Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Volatility_rivals135605" data-source="post: 131108865" data-attributes="member: 1476288">You can have an Elite11 talent QB on a H.S. team that has zero talent.&nbsp; Having other D1 talent or D2 talent can heavily determine a QB's stats.Which is why its difficult to judge based on stats alone.&nbsp; How was his OL, how was his RB &amp; WR's??&nbsp; Dropped passes, wrong routes, DL rush, so many variables that are less likely to cause such a decline from yr to yr.How did he perform with other D1 WR's?&nbsp; If you are 1 of the 20 invites, considering the detailed evaluation that goes into the selection process, majority not based on H.S. stats or offer list, I would think a QB is/should be a 4 star.Same goes with a RB &amp; WR, you can be a 5 star WR(Talent wise) in HS, but if you dont have a QB to get the ball to you, your stats are going to be crap.I place more weight on talent &amp; competition evals performed by experienced professionals(not sports writers) then HS stats or offer lists.. Obviously GG will have his chance to shine and prove his quality, its going to be a good time watching him perform in Morgantown</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Volatility_rivals135605, post: 131108865, member: 1476288"] You can have an Elite11 talent QB on a H.S. team that has zero talent. Having other D1 talent or D2 talent can heavily determine a QB's stats. Which is why its difficult to judge based on stats alone. How was his OL, how was his RB & WR's?? Dropped passes, wrong routes, DL rush, so many variables that are less likely to cause such a decline from yr to yr. How did he perform with other D1 WR's? If you are 1 of the 20 invites, considering the detailed evaluation that goes into the selection process, majority not based on H.S. stats or offer list, I would think a QB is/should be a 4 star. Same goes with a RB & WR, you can be a 5 star WR(Talent wise) in HS, but if you dont have a QB to get the ball to you, your stats are going to be crap. I place more weight on talent & competition evals performed by experienced professionals(not sports writers) then HS stats or offer lists.. Obviously GG will have his chance to shine and prove his quality, its going to be a good time watching him perform in Morgantown [/QUOTE]

Name