thread, and feeto's "Friday Upset Special."

You thread has inspired me to recall some of the more memorable posts I've witnessed. While it's unlikely I will list every one which I found amusing, the following immediately come to mind:

We all succumb to a spontaneous combustion moment............

From 2013, an epic post from epicbret, in which the Naz poster let loose with some colorful language after an untimely Roadrunner loss. Out of respect for epic, I won't post precisely what he wrote, but it was a call for the taunting poster to suck a fat "something" and labeling the agitator an "a-hole."

To be compared to a scoundrel the likes of fratty is a true insult.........

This one goes back over 15 years and I have forgotten which poster delivered the stinging ripost, but the unnamed poster called Dean "lower than fratboy."

Dean: This was rough...........

I believe it was 2010 when Dean described PC's anemic offense as "The involuntary flinching of a dead animal" after a loss to BR.

Mr. Bones: This hurt.........

Crossbones referring to me as M-Nit-Wittman after my inaugural post.

Another beaut from Dean............

In 2015, Dean inquired of GW fans what the kickoff time was at Doucheon Field for a playoff game.

A ramblinman mainstay to the regular outrages he confronts always makes me crack a smile........

"What a crock of crap!"

From Edgy, anytime he threatens to slap a wrist or delete a thread....

"Flushed a few turds down the toilet today."

From IG88/Golden Domer...........

The claim he graduated from ND in 1993 or 1994 and was housed in Holy Cross Hall. I responded Holy Cross Hall was torn down in 1990. He never replied.

OR the claim HF games were regularly sold out weeks prior to the game, to which one shrewd posted uploaded an image of nearly-empty HF home stands.

OR the claim he was unable to post after a HF loss over his mother's sudden diagnosis with diverticulitis.

OR his numerous claims he would never return if HF lost, only to return from the dead.

I'll get back with more as memory serves me for the purposes of this thread.
 

ignazio

All-Conference
Oct 25, 2007
3,837
2,878
0
The Richards assistant on a bender from the pressbox.

Took forever, but I finally witnessed a meltdown.
 

eagles2k3

All-Conference
Dec 26, 2003
1,922
1,212
0
Didn’t Dean post something along the lines of “the dean father”. Parody of The Godfather? I remember laughing outloud to that one.
 

Cat Box

Senior
Sep 23, 2012
1,118
718
0
For straight up football talk week in and week out I like Ignazio’s “Original Chicago Catholic League” thread.

Sadly my “Iggles” as Ignazio likes to say will no longer be part of the CCL action.
 

Cat Box

Senior
Sep 23, 2012
1,118
718
0
It's time to start roaring up for high school football season now that only baseball stands between us and summer practice.

I wanted to see if we could conjure up some good conversation on what some of the all time great threads have been in Edgy history.

Personally, I am always a big fan of any of the "Pizza Wars".

Let' hear what you all think!

Hey Guerin - I’m not gonna lie. I am disappointed you have not made a contribution to the Dumpster Fire thread.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Voodoo Tatum 21

jwarigaku

All-Conference
Jan 30, 2006
4,201
1,559
73
But Epic, Its the offseason what else do you have to do on a football page? Come on over and have some fun...I've seen your internet discovery skills at work in the past.

Ones about games and not loser fans
 

BretEpic

Heisman
Jan 27, 2005
16,866
22,189
113
But Epic, Its the offseason what else do you have to do on a football page? Come on over and have some fun...I've seen your internet discovery skills at work in the past.
I've been writing about the top ten college football players at each position for 2018, football never sleeps with ol' Bort.

I could have that fool found in five minutes, but not here. I respect edgy too much to be doxxing dudes on his board.
 

Cross Bones

All-Conference
Aug 19, 2001
52,877
3,952
113
Hahahaha. Forgot about that. He was fiending indeed
I was having too much fun and didn't realize he went full loon until the season was over a couple weeks after the thread. Then he left and never returned. It was stunning to me because he was a really good poster till that point.
 

Cross Bones

All-Conference
Aug 19, 2001
52,877
3,952
113
What happened there?

Bones trolled him to Bolivian

He was a District 99 employee, low key, and after my Raiders put a prolific beating on my DGS Mustangs in the playoffs something in him just snapped and his post game write-up (which were awesome every week) was filled with vitriol and backhanded compliments along with a doubt that they could defeat the RedHawk from the DVC the following week in the semi-final. As fate would have it we had Bailey. I went back to the thread after the Loyola game to address some things and he had a meltdown and left. Shame, I think I can speak for everyone when I say we enjoyed his commentary.