Rodgers would have driven down the field, but at least they would have had to earn it - when you get a chance to win a Super Bowl once every couple decades now (sans the beloved 90s), you kind of want that to happen. And the Cowboys may have got a 2 point play where a FG only tied the game.
Not the same comparison to the Lions, where it was a bad call as well (shouldn't have punted at 4th and inches, shouldn't have shanked the kick, shouldn't have given up a TD, shouldn't have fumbled, should have done something after the gift returned fumble, etc.).