What's your Top 5 all time TV comedies. & your 5 most overrated TV comedies.

wildcatwelder_rivals

Well-known member
Jul 28, 2006
11,162
2,177
113
Seinfeld
Honeymooners
Cheers
Andy Griffith
Carol Burnett
Soap
Newhart (Both shows, but the original is the best)
Beverly Hillbillies
All in the Family
Taxi...should have put it in, one of the very best, IMO.



Over-rated:
Two Broke Girls
Friends
Modern Family
Cosby
Big Bang
 

Kooky Kats

New member
Aug 17, 2002
25,741
15,702
0
1) Seinfeld
2) The Office
3) SouthPark
4) the Simpsons
5) The Munsters (best show ever when stoned)

Honorable Mention: Cops
 
  • Like
Reactions: TortElvisII

mhroe1984

New member
Dec 16, 2007
14,060
1,507
0
Favorites...
1. Fresh Prince
2. The Simpsons
3. Married with Children (Al Bundy is an American hero who scored 4 touchdowns in a high school football game!)
4. South Park
5. The Office (first 4 seasons were great but it kinda sucked after that)

Completely and Totally overrated...(in no particular order)
- How I met your Mother (just awful and not remotely funny)
- 2 Broke Girls (see explanation for HIMYM above)
- Friends
- Andy Griffith (maybe that's what passed as comedy in the 60s and 70s but what I've seen of that show is horrible)
- MASH (same explanation for Andy Griffith)
 

CatCall

Member
May 22, 2002
917
32
28
Top 5:

The Office (British version) - A pure treat

Cheers – Mostly confined to the bar and still managed to be consistently fresh and funny

Andy Griffith – (B&W episodes) Barney/Otis/Floyd all classic characters and Andy just makes you feel better

Seinfeld – If only for “The Contest”

Modern Family – Best writing out there now



Overrated: I watched but thinking back I have issues with…

M*A*S*H – Just got stale and preachy

Friends- Amusing but not always funny

Married with Children – Groundbreaking but almost as many misses as hits on comedy

Two and a Half Men – Really? I watched a few but not sure why I watched any

Will & Grace – Once was enough
 

UpstateNYCat

New member
Jul 4, 2012
2,931
276
0
Cheers
Seinfeld
Barney Miller
Taxi
TAGS

HM: Newhart, Carol Burnet, MTM, MASH, AITF, Wings, SOAP, Rosanne,many many more I'm sure I'm missing.

Overrated?

Cosby - just never cared for it.
 

TortElvisII

Active member
May 7, 2010
51,228
6,767
66
Favorites...
1. Fresh Prince
2. The Simpsons
3. Married with Children (Al Bundy is an American hero who scored 4 touchdowns in a high school football game!)
4. South Park
5. The Office (first 4 seasons were great but it kinda sucked after that)

Completely and Totally overrated...(in no particular order)
- How I met your Mother (just awful and not remotely funny)
- 2 Broke Girls (see explanation for HIMYM above)
- Friends
- Andy Griffith (maybe that's what passed as comedy in the 60s and 70s but what I've seen of that show is horrible)
- MASH (same explanation for Andy Griffith)

Fresh Prince is funnier than Barney Fife? You have a bright future.
 

Kooky Kats

New member
Aug 17, 2002
25,741
15,702
0
Cops: Sweaty naked dude on PCP in North Philly Cuts and Fades barbershop was the most hilarious broadcasted moment in the history of electricity. 4 Philly cops wrestle him down and he gets out of cuffs somehow and Broncs off officers like ragdolls.
Put it in the paper!!!!
 

Kooky Kats

New member
Aug 17, 2002
25,741
15,702
0
Cops: Sweaty naked dude on PCP in North Philly Cuts and Fades barbershop was the most hilarious broadcasted moment in the history of electricity. 4 Philly cops wrestle him down and he gets out of cuffs somehow and Broncs off officers like ragdolls.
Put it in the paper!!!!
Christ my memory is good. enjoy.

 

rautry2

New member
Jan 3, 2017
843
177
0
1. Friends
2. Sanford and Son
3. Seinfeld
4. Drake and Josh
5. Beverly Hillbillies
 

jockstrap_mcgee

New member
Jan 22, 2009
1,354
913
0
I realize this is a generational thing but no mention of these shows at all in this thread is a travesty:

Community
Arrested development
 
  • Like
Reactions: tommyg4uk

BlueRunner11

New member
Mar 26, 2011
11,563
2,370
0
1. The Office
2. Curb
3. Party Down (not Party Down South)
4. Impractical Jokers
5. King of Queens

Not any particular order.
 
Feb 24, 2009
3,807
555
0
I realize this is a generational thing but no mention of these shows at all in this thread is a travesty:

Community
Arrested development
Best:

Seinfeld
Arrested Development
WKRP in Cincinnati
30 Rock
News Radio

Always Sunny
Curb
Broad City
Community (Sans final season)
Comedy Bang Bang

NewsRadio
Arrested Development
Seinfeld
The Office (before Pam and Jim got married)
Curb Your Enthusiasm

Overrated:
Two Broke Girls (I mean what the **** is this???)
HIMYM

Curb Your Enthusiasm
Beavis & Butthead
Trailer Park Boys
South Park
Arrested Development
Seinfeld

Overrated:

Everything Else
:eyes::100points::zzz:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Get Buckets

larry the cable guy

New member
Apr 4, 2006
7,152
635
0
I love The Office but it wasn't as good after Steve Carrell left.

I can't believe that nobody has Cops in their top 5. There is nothing funnier than a crack ho being tazed.
 

Chuck Lorre

New member
Jan 7, 2016
39
19
0
Overrated....



My assistant brought this **** talking circle J to my attention.

I'd comment further if I wasn't so pressed for time to finish packing for my hunting expedition. What am I hunting? Well...when you're rich, you can hunt anything.

Me and a few of my buddies from the studios have a nice little weekend planned in Laos. There's this "company" that gathers derelicts, homeless, and other miscreants for my friends and I to track and kill for sport. We've been told they almost never use innocents....was very important to me when shopping around for the best package and ultimately tipped the scale to them.

We're on the beginner's package this time because I have some noobs coming along, but they have such a great plethora of options. You can pre-equip the "game" with 5 Xanax and a nerf bat if you're a *****, all the way up to crystal meth and machetes for the true sportsmen.

Anywho, lots of love to all of my haters. Wish me luck! XOXO
 

Cawood86_rivals

New member
Feb 20, 2005
36,711
3,212
0
Andy Griffith Show
Cheers
Seinfeld
Cosby Show
The Office

Overrated
MASH
Anything Chuck Lorre does now
Mary Tyler Moore
 

CastleRubric

New member
Nov 11, 2011
5,854
601
0
Top 5 TV comedies

1. All in the family
2. Sanford & son
3. The Andy Griffith show
4. In living color
5. Married with children

5 most overrated comedies

1. M.A.S.H.
2. M.A.S.H.
3. M.A.S.H.
4. M.A,S,H.
5. M.A.S.H.


I'm going to suck at this but the idea is interesting -- so here goes

Top 5 Funny Ones (no particular order)

1) Frasier
2) Mad TV
3) Raising Hope
4) The Office
5) Parks & Recreation
Honorable Mention : In Living Color

5 Most Overrated - I think a LOT of TV is overrated so I generally just don't watch it much -- so this part will be hard....I'll go based on what I've heard others say / not necessarily whether or not I've spent a lot of time watching these ...

1) 30D Rock
2) Cheers
3) 3 1/2 Men Always looked like the suck
4) George Ramos?? whatever his damn name is -- not funny
5) Different F'ing Strokes
 
May 29, 2001
19,228
1,483
0
Top 5:
The Andy Griffith Show
Seinfeld
Family Guy
The Dick Van Dyke Show
The Beverly Hillbillies

Overrated 5:
MASH
Arrested Development
Two and a Half Men
The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air
30 Rock