Wondering what everyone thought of Elliot's

[TilloDawg]

decision to have 2 seperate surgeries on his knee rather than both at the same time, as advised by the medical staff.

He will now not be able to go through spring practice

 

[thunderclap]

if Elliot would have known that Dan Mullen and not Sly Croom was going to be running our offense in spring practice, he would have made a different decision.

 

[Coach34]

he thought he was going to have to go through another Spring practice of running Croom's same 7 plays and then having to play in a 0-0 Spring Game...i can see why he wanted to miss that

 

[graddawg]

I, for one, will never second guess anyone for taking the opinion of ANY doctor over that of The Butcher of Starkville. Well, I might listen to The Butcher over Dr. KB21 but that's about it.

 

[lawdawg02]

even with a simple reconstruction, spring practice would've been a little quick for him to be back on the field anyway.

 

[HD6]

Ray Ray No! Ray Ray No!

 

[JxnDawg39211]

Just so you can relive it through your head:

1. Dixon off left tackle
2. Dixon off right tackle
3. Ducre draw
4. Brandon Mcrae's 5 yard out
5. Tyson Lee 5 yard drop, then scramble
6. Arnil Stallworth screen pass
7. Brandon Mcrae reverse

 

[Shmuley]

he was "going to" add:

8. QB sneak

 

[DerHntr]

nm

 

[MM56]

9. Option-Sack!

 

[TheHorrorTheHorror]

drunk. however, i think that the ever elusive V-formation made an appearance @ the MTSU game this year...
i'm probably wrong, but there is always that chance...

 

[kired]

I wouldn't expect him to return by this spring no matter what happened. I'll just be happy if he's 100% by this fall, which I still think is a stretch. I always understood it took at least 9-12 months from surgery before playing football, and even longer if there are any complications (see Tom Brady).

 

[RonnyAtmosphere]

...season.

I would rather the guy take a medical redshirt season for the 2009 season & recover 100% than come back too early & be 2 steps too slow the rest of his college career.

Same with McRae: I would rather see MSU's best WR take a medical redshirt season than come back too early & look like Will Prosser.