Why is Indiana So Good

broken record

Senior
Jul 9, 2025
284
456
63
Yesterday more than any game I was able to really understand fully why Cignetti has accomplished so much in just two seasons. There is a lot going on here but the recipe isn't that complicated. It's just that coaches don't do the small things necessary to win.
1) Team Speed: Indiana has speed on defense, at running back, and just about everywhere. The closing speed of the defense was pointed out during the game on a pass completion by OSU. Fast guys on defense mean that one guy can miss and another is right there to make the tackle. Speed is the one thing you cannot coach.
2) Fundamentals: Fundamentals. They weren't perfect, but they don't make many mistakes. No fumbles, few penalties, always making the tackle and executing the plays at full speed without hesitation. This is 100% coaching.
3) Team Before the Player: This is the big one. Most of these guys with the exception of Mendoza aren't stars. A lot of these guys were overlooked as recruits and don't get a lot of attention nationally. They don't have egos and don't act like they are bigger than the team. They do their jobs at 100% effort and fight to win every 1-1 battle. They also don't seem the least bit concerned about losing Mendoza, Sarrat, or anyone else. A program is bigger than individuals.
Few of the starters are probably Indiana natives. They are the best that Cignetti can play at the position. There is no concern for feelings.
4) Belief in Themselves: They aren't overawed by whoever line up against them. They don't care if OSU has a bunch of future first round draft picks. They play hard and fast and execute. They expect to win.
5) Toughness and Endurance: I saw OSU wilting as the game went along. OSU expects whoever they play to give up and quit. Indiana kept punching and it was OSU that began to wilt. Again, Indiana has some guys that will be high draft picks and Mendoza could be number one, but compared to OSU they have far fewer stars. That's again a result of coaching and great work in the gym and in training.
 
  • Like
Reactions: oldjar07

Man Woman & Child

All-Conference
Dec 31, 2003
3,214
1,066
113
I remember being told we were getting a lot of that at Rhule's introductory press conference...

Mr Mayor Waiting GIF by NBC
 

ADV88

Junior
Oct 26, 2018
1,860
392
83
3) Team Before the Player: This is the big one. Most of these guys with the exception of Mendoza aren't stars. A lot of these guys were overlooked as recruits and don't get a lot of attention nationally. They don't have egos and don't act like they are bigger than the team. They do their jobs at 100% effort and fight to win every 1-1 battle. They also don't seem the least bit concerned about losing Mendoza, Sarrat, or anyone else. A program is bigger than individuals.

Lock the entire team in a room, take all phones and devices away and make them watch the Indiana post game interviews of this for like an Hour... Then, have Rebekah Allick & DBK come in and give them fellas a stern conversation of what this means and looks like...
 
  • Like
Reactions: DrAlan_Grant

RedCap

Sophomore
Jun 1, 2022
75
170
33
Yesterday more than any game I was able to really understand fully why Cignetti has accomplished so much in just two seasons. There is a lot going on here but the recipe isn't that complicated. It's just that coaches don't do the small things necessary to win.
1) Team Speed: Indiana has speed on defense, at running back, and just about everywhere. The closing speed of the defense was pointed out during the game on a pass completion by OSU. Fast guys on defense mean that one guy can miss and another is right there to make the tackle. Speed is the one thing you cannot coach.
2) Fundamentals: Fundamentals. They weren't perfect, but they don't make many mistakes. No fumbles, few penalties, always making the tackle and executing the plays at full speed without hesitation. This is 100% coaching.
3) Team Before the Player: This is the big one. Most of these guys with the exception of Mendoza aren't stars. A lot of these guys were overlooked as recruits and don't get a lot of attention nationally. They don't have egos and don't act like they are bigger than the team. They do their jobs at 100% effort and fight to win every 1-1 battle. They also don't seem the least bit concerned about losing Mendoza, Sarrat, or anyone else. A program is bigger than individuals.
Few of the starters are probably Indiana natives. They are the best that Cignetti can play at the position. There is no concern for feelings.
4) Belief in Themselves: They aren't overawed by whoever line up against them. They don't care if OSU has a bunch of future first round draft picks. They play hard and fast and execute. They expect to win.
5) Toughness and Endurance: I saw OSU wilting as the game went along. OSU expects whoever they play to give up and quit. Indiana kept punching and it was OSU that began to wilt. Again, Indiana has some guys that will be high draft picks and Mendoza could be number one, but compared to OSU they have far fewer stars. That's again a result of coaching and great work in the gym and in training.
It boils down to one thing above all: coaching matters.
 

oldjar07

All-Conference
Oct 25, 2009
9,458
2,000
113
Yesterday more than any game I was able to really understand fully why Cignetti has accomplished so much in just two seasons. There is a lot going on here but the recipe isn't that complicated. It's just that coaches don't do the small things necessary to win.
1) Team Speed: Indiana has speed on defense, at running back, and just about everywhere. The closing speed of the defense was pointed out during the game on a pass completion by OSU. Fast guys on defense mean that one guy can miss and another is right there to make the tackle. Speed is the one thing you cannot coach.
2) Fundamentals: Fundamentals. They weren't perfect, but they don't make many mistakes. No fumbles, few penalties, always making the tackle and executing the plays at full speed without hesitation. This is 100% coaching.
3) Team Before the Player: This is the big one. Most of these guys with the exception of Mendoza aren't stars. A lot of these guys were overlooked as recruits and don't get a lot of attention nationally. They don't have egos and don't act like they are bigger than the team. They do their jobs at 100% effort and fight to win every 1-1 battle. They also don't seem the least bit concerned about losing Mendoza, Sarrat, or anyone else. A program is bigger than individuals.
Few of the starters are probably Indiana natives. They are the best that Cignetti can play at the position. There is no concern for feelings.
4) Belief in Themselves: They aren't overawed by whoever line up against them. They don't care if OSU has a bunch of future first round draft picks. They play hard and fast and execute. They expect to win.
5) Toughness and Endurance: I saw OSU wilting as the game went along. OSU expects whoever they play to give up and quit. Indiana kept punching and it was OSU that began to wilt. Again, Indiana has some guys that will be high draft picks and Mendoza could be number one, but compared to OSU they have far fewer stars. That's again a result of coaching and great work in the gym and in training.
I've been watching Indiana for longer than the championship game, and this is pretty much spot on. The guys they recruit may not be rated highly, but they have good size and speed at every position. And Cignetti and staff coach them up to make plays.
 

oldjar07

All-Conference
Oct 25, 2009
9,458
2,000
113
The answer is mark cuban he can buy any player they want
Guarantee our NIL spending is higher. Dylan Raiola makes more than Mendoza. According to 247, our transfer portal ranking was higher, and we brought in players like Dane Key, Nwaneri, Pritchett, and Spindler, averaging about a million each. NU also makes a generous outlay to the entire roster.
 

konaki

All-Conference
Oct 18, 2002
11,599
2,946
113
After watching those two schools play last night and especially Indiana and it's DL it's wonder any team will beat them this year. That team looked like an NFL roster ready squad, the power and speed was something I haven't seen in a long time in college football. I know Cignetti said after he lost last year he had to get some players from the NIL to win the Championship or something like that and I'll give him credit he's a man of his words.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dylman

konaki

All-Conference
Oct 18, 2002
11,599
2,946
113
Funny isn't it, OSU may not be the top dog in the BIG for a while, who thought they would ever see the day. This goes to show you that if just one man has enough money to spend on a program and the school gets the right man to run the team they can make the jump. Nothings impossible it seems, these are strange days.
 

TouchdownTom

Junior
Jul 10, 2025
205
361
63
It's because Cignetti has a plan and he is laser focused on it. His mindset is that he is going to win no matter what and doesn't accept excuses. And he doesn't hire coaches because they are related to a five star recruit or old friend. No way he puts up with our underperforming coaches for more than a year. He has the killer instinct you need to win as well and the team takes on that mindset.

Contrast that with Rhule. Nobody really knows what his plan is. He talks about what he wants to do, but his actions don't match what he preaches so that's why they have so much trouble executing anything. Or other coaches even Ryan Day being too conservative at times. I'm sure Cignatti also holds all his players responsible and preaches fundamentals a lot more than we do. It's not hard to build a culture of winning when you are committed to a plan and not scared to execute it even when people ridicule you like when Cig said to google him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Anon1752071136

Jamsand88

Sophomore
Jan 14, 2004
847
177
43
Just need to bring back our nutritionalist from 80’s and 90’s.. start serving up roids/HGH/coke/adderal to our line and get them back in the game!
Stop salivating over other teams success and worrying about their failures.. Nebraska needs to hit flush and get back to what made the Big Red Machine successful! 😉😂
 

TouchdownTom

Junior
Jul 10, 2025
205
361
63
So coaching doesn't matter, obviously since you support Fraud
Sounds like Baxter is just jealous of Indiana at this point. Yeah without the portal and nil, Indiana wouldn't be as great, but even without it, Cig would still out coach and embarrass Rhule.
 

huskernation77

Heisman
Jan 10, 2007
159,985
26,508
113
Funny isn't it, OSU may not be the top dog in the BIG for a while, who thought they would ever see the day. This goes to show you that if just one man has enough money to spend on a program and the school gets the right man to run the team they can make the jump. Nothings impossible it seems, these are strange days.
Day is an average coach. Imo
 

broken record

Senior
Jul 9, 2025
284
456
63
I don't know who has more or spent more, but there's no doubt who used it better. And it wasn't us. I mean, you're not really going to try to claim their success is solely due to how much they outspent everyone else on their 2-3 star roster are you?
We spent money and it helped some. But the overall package wasn't very good. Indiana's ROI was much higher. Again, just paying for players doesn't mean they are going to play hard, be coachable, and even fit a system. I look at all the blathering preseason interviews and videos of guys who never played a snap at NU and hearing them all praise each other and I think we need to toughen up the culture a bit. Our guys may start well but they don't finish. They feel special from the get go. Emmett is the one guy I can point to that kept his mouth shut, worked his *** off, and earned his stripes.
 

broken record

Senior
Jul 9, 2025
284
456
63
It's because Cignetti has a plan and he is laser focused on it. His mindset is that he is going to win no matter what and doesn't accept excuses. And he doesn't hire coaches because they are related to a five star recruit or old friend. No way he puts up with our underperforming coaches for more than a year. He has the killer instinct you need to win as well and the team takes on that mindset.

Contrast that with Rhule. Nobody really knows what his plan is. He talks about what he wants to do, but his actions don't match what he preaches so that's why they have so much trouble executing anything. Or other coaches even Ryan Day being too conservative at times. I'm sure Cignatti also holds all his players responsible and preaches fundamentals a lot more than we do. It's not hard to build a culture of winning when you are committed to a plan and not scared to execute it even when people ridicule you like when Cig said to google him.
This is a huge part of it. The NU fan base and 'tradition' element has also been a dead weight on the program. There are STILL fans pining over Solich and Pelini. Move the F on. When many of our recent coaches were hired they had to tread lightly so as not to offend the Husker OGs like Osborne or they go run out of town. We need to treat our past like Alabama or Notre Dame treats its past. They live in the here and now and don't say bring back the Bear Bryant or Knute Rockne eras. The one good thing that happened after Frost was fired is Osborne finally let go.
Cignetti can create his own machine without worrying about all of the BS.
 

huskat

Senior
Jan 27, 2005
2,531
501
113
Indiana wouldn’t have won the big 10 without the portal and nil
I am so sick of reading this on here, it doesn't matter. That is like saying Nebraska wouldn't have won their championships without having 85 scholarships. Irrelevant because so does everyone else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: oldjar07

dinglefritz

Heisman
Jan 14, 2011
51,347
12,780
78
This is a huge part of it. The NU fan base and 'tradition' element has also been a dead weight on the program. There are STILL fans pining over Solich and Pelini. Move the F on. When many of our recent coaches were hired they had to tread lightly so as not to offend the Husker OGs like Osborne or they go run out of town. We need to treat our past like Alabama or Notre Dame treats its past. They live in the here and now and don't say bring back the Bear Bryant or Knute Rockne eras. The one good thing that happened after Frost was fired is Osborne finally let go.
Cignetti can create his own machine without worrying about all of the BS.
I think the blame for our fan base’s obsession over Solich and Pelini is long past worn off. Run the ball guy really has little to do with those eras anymore. Rhule isn’t getting blamed for that. Tom has supported Matt publicly. People are just disappointed with the product this far.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Baxter48

dinglefritz

Heisman
Jan 14, 2011
51,347
12,780
78
I am so sick of reading this on here, it doesn't matter. That is like saying Nebraska wouldn't have won their championships without having 85 scholarships. Irrelevant because so does everyone else.
It’s probably true but the fact remains that we went shopping in the same portal. I think it’s pretty obvious that Cignetti’s defense was better than ours and a good chunk of that was his coaching. It’s also clear to me that he got better QB play from his senior portal QB than we got from Dylan as a sophomore.
 

itseasyas1-2-3

All-Conference
Sep 6, 2021
9,805
2,137
113
I think the blame for our fan base’s obsession over Solich and Pelini is long past worn off. Run the ball guy really has little to do with those eras anymore. Rhule isn’t getting blamed for that. Tom has supported Matt publicly. People are just disappointed with the product this far.
All I've ever heard TO say about Matt is, "Matt's a really hard worker."
That's not much of an endorsement.
 

itseasyas1-2-3

All-Conference
Sep 6, 2021
9,805
2,137
113
It’s probably true but the fact remains that we went shopping in the same portal. I think it’s pretty obvious that Cignetti’s defense was better than ours and a good chunk of that was his coaching. It’s also clear to me that he got better QB play from his senior portal QB than we got from Dylan as a sophomore.
Mendoza is a JR.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dinglefritz

SuperBigFan69

All-Conference
Apr 17, 2021
4,307
3,906
113
I think all the points listed are solid except for that "they were not heavily recruited" stuff.

Look, generally speaking the team with the best players and the biggest recruits will end up winning it all, I know we all love the old "Look at this small town kid who no one wanted" story...but it just really isn't that true.

I would rather swing and miss with "studs" than swing and miss with "Johnny Walkon"
 

itseasyas1-2-3

All-Conference
Sep 6, 2021
9,805
2,137
113
I watched the entire game last night, both are outstanding teams. If they played 10 times this year, each team would win 5 times and barring crazy things, they would all be very tight games. Indiana just refused to quit.
A dream matchup would be IND v. GA. Those are the two most difficult teams in college football to beat.
Two junkyard dogs who refuse to give up that bone and will fight you to the bitter end to win.

Not necessarily the two best teams in college, just the two hardest to knock out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dinglefritz

TrueBigRedFan

All-American
Jun 29, 2004
12,550
5,146
113
The answer is mark cuban he can buy any player they want
Good answer, he can. I don’t know much about Indiana, how many 4-5 Star players do they have? And are they playing mostly Portal Players?

I honestly don’t know the answer to that.
 

inthedeed

Junior
Mar 28, 2009
6,917
313
83
talent recognition has been a major problem for years. major misses and failure to even recruit future NFL players is obvious. the numbers of average players vs above average players I think is the great hidden failure of Nebraska football. talent evaluators from high school, Jr college, transfers, and nil have failed the program massively. our so called gurus need to retire and stfu.