Will James' preseason baseball notes (comprehensive)

Will James

Redshirt
Feb 11, 2013
1,342
0
0
I expect that we will have a similar record as last year in the SEC. Our schedule is tougher this time around. I wish there wasn't so much hype around this team and I really hope it doesn't go to our player's heads that they are something special. We are not the 5th best team in America, most of the other publications have it right near 15. And that is generous in my opinion (sorry Engie) We need to have the underdog mentality. "We're back!" No the 17 we are not. Do it on the field and get us back before making such a arrogant marketing campaign.

The biggest obstacle to success this year will come from the same place it did last year, John Cohen. He said that this is the fastest team he's ever had so he better let them steal some 17ing bags and not throw away outs at the plate. We have talented hitters and experienced hitters this year so it's time for Cohen to take the training wheels off and let them do their thing.

The ******** focus on walks and manufacturing led to a frustratingly high amount of strikeouts. Last year we looked like scared pussies taking strike 3 because Cohen gets off to walks. The bunting last year was out of control as well. First off we sucked at getting them down and at least 15 times either popped out or wasted 2 strikes trying to bunt and had a wasted AB. It is way too easy to get on base in college ball to give away outs like Cohen loved to do.

"Leadoff man gets on, next man bunts him over to second" - This cannot be tolerated, especially early in games like last year. Engie and C34 can attest because they obviously carry weight on here. We cost ourselves probably 20+ runs last season doing this.

Renfroe, Rea, and Frazier combined for 16 sac bunts last year. If they combine for more than 3 in 2013 I will be irate.

MSDawg34 said:
I looked at the innings which our leadoff man got on first base in conference play for analysis. I looked at what the outcomes where when we immediately followed a leadoff one-bagger (Hit, HBP, BB, IBB, etc) man on 1st 0 out. I knew it was bad, but nothing like this.

With man on 1st, 0 out. WE BUNT
Occurrences: 26
Score a run: 6
# of runs : 6

We bunted in that position 26 times, only scoring 6 times, only one run each time. That is 23% which is off the charts bad yielding .2 runs/inning.

With a man on 1st, 0 out. WE DONT BUNT
Occurrences: 66
Score a run: 36
# of runs: 77

We didnt bunt in that situation 66 times, scoring 36 times, with many occurrences of multiple runs. That is 55% of innings we score yielding 1.12 runs/inning, A FULL RUN HIGHER than bunting in the same situation.

55% > 23% of innings we score
1.12 > .2 runs per inning

The quote is stats from last year's conference play. We benefited from historically great bullpen play. There is no way that we match that this year. Holder will not have a 0.00 ERA again and we do not have a horse like Stratton that we can rely on scoring 2 runs and winning a ball game. With normal or above average pen play last year we lose 5 more games minimum. The offense has to take pressure off of the pitchers this year and that starts and ends with Cohen taking pressure off the offense.

Just play the damn game and we will be successful, host, and make our run to Omaha, we have the talent. It's up to John Cohen to not 17 it up.

Frazier- can he match last season? We need him to
Bradford- One of our most important players. We need him to hit >.300 to set up our big bats. Cohen please dont use him to sac
Renfroe- Ive been waiting 3 years for the player MD saw this summer. It's time man, step up and lead.
Rea- Not buying the hype yet.. Show me what you can do at the plate big man we need you to produce
Porter- Would like to see more doubles (9 last year) Score Rea's fat *** from 1st like in the scrimmage
Robson- we'll see... its his first go around in SEC ball. Should never be bunted over..... ever
Norris- If you can break out our offense could really be special.
Slauter- You're here for D, leadership, and game management. Anything you give us and improve from 2012 is a plus

While we should win most pre-SEC games, it's definitely a time for competition. If Flair beats Norris out, great! If Hann explodes, find him a spot in the lineup! Detz/Britton/Hann may the best man win the 2B job.

Same for SP- the best 3 should start. Kendall has looked shaky early on and if he loses his weekend job so be it. Throw on Wed and earn it back. Nobody is safe as far as weekend SP go.

Bullpen- A+ keep up the good work.

Good to be back on the pack, look to me for zero sunshine pumping baseball postings as this is the one sport where any criticism can lead to feathers getting ruffled on here it seems. Flame away.
 

Railin Jemmye

Redshirt
Oct 29, 2012
1,937
0
0
Flame away I will.....

Hmmm, where should I start:

I wish there wasn't so much hype around this team and I really hope it doesn't go to our player's heads that they are something special.........We need to have the underdog mentality. "We're back!" No the 17 we are not. Do it on the field and get us back before making such a arrogant marketing campaign.

This is MSU baseball, not football. **** being the underdog, we've been here before. #1 sign that you don't know much about MSU baseball history. The marketing is great. You're the one who suffers from false arrogance.

The biggest obstacle to success this year will come from the same place it did last year, John Cohen. He said that this is the fastest team he's ever had so he better let them steal some 17ing bags and not throw away outs at the plate. We have talented hitters and experienced hitters this year so it's time for Cohen to take the training wheels off and let them do their thing.

I'll give you this, but the facts are that he was trying to manufacture runs with limited offensive production. Logic dictates he'll step out the way a little bit more this year, as he has every year as talent has increased.

The ******** focus on walks and manufacturing led to a frustratingly high amount of strikeouts. Last year we looked like scared pussies taking strike 3 because Cohen gets off to walks. The bunting last year was out of control as well. First off we sucked at getting them down and at least 15 times either popped out or wasted 2 strikes trying to bunt and had a wasted AB. It is way too easy to get on base in college ball to give away outs like Cohen loved to do.

We bitched about this during the Polk II Error, now we don't want to play small ball? Again, as talent increases, so does the so-called frustration that people who don't know anything about baseball seem to portray. #2 sign that you don't know **** about MSU baseball.

Engie and C34 can attest because they obviously carry weight on here.

Bwa ha ha ha ha. Just because you post ******** over and over does not mean you carry weight.

The quote is stats from last year's conference play. We benefited from historically great bullpen play. There is no way that we match that this year. Holder will not have a 0.00 ERA again and we do not have a horse like Stratton that we can rely on scoring 2 runs and winning a ball game. With normal or above average pen play last year we lose 5 more games minimum. The offense has to take pressure off of the pitchers this year and that starts and ends with Cohen taking pressure off the offense.

Safe to say the offense will take pressure off the defense. And no we don't have A horse, we have a few of them. No one knew Stratton was going to break out last year after an awful So. season, let the other guys do their thing.

Detz/Britton/Hann may the best man win the 2B job.

#3. Pirtle is widely known to be the guy at 2B at this point.

look to me for zero sunshine pumping

Seems like this is some type of badge of honor on this board now. Fine, I'll look you for that, you look to me to routinely call out yours, patdogs, rugbdawgs, and everybody else's horseshit opinions in regards to our baseball team.

Welcome to the board.
 

maroonmania

All-Conference
Feb 23, 2008
11,389
1,165
113
In my mind there is no doubt this team SHOULD be significantly better than last year. Don't know how that translates to record since as you mentioned our schedule, especially in conference, is tougher. Really to me the only question mark is finding a dominant pitcher or two. We know we have a lot of good pitchers but I don't know that we have a dominant one. But if people remember, in his Sophomore year, Stratton was not only NOT dominant but he was downright bad. I have faith that one or two of the guys will step up this year and be really good even if not quite Stratton level from last year. On offense, we have to remember we did what we did last year primarily with first year players at nearly every position. It was amazing to me that we won what we did playing an injured Rea at 1st, an error prone true freshman 2nd baseman in Britton and a 3rd baseman totally out of position in Frost. Then we had to move Renfroe to CF because of losing Bradford and play Henderson and Fullerton, neither of whom were really ready in LF. NO WAY we can be anything but better by having more experienced, healthier versions of Rea, Norris and Bradford plus another year of experience for Frazier, Slaughter, and Renfroe. Then throw in more options at 2nd base and then either a Henderson, Robson or Fullerton in LF and things look much better. And that doesn't even consider some of the other new guys available like Nick Flair, Daniel Garner, Kyle Hann etc. Just don't see how in the field and at the plate we can be anything but significantly improved this year over 2012. Should be a fun year and hopefully we have better luck on the injury front than we had last year.
 
Last edited:

Will James

Redshirt
Feb 11, 2013
1,342
0
0
Hmmm, where should I start:



This is MSU baseball, not football. **** being the underdog, we've been here before. #1 sign that you don't know much about MSU baseball history. The marketing is great. You're the one who suffers from false arrogance. These guys haven't been anywhere. Yes that proves I don't know **** because I don't want inflated egos.

I'll give you this, but the facts are that he was trying to manufacture runs with limited offensive production. No he limited the production even further as the stats clearly show. The regional was an embarrassment. Logic dictates he'll step out the way a little bit more this year, as he has every year as talent has increased.

We bitched about this during the Polk II Error, now we don't want to play small ball? Again, as talent increases, so does the so-called frustration that people who don't know anything about baseball seem to portray. #2 sign that you don't know **** about MSU baseball. This literally makes no sense. Meds Im sure. Cohen's small ball goes against all baseball wisdom.

Bwa ha ha ha ha. Just because you post ******** over and over does not mean you carry weight. Let's have a poll of reputation between you and Engie. I can tell you what the outcome will be.

Safe to say the offense will take pressure off the defense. Maybe, we'll see And no we don't have A horse, we have a few of them. Maybe, we'll see. No one knew Stratton was going to break out last year after an awful So. season, let the other guys do their thing.

#3. Pirtle is widely known to be the guy at 2B at this point. Competition will determine that. Detz has looked good the times Ive seen.

Seems like this is some type of badge of honor on this board now. Fine, I'll look you for that, you look to me to routinely call out yours, patdogs, rugbdawgs, and everybody else's horseshit opinions in regards to our baseball team Please do, should be fun watching you make a fool out of yourself.. some more
 

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
Glad you went ahead and defined your new alterego**

Just because you are correct sabermetrically about bunting does not then turn you into any sort of a baseball guru. Can you please link me to where I said we were a "top 5" team in the country? No, you can't. Because I haven't. I've held, consistently, that we deserve to be somewhere between #8 and #12 -- Exactly where we are in composite rankings. The rest of your ranking rant can best be described as total gibberish.

You've missed the entire point of why Cohen played ball that way last year, but that is not surprising to me. Let's ignore all of our injuries and youth last season -- which was a DRASTICALLY different style than we played in Cohen's first 3 years, when offensive production WAS NOT A PROBLEM(it was pitching holding us back). Fear not, bunting will be a smaller part of our gameplan this year -- because we've got at least 7 or 8 guys that CAN and WILL swing it -- and at least 5 or 6 that can and will swipe bases. If you can steal second, you don't need to bunt the guy over. Cohen quit taking chances with stealing bases last year because of our injury situation -- and a slide into second is statistically one of the most likely places for an injury to occur in baseball(behind sliding into home -- which happens much, much less often).

The worst part of all this related to your post? Goat is traditionally a pretty good baseball poster...
 
Last edited:

Philly Dawg

Heisman
Oct 6, 2012
16,378
11,076
113
If you listen to the baseball statistics guys, you'd only steal if you can do it successfully 70% of the time and only bunt very rarely in late game situations. I tend to agree with this and think we left runs on the bases last year.

The guys projecting us very high are making some big assumptions in our favor, including that newcomers such as Pirtle and Robson will put up big stats. But the pitching staff appears to be legit, and our defense will be stout again, so its not a stretch to expect us to field a very solid team.
 

BiscuitEater

Redshirt
Aug 29, 2009
4,178
0
36
Did Cohen ...

This literally makes no sense. Meds Im sure. Cohen's small ball goes against all baseball wisdom.

Winning an outright SEC Baseball Championship at Kentucky with his 'small ball' approach go against "all baseball wisdom?" This is the same Univ of KY where students don't even know or care that they have a baseball team.

I kinda thought we hired him to Win baseball games. I'm frankly more interested in the 'winning' part and less in the 'how' part.
 

Will James

Redshirt
Feb 11, 2013
1,342
0
0
Glad you went ahead and defined your new alterego*Glad you caught on

Just because you are correct sabermetrically about bunting does not then turn you into any sort of a baseball guru Didn't say it did, but for the idiots last season on this issue I enjoy informing the masses Can you please link me to where I said we were a "top 5" team in the country? No, you can't. Because I haven't Didnt say you said we were a top 5 team but in another thread you said we were underrated at 15 and I disagree. Obviously. I've held, consistently, that we deserve to be somewhere between #8 and #12 -- Exactly where we are in composite rankings. The rest of your ranking rant can best be described as total gibberish.

You've missed the entire point of why Cohen played ball that way last year, but that is not surprising to me there is no reason ever to play like he did last year. That is not up for debate. I have no problem with small ball like stealing or doing hit-and-runs. My entire beef is the bunt one runner over to second. Which we employed a ton. That play should never be used EVER. Injuries and Youth do not factor into how dumb doing that is. Even with our injuries and youth we still managed to score 53% of the time not doing it, only 23% when doing it. So dont act like not doing it would fail, it didnt. . Let's ignore all of our injuries and youth last season -- which was a DRASTICALLY different style than we played in Cohen's first 3 years, when offensive production WAS NOT A PROBLEM(it was pitching holding us back). Fear not, bunting will be a smaller part of our gameplan this year -- because we've got at least 7 or 8 guys that CAN and WILL swing it -- and at least 5 or 6 that can and will swipe bases. If you can steal second, you don't need to bunt the guy over.Thats correct, except so far in the scrimmages he has done the bunt one man over numerous times. On one occasion he bunted Frazier over with CT, right before a Renfroe blast. Wasted out. Cohen quit taking chances with stealing bases last year because of our injury situation -- and a slide into second is statistically one of the most likely places for an injury to occur in baseball(behind sliding into home -- which happens much, much less often).No he quit taking chances stealing because we couldnt steal. In conference play we stole 7 bases and got caught stealing 14 times. Thats a 33% clip. Thats horrible. So not only were we making outs on the basepaths, we were making more outs at the plate.

The worst part of all this related to your post? Goat is traditionally a pretty good baseball poster...

We bunted one man over to second 26 times in league play last year. Out of those 26 innings we only scored 6 times. And out of those 6 all were only 1 run innings. This is my entire problem. Not small ball, not stealing, not putting pressure on the defense. Bunting one man over from first to second. If Cohen changes like you say, great, I will be happy. If we keep doing this one move, Cohen should be called out, because its retarded.
 
Sep 16, 2012
498
0
0
Too lazy (& indifferent) to look this up but...

..it seemed everytime last year we got a man on 1st with either 0 outs or 1 outs, if the upcomig batter was allowed to hit away, he would promptly hit into a double play. So when Cohen went to small ball exclusively, I for one was relieved. Plus last year the squad displayed no timely hitting except during the UK series & the SECT. And even then it was our pitching that saved the day during that stretch, not the hitting. I expect the hitting to be better this year for several reasons. What's seldom mentioned is Cohen won 40 games last year with a squad that couldn't hit for ****. This year, give Cohen improved hitting & equal or even slightly worse pitching & he is going to go places.
 

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
The guys projecting us very high are making some big assumptions in our favor, including that newcomers such as Pirtle and Robson will put up big stats. But the pitching staff appears to be legit, and our defense will be stout again, so its not a stretch to expect us to field a very solid team.

Projecting how good MSU will be is making the LEAST assumptions of any SEC team right now. We return basically everyone. There is VERY LITTLE unknown quantities on this team. How those guys mature and improve is the only thing causing the diversity in opinions among the national media types.

Should be noted that in hindsight, we've been underrated BOTH of the past two years BIGTIME by all national publications. We were picked 5th and 4th in the west the past two years and came in second both times.

Like I say, I think we're #8-#12 right now. My bigger questionmark is finding a lights-out Friday guy. I'm very, very confident that the hitting will improve into a middle of the pack SEC team this year. Going to search the archive and pull out my prediction for this season from last year when everyone was melting down about the offense. You'll see that I was pretty close on that...
 

Hump4Hoops

Redshirt
May 1, 2010
6,611
13
38
So, here's what I think happened with "Will James"

MSDawg34 has average knowledge and insight into baseball. He loves it, but is nothing special when it comes to analysis. He also happens to really 17ing hate bunting. His persistence in knocking on bunting led to many arguments on the board, to the point where people began to know and recognize him for that one fact - that he hates bunting.

He decided to come back on as "Will James," and instead of attempting any sort of real insight, decides to play off of his notoriety for hating bunting in order to increase that notoriety even more - if enough people recognize him for something, surely he can trick a few of them into thinking he has a clue what he's talking about in the grander sense.
 

Will James

Redshirt
Feb 11, 2013
1,342
0
0
Winning an outright SEC Baseball Championship at Kentucky with his 'small ball' approach go against "all baseball wisdom?" This is the same Univ of KY where students don't even know or care that they have a baseball team.

I kinda thought we hired him to Win baseball games. I'm frankly more interested in the 'winning' part and less in the 'how' part.

Kentucky's SEC Championship team had 99 home runs. We had 21. Small-ball*

I'm interested in winning too. And doing the most we can to win ball games which means scoring the most runs, maximizing our offense. I'd rather win 6-3 and 3-2 than win 4-3 and lose 2-1
 

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
In conference play, we were already EXTREMELY injured. We called 2 guys off Spring Break to come start their college career at SoutheasternLA on their way to kick off conference play in Baton Rouge. That point doesn't hold water. You contend that we couldn't steal. I contend that we didn't steal(and couldn't to an extent) because we were already too injured to take those chances with our 2-3 healthy speed guys. Almost all of our injured position players were + speed guys...

This year, we are nothing but speed guys outside of Rea and Slauter...Porter if he actually holds the DH slot, which I question.
 

Will James

Redshirt
Feb 11, 2013
1,342
0
0
If you listen to the baseball statistics guys, you'd only steal if you can do it successfully 70% of the time and only bunt very rarely in late game situations. I tend to agree with this and think we left runs on the bases last year.

The guys projecting us very high are making some big assumptions in our favor, including that newcomers such as Pirtle and Robson will put up big stats. But the pitching staff appears to be legit, and our defense will be stout again, so its not a stretch to expect us to field a very solid team.

Agreed 100%
 

Will James

Redshirt
Feb 11, 2013
1,342
0
0
In conference play, we were already EXTREMELY injured. We called 2 guys off Spring Break to come start their college career at SoutheasternLA on their way to kick off conference play in Baton Rouge. That point doesn't hold water. You contend that we couldn't steal. I contend that we didn't steal(and couldn't to an extent) because we were already too injured to take those chances with our 2-3 healthy speed guys. Almost all of our injured position players were + speed guys...

This year, we are nothing but speed guys outside of Rea and Slauter...Porter if he actually holds the DH slot, which I question.

So therefore you agree with me that if we do the same ******** on offense like last year there's a problem. It is way too easy to get on base in college ball to be giving away outs. Our OBP from last year (****** offense) was higher than 99% of MLB teams from the past decade
 
Sep 16, 2012
498
0
0
I don't remember that; just remember the double plays...

...the bottom line is, like me, Cohen got tired of seeing his predictable hitters ruin innings & momentum by hitting into the predictable double play. Hence he went to small ball exclusively. If you wish to aruge the statistics of this move with Cohen, sorry. Don't know his e-mail or Twitter address.
 

Will James

Redshirt
Feb 11, 2013
1,342
0
0
...the bottom line is, like me, Cohen got tired of seeing his predictable hitters ruin innings & momentum by hitting into the predictable double play. Hence he went to small ball exclusively. If you wish to aruge the statistics of this move with Cohen, sorry. Don't know his e-mail or Twitter address.

I just don't understand how the same people that rip Chris Wilson and Les Koenning for scheme (rightly so) are able to watch our baseball team last year and not say **** as we small-balled our way out of a regional courtesy of Samford. Couldn't ride Holder any further than we did.
 

Will James

Redshirt
Feb 11, 2013
1,342
0
0
His persistence in knocking on bunting led to many arguments on the board, to the point where people began to know and recognize him for that one fact - that he hates bunting.

Prove me wrong. It led to arguments because questioning Cohen was blasphemous to some. No debating the stats just the need to stamp out any criticism on Cohen. I kept bringing it up because Cohen kept doing, and failing, that tactic.

He decided to come back on as "Will James," and instead of attempting any sort of real insight, decides to play off of his notoriety for hating bunting in order to increase that notoriety even more

Great insight there chief. Which one of my points do you disagree with again?
 

BiscuitEater

Redshirt
Aug 29, 2009
4,178
0
36
Yes, ...

Kentucky's SEC Championship team had 99 home runs. We had 21. Small-ball*

I'm interested in winning too. And doing the most we can to win ball games which means scoring the most runs, maximizing our offense. I'd rather win 6-3 and 3-2 than win 4-3 and lose 2-1

and in the late '80s, State traveled to KY and in one game, won like 28-16.

In '06, KY played most of their games at Cliff Hagan with 310 down one line, and 350 & 365 power allys. Historically, Dudy Noble is not a HR park.

Cohen's KY SEC Championship team also had 337 Base on balls (v 140), led the SEC in HBP, stole 52 of 74 (v 18 of 27). While they had power, they also used 'small ball' to their advantage. They also struck out 428 times.

Like you, I'm interested in winning. I just think that Cohen has a better idea of what it will take for 'his' team to win than you do. Last year, due to new bats, youth and injuries, guess he felt that small ball was the team's best chance. We will see what the new season brings.
 

Todd4State

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
17,411
1
0
You do realize

I just don't understand how the same people that rip Chris Wilson and Les Koenning for scheme (rightly so) are able to watch our baseball team last year and not say **** as we small-balled our way out of a regional courtesy of Samford. Couldn't ride Holder any further than we did.

that us NOT playing small ball would have been much more like Chris Wilson than not? Of course you don't. The way you want us to play- we would have to have a lot of power hitters. That is rare for a college team- even a SEC team. And you want us to do it in a pitcher's park- making it even more difficult to hit extra base hits. And you wanted us to play like that with largely injured team? Not a good idea. If Cohen ran more than he did and someone else got hurt, this board would have gone nuts- and rightfully so.

What you don't get and you will obviously never get- and the "stat guys" as well- is that you manage a game based on individual situations rather than based solely on stats.

Let me give you an example- Sam Frost with no one out and a runner on first in the fifth inning. The odds of Sam Frost hitting into a double play are better than him getting a hit. Therefore, it is better for him to bunt and put a runner in scoring position with one out than have the bases empty with two.

Your bunting stat is skewed because it doesn't isolate straight sarifices vs bunting to get a hit and it also doesn't take into account times that we bunted and got a hit because that is scored a single- so it is viewed the same way as it is a straight single or a home run for that matter, nor does it take into account the times that we bunted and the other team made an error.

We won the SEC Tournament with a MASH unit for an offense. Cohen should be applauded for that. Most of us with a brain get that.

Our hitting will be better because we have more experience and we are healthy. Being healthy will also mean a deeper bench, which allows for more versatility. Being healthy will also mean that we will run more, do more hit and runs, etc. We couldn't do that last year- heck, we hit into TWO triple plays within a span of about two weeks because we had an inexperienced hitter at the plate who hit a pitcher's pitch.
 

Coach34

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2012
20,283
1
0
I hate bunting also- but sometimes its necessary. Cohen was snakebit alot last year. When he didnt bunt- we hit into alot of double play or struck out to kill innings. I hope he backs off the bunting some now that we are more mature and healthy.

One thing thats hard to disagree with- Cohen got everything out of last year's team that a coach could have with all the injuries and inexperience. He also put another SEC banner on the wall. Hopefully we will have some good luck and are able to get to Omaha
 

Hump4Hoops

Redshirt
May 1, 2010
6,611
13
38
It has nothing to do with right or wrong

Your thread is called "baseball preseason notes," but it's 90% dedicated to bitching about bunting.

You're a 1 trick pony.
 

Will James

Redshirt
Feb 11, 2013
1,342
0
0
that us NOT playing small ball would have been much more like Chris Wilson than not? Of course you don't. The way you want us to play- we would have to have a lot of power hitters. How can you not comprehend what I want. I'm not looking for the long ball, we could do better with our offense we had. When we didn't bunt IT WORKED. When we did IT DIDNT.

Let me give you an example- Sam Frost with no one out and a runner on first in the fifth inning. The odds of Sam Frost hitting into a double play are better than him getting a hit. Thats not true. Therefore, it is better for him to bunt and put a runner in scoring position with one out than have the bases empty with two. Frost grounded into 2 double plays all year. He did however 17 up at least 4 bunt attempts. Popping out to the catcher and ****. Look it may be even marginally different if we could lay a bunt down but we would screw up 25% of the time we tried. You cannot play for 1 run early in a ballgame. Look at our big 1st inning down in Baton Rouge. We could have bunted there with runners on 1st and 2nd no out, but we didnt and scored 5 runs. I advocate for nothing more than not giving away outs, especially when we cant even give away outs sucessfully.

Your bunting stat is skewed because it doesn't isolate straight sarifices vs bunting to get a hit and it also doesn't take into account times that we bunted and got a hit because that is scored a single- so it is viewed the same way as it is a straight single or a home run for that matter, nor does it take into account the times that we bunted and the other team made an error.Its not all bunting. For the 100th time. You know this.

We won the SEC Tournament with a MASH unit for an offense. Cohen should be applauded for that. Most of us with a brain get that Yes he should, our pitchers were unbelievable last year. We all know though you are judged by the NCAAs

Our hitting will be better because we have more experience and we are healthy. Being healthy will also mean a deeper bench, which allows for more versatility. Being healthy will also mean that we will run more, do more hit and runs, etc. We couldn't do that last year- heck, we hit into TWO triple plays within a span of about two weeks because we had an inexperienced hitter at the plate who hit a pitcher's pitch.

Triple plays are such an anomaly I hope you arent suggesting those are anyone's fault. If I remember right one was on a double steal and one was hit by Adam Frazier
 

Will James

Redshirt
Feb 11, 2013
1,342
0
0
Your thread is called "baseball preseason notes," but it's 90% dedicated to bitching about bunting.

You're a 1 trick pony.

Probably 30% of the original post. Not much has to be said on pitching and defense. The main hurdle to our success is Cohen.

Looks like 100% of your post is not contradicting anything I say so as far as one trick ponies go..
 

maroonmania

All-Conference
Feb 23, 2008
11,389
1,165
113
If you listen to the baseball statistics guys, you'd only steal if you can do it successfully 70% of the time and only bunt very rarely in late game situations. I tend to agree with this and think we left runs on the bases last year.

The guys projecting us very high are making some big assumptions in our favor, including that newcomers such as Pirtle and Robson will put up big stats. But the pitching staff appears to be legit, and our defense will be stout again, so its not a stretch to expect us to field a very solid team.

We really don't need many guys putting up "big stats" to be a really good team this year. If we get production from Frazier like last year and everyone else is just a little bit better plus adding Bradford and Norris back into the lineup to go along with our pitching staff then that is all it will take for us to be a high ranked team. Like I said I'm still amazed we were as good as we were last year with Frost, Britton and a bum-shouldered Rea often anchoring the infield.
 

Philly Dawg

Heisman
Oct 6, 2012
16,378
11,076
113
I think the improvement in hitting is the biggest unknown quantity on the team. We do not have proven returning hitting as a team. I also think we'll be improved, possibly significantly, but it might not materialize to the extent we might expect.
 

DawgatAuburn

All-Conference
Apr 25, 2006
11,192
2,329
113
My uneducated guess at this situation is that Cohen suspected his punch and judy lineup was not likely to string together two singles to score a runner from first, or produce any type of extra base hit that would have scored someone from first, so he gave up the out to advance the runner (at a much lower success rate than we should have, I might add). Then he just needed one hit instead of two to get the run in. Apparently as the data shows, that didn't work very well either.

I'd really like to see us dial back the bunting to situations when we have a slim lead in a pitcher's duel, when we have a comfortable lead in an average game and we are trying to stretch it out to a five or six run lead, and when we need a run to tie after the 6th or 7th and we don't take the bat out of the hands of any of our best bats. Most other situations I'd rather swing away. I have never coached so much as little league, so my opinion is just that.
 

Todd4State

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
17,411
1
0
OK- so you don't want to bunt BUT

that us NOT playing small ball would have been much more like Chris Wilson than not? Of course you don't. The way you want us to play- we would have to have a lot of power hitters. How can you not comprehend what I want. I'm not looking for the long ball, we could do better with our offense we had. When we didn't bunt IT WORKED. When we did IT DIDNT.

Let me give you an example- Sam Frost with no one out and a runner on first in the fifth inning. The odds of Sam Frost hitting into a double play are better than him getting a hit. Thats not true. Therefore, it is better for him to bunt and put a runner in scoring position with one out than have the bases empty with two. Frost grounded into 2 double plays all year. He did however 17 up at least 4 bunt attempts. Popping out to the catcher and ****. Look it may be even marginally different if we could lay a bunt down but we would screw up 25% of the time we tried. You cannot play for 1 run early in a ballgame. Look at our big 1st inning down in Baton Rouge. We could have bunted there with runners on 1st and 2nd no out, but we didnt and scored 5 runs. I advocate for nothing more than not giving away outs, especially when we cant even give away outs sucessfully.

Your bunting stat is skewed because it doesn't isolate straight sarifices vs bunting to get a hit and it also doesn't take into account times that we bunted and got a hit because that is scored a single- so it is viewed the same way as it is a straight single or a home run for that matter, nor does it take into account the times that we bunted and the other team made an error.Its not all bunting. For the 100th time. You know this.

We won the SEC Tournament with a MASH unit for an offense. Cohen should be applauded for that. Most of us with a brain get that Yes he should, our pitchers were unbelievable last year. We all know though you are judged by the NCAAs

Our hitting will be better because we have more experience and we are healthy. Being healthy will also mean a deeper bench, which allows for more versatility. Being healthy will also mean that we will run more, do more hit and runs, etc. We couldn't do that last year- heck, we hit into TWO triple plays within a span of about two weeks because we had an inexperienced hitter at the plate who hit a pitcher's pitch.

Triple plays are such an anomaly I hope you arent suggesting those are anyone's fault. If I remember right one was on a double steal and one was hit by Adam Frazier

You're not looking for the long ball? So, basically, you are looking for three hits in a row from a team that finished near the bottom in the SEC in hitting? You can't have it both ways. If you don't play small ball some- you HAVE to drive in runs with extra base hits or your offense will suck. If you play station to station with singles hitters, you have to get three hits to score a run. We could do that in 1985, but that's not the norm for us or any college team for that matter. An MLB team can do it if they want to because of free agency and because those players are the best in the world. I think the ideal thing is to be able to do some of both. When you can put pressure on a defense with fast base runners, yes- bunting, hit and running, etc. you cause the other team to make mistakes. And if you have some power hitters- those can turn into home runs.

Does it not occur to you that Sam Frost only grounded into two double plays because maybe we didn't put him in a position to hit into a double play? Thanks for making my point. I find it hilarious that a guy that claims to be the "stat guy" basically has an approximated number of how many times Frost screwed up a bunt. Also, does it not occur to you that maybe we didn't bunt in the first inning against LSU because it was the first inning?

On your third point- I'll tell you what I do know- you can't defend your stat. If that stat accounted for bunts that were scored singles and errors- I would buy it a lot more. But it doesn't. And the fact that there is only a run difference when you don't count the best possible sceanrio for a bunt- it actually more than likely means that bunting is actually a good play or at the very least a lot smaller than what the data represents.

Now, I do agree that triple plays are an anamoly. However, when you have two in the span of two weeks- its got to make you wonder. Especially when again- they were basically caused by double hit and runs where again, the hitter didn't execute. Now, Chris Wilson probably would have kept doing it- but at least Cohen had the brains to put that play on the shelf until we got healthy this year.
 

CadaverDawg

Redshirt
Dec 5, 2011
6,409
0
0
that us NOT playing small ball would have been much more like Chris Wilson than not? Of course you don't. The way you want us to play- we would have to have a lot of power hitters. That is rare for a college team- even a SEC team. And you want us to do it in a pitcher's park- making it even more difficult to hit extra base hits. And you wanted us to play like that with largely injured team? Not a good idea. If Cohen ran more than he did and someone else got hurt, this board would have gone nuts- and rightfully so.

What you don't get and you will obviously never get- and the "stat guys" as well- is that you manage a game based on individual situations rather than based solely on stats.

Let me give you an example- Sam Frost with no one out and a runner on first in the fifth inning. The odds of Sam Frost hitting into a double play are better than him getting a hit. Therefore, it is better for him to bunt and put a runner in scoring position with one out than have the bases empty with two.

Your bunting stat is skewed because it doesn't isolate straight sarifices vs bunting to get a hit and it also doesn't take into account times that we bunted and got a hit because that is scored a single- so it is viewed the same way as it is a straight single or a home run for that matter, nor does it take into account the times that we bunted and the other team made an error.

We won the SEC Tournament with a MASH unit for an offense. Cohen should be applauded for that. Most of us with a brain get that.

Our hitting will be better because we have more experience and we are healthy. Being healthy will also mean a deeper bench, which allows for more versatility. Being healthy will also mean that we will run more, do more hit and runs, etc. We couldn't do that last year- heck, we hit into TWO triple plays within a span of about two weeks because we had an inexperienced hitter at the plate who hit a pitcher's pitch.

+1
 

Will James

Redshirt
Feb 11, 2013
1,342
0
0
Does it not occur to you that Sam Frost only grounded into two double plays because maybe we didn't put him in a position to hit into a double play? Thanks for making my point. I find it hilarious that a guy that claims to be the "stat guy" basically has an approximated number of how many times Frost screwed up a bunt. Also, does it not occur to you that maybe we didn't bunt in the first inning against LSU because it was the first inning?

On your third point- I'll tell you what I do know- you can't defend your stat. If that stat accounted for bunts that were scored singles and errors- I would buy it a lot more. But it doesn't. And the fact that there is only a run difference when you don't count the best possible sceanrio for a bunt- it actually more than likely means that bunting is actually a good play or at the very least a lot smaller than what the data represents.

Todd this is the last time I am going to say this. That stat is only for bunts with RUNNERS on FIRST, NO OUTS. I do not have a problem with bunting for hits or getting on via errors. I DID include those bunts although if memory serves there were only like 2 of those instances with runner on 1st and no out.

The instances where bunts were popped up (numerous), bunts were failed resulting in 2 wasted strikes leading to a groundout, for example, are categorized in the DID NOT BUNT stat.

I did not plan on keeping this stat until halfway through the season so obviously I couldnt know the AB's where the bunt was failed from memory. I will continue the research this year with failed bunts included which would have even better made my point last year. Half the bunts in the scrimmages have been missed or fouled away. These kids just do not know how to get it down which makes any theory of it null and void anyway.

Another meme you love is the 3 base hits. Why you use the opposite ends of the spectrum is absurd. There are stolen bases, walks, HBP, wild pitches, errors, etc that can move runners other than bunting. It doesn't take 3 singles, you know this.

Explain your last sentence for me. What you are saying I am not including, I did.
 
Last edited:

mcdawg22

Heisman
Sep 18, 2004
13,785
12,442
113
I do have a question. Do those stats take in account who was at bat? Did we swing away when Frazier was at the plate, but bunt when Rea was in his slump. I think your math is solid but you have to look at the actual hitter.
 

Will James

Redshirt
Feb 11, 2013
1,342
0
0
I do have a question. Do those stats take in account who was at bat? Did we swing away when Frazier was at the plate, but bunt when Rea was in his slump. I think your math is solid but you have to look at the actual hitter.

Frazier 3
Rea 3
Frost 3
Britton 3
Bradford 3
Renfroe 3
Slauter 2
Norris 2
Jones 1
Stark 1
Brownlee 1
Fullerton 1

SEC games. Cohen was an equal opportunity bunter, with a man on 1st no outs. That accounted for 26 of our 33 sac bunts in league play.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Football Jeff Lebby fires assistants Phil Loadholt and Cliff Odom after Auburn loss
  2. 02 Maroon and White Mississippi State PFF Grades from 41-9 loss to Auburn
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Lopsided analytics illustrate Mississippi State's collapse against Auburn
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football "Not good enough": Jeff Lebby answers questions of performance and job security following blowout loss to Auburn
  5. 05 Maroon and White Football Rapid Recap: Auburn 41-9 Mississippi State