Skip to main content
Avatar

If all of us take off our maize and blue colored glasses for a moment....

...and look at the Football Program as a whole since Jim Harbaugh was hired, we would see some of the same optics others outside of Michigan fandom sees. I will reiterate what I said in another post....it is time that Michigan distances it's self from Harbaugh and his coaching family/tree. I know many on here will defend Jim until the last day, however it is tough to stomach everything that Michigan has been through over the last 4-5 years. Yes Jim won a NC for Michigan, but at what cost to the program and it's current situation. All the drama that surrounded Harbaugh over the years, plus the whole sign-gate scandal and now Moore's mess. Harbaugh did not do Michigan any favors in how things went while he was here and since he has left. Now Jim is not alone in being the center of so much turmoil, Warde certainly has played his part and the coaches and staff members who have given Michigan a black eye are as guilty as anyone, but there is a long list of dirty laundry on the field over the last 10 or so years in the Michigan Football program. Some very questionable character of some hires over these years have added up to a big mess we are seeing being played out in the media. I am not sure how Michigan or even if they should go after Jesse Minter, Jay Harbaugh, or John for that matter. I strongly believe it is time for Michigan to do a full reset within the Michigan Football program. We need to earn back some respect from the college football world. Just compare the Men's and Women's Basketball Programs, not too mention the current Hockey program and you will see a drastic difference between them and Michigan Football today.
90 Replies
Avatar

Qball

Dec 11, 7:45 PM

I think Jesse Minter would be a homerun hire
Avatar

marzanoj

Dec 11, 7:46 PM

I think you are wrong
Avatar

TrueBlueFanatic

Dec 11, 7:47 PM

Qball said:
I think Jesse Minter would be a homerun hire
I agree, but he has been caught up in the Harbaugh whirlwind of crap. Do we think there would be enough separation between him and Harbaugh for him to be a "clean" hire?
Avatar

blue20

Dec 11, 7:48 PM

TrueBlueFanatic said:
...and look at the Football Program as a whole since Jim Harbaugh was hired, we would see some of the same optics others outside of Michigan fandom sees. I will reiterate what I said in another post....it is time that Michigan distances it's self from Harbaugh and his coaching family/tree. I know many on here will defend Jim until the last day, however it is tough to stomach everything that Michigan has been through over the last 4-5 years. Yes Jim won a NC for Michigan, but at what cost to the program and it's current situation. All the drama that surrounded Harbaugh over the years, plus the who sign-gate scandal and now Moore's mess. Harbaugh did not do Michigan any favors in how things went while he was here and since he has left. Now Jim is not alone in being the so center of so much turmoil, Warde certainly has played his part and the coaches and staff members who have given Michigan a black eye are as guilty as anyone, but there is a long list of dirty laundry on the field over the last 10 or so years in the Michigan Football program. Some very questionable character of some hires over these years have added up to a big mess we are seeing being played out in the media. I am not sure how Michigan or even if they should go after Jesse Minter, Jay Harbaugh, or John for that matter. I strongly believe it is time for Michigan to do a full reset within the Michigan Football program. We need to earn back some respect from the college football world. Just compare the Men's and Women's Basketball Programs, not too mention the current Hockey program and you will see a drastic difference between them and Michigan Football today.
you will get destroyed but looking at it objectively, you definitely make some good points.
Avatar

blue20

Dec 11, 7:48 PM

TrueBlueFanatic said:
I agree, but he has been caught up in the Harbaugh whirlwind of crap. Do we think there would be enough separation between him and Harbaugh for him to be a "clean" hire?
.....but i thought we were done with the "Michigan is not the place for first time head coaches"
Avatar

TrueBlueFanatic

Dec 11, 7:49 PM

marzanoj said:
I think you are wrong
Okay, would you like to elaborate on why? Harbaugh hired and pushed for Moore to be the new HC. So today we are still stuck in the Harbaugh whirlwind of drama.
Avatar

timmieb

Dec 11, 7:49 PM

Qball said:
I think Jesse Minter would be a homerun hire
I think the OP would dislike that, because Minter would be a head coach with reasonable integrity and would very likely obtain fantastic results, leading some to give further credit to Jim that OP would seek to preclude.
Avatar

Jason_S

Dec 11, 7:50 PM

TrueBlueFanatic said:
I agree, but he has been caught up in the Harbaugh whirlwind of crap. Do we think there would be enough separation between him and Harbaugh for him to be a "clean" hire?
The answer is yes. You think he’s going to call up stallions or something?
Avatar

EpiWolv

Dec 11, 7:50 PM

I don’t think Minter should be an automatic no, but I also don’t think he should be a tier 1 option partially because of this.
Avatar

Sasquatch616

Dec 11, 7:51 PM

Greatest three year run in the history of Michigan Football 15-0 National Champions Also: Image
Avatar

timmieb

Dec 11, 7:52 PM

EpiWolv said:
I don’t think Minter should be an automatic no, but I also don’t think he should be a tier 1 option partially because of this.
He’s essentially the top of the list option if actually an option because of tremendous demonstrated football acumen, and also seems to be a decent guy with decent integrity (although of course “bad” surprises are possible, and we ended up with basically the worst with Sherrone).
Avatar

KenGrantFanatic

Dec 11, 7:53 PM

Posts like this where we compare what Harbaugh did and what Sherrone did are utterly idiotic. Harbaugh caused controversy yes but it was almost always standing up for something, for example calling for players to get paid, standing up to the NCAA. Sherrone was just a selfish idiot who did something morally terrible. You can’t just say “Sherrone bad, so Harbaugh bad”
Avatar

TrueBlueFanatic

Dec 11, 7:54 PM

Jason_S said:
The answer is yes. You think he’s going to call up stallions or something?
Just asking...
Avatar

Sandiegogoblue

Dec 11, 7:54 PM

Qball said:
I think Jesse Minter would be a homerun hire
Every time I log back on (every 15 minutes or so, lol) I am hoping to see on the homepage "Jesse Minter hired as the next head coach." Not going to lie, he is my number 1 and it's not even close.
Avatar

TrueBlueFanatic

Dec 11, 7:54 PM

timmieb said:
I think the OP would dislike that, because Minter would be a head coach with reasonable integrity and would very likely obtain fantastic results, leading some to give further credit to Jim that OP would seek to preclude.
Not at all, just looking at all the crap that has happen to Michigan Football since Harbaugh was hired. Remember you have to take your maize colored glasses off first.
Avatar

TrueBlueFanatic

Dec 11, 7:55 PM

Sasquatch616 said:
Greatest three year run in the history of Michigan Football 15-0 National Champions Also: Image
At what cost though?
Avatar

The Brown Jug

Dec 11, 7:57 PM

TrueBlueFanatic said:
...and look at the Football Program as a whole since Jim Harbaugh was hired, we would see some of the same optics others outside of Michigan fandom sees. I will reiterate what I said in another post....it is time that Michigan distances it's self from Harbaugh and his coaching family/tree. I know many on here will defend Jim until the last day, however it is tough to stomach everything that Michigan has been through over the last 4-5 years. Yes Jim won a NC for Michigan, but at what cost to the program and it's current situation. All the drama that surrounded Harbaugh over the years, plus the who sign-gate scandal and now Moore's mess. Harbaugh did not do Michigan any favors in how things went while he was here and since he has left. Now Jim is not alone in being the so center of so much turmoil, Warde certainly has played his part and the coaches and staff members who have given Michigan a black eye are as guilty as anyone, but there is a long list of dirty laundry on the field over the last 10 or so years in the Michigan Football program. Some very questionable character of some hires over these years have added up to a big mess we are seeing being played out in the media. I am not sure how Michigan or even if they should go after Jesse Minter, Jay Harbaugh, or John for that matter. I strongly believe it is time for Michigan to do a full reset within the Michigan Football program. We need to earn back some respect from the college football world. Just compare the Men's and Women's Basketball Programs, not too mention the current Hockey program and you will see a drastic difference between them and Michigan Football today.
Don't forget that Harbaugh recommended Moore. Nice call, Jim. I believe Harbaugh is a very good football coach and a dysfunctional human being.
Avatar

TrueBlueFanatic

Dec 11, 7:58 PM

KenGrantFanatic said:
Posts like this where we compare what Harbaugh did and what Sherrone did are utterly idiotic. Harbaugh caused controversy yes but it was almost always standing up for something, for example calling for players to get paid, standing up to the NCAA. Sherrone was just a selfish idiot who did something morally terrible. You can’t just say “Sherrone bad, so Harbaugh bad”
Can you deny that since Harbaugh was hired there have been many controversial happenings with the Michigan Football program? Do you think Harbaugh himself is completely without blame on where we are today? He hired Moore and pushed for his promotion, I realize he may or may not have known about Moore's character issues, but yet here we are today.
Avatar

timmieb

Dec 11, 7:59 PM

TrueBlueFanatic said:
Not at all, just looking at all the crap that has happen to Michigan Football since Harbaugh was hired. Remember you have to take your maize colored glasses off first.
Harbaugh hired a few guys who turned out to be assholes, and Harbaugh and Michigan ended up in the crosshairs of some fake scandals essentially invented by OSU, the NCAA, and the Big 10. Unless there’s guilty knowledge on Harbaugh’s part of a kind that’s never been presented, it’s not that deep and it’s not that big a deal, even though with the benefit of hindsight of course Michigan and Harbaugh would both rather have had nothing to do with Sherrone Moore, ever.
Avatar

FL_Blue

Dec 11, 8:00 PM

TrueBlueFanatic said:
...and look at the Football Program as a whole since Jim Harbaugh was hired, we would see some of the same optics others outside of Michigan fandom sees. I will reiterate what I said in another post....it is time that Michigan distances it's self from Harbaugh and his coaching family/tree. I know many on here will defend Jim until the last day, however it is tough to stomach everything that Michigan has been through over the last 4-5 years. Yes Jim won a NC for Michigan, but at what cost to the program and it's current situation. All the drama that surrounded Harbaugh over the years, plus the who sign-gate scandal and now Moore's mess. Harbaugh did not do Michigan any favors in how things went while he was here and since he has left. Now Jim is not alone in being the so center of so much turmoil, Warde certainly has played his part and the coaches and staff members who have given Michigan a black eye are as guilty as anyone, but there is a long list of dirty laundry on the field over the last 10 or so years in the Michigan Football program. Some very questionable character of some hires over these years have added up to a big mess we are seeing being played out in the media. I am not sure how Michigan or even if they should go after Jesse Minter, Jay Harbaugh, or John for that matter. I strongly believe it is time for Michigan to do a full reset within the Michigan Football program. We need to earn back some respect from the college football world. Just compare the Men's and Women's Basketball Programs, not too mention the current Hockey program and you will see a drastic difference between them and Michigan Football today.
Don't knee jerk....every man, woman, child, and dog should be judged as an individual in their own right. Now cats...they all suck
Avatar

GeorgeJones

Dec 11, 8:00 PM

100% agree. Program needs a coaching reset away from Harbs.
Avatar

Mcss2001

Dec 11, 8:00 PM

Avatar

JuiceMonster32

Dec 11, 8:01 PM

TrueBlueFanatic said:
...and look at the Football Program as a whole since Jim Harbaugh was hired, we would see some of the same optics others outside of Michigan fandom sees. I will reiterate what I said in another post....it is time that Michigan distances it's self from Harbaugh and his coaching family/tree. I know many on here will defend Jim until the last day, however it is tough to stomach everything that Michigan has been through over the last 4-5 years. Yes Jim won a NC for Michigan, but at what cost to the program and it's current situation. All the drama that surrounded Harbaugh over the years, plus the who sign-gate scandal and now Moore's mess. Harbaugh did not do Michigan any favors in how things went while he was here and since he has left. Now Jim is not alone in being the so center of so much turmoil, Warde certainly has played his part and the coaches and staff members who have given Michigan a black eye are as guilty as anyone, but there is a long list of dirty laundry on the field over the last 10 or so years in the Michigan Football program. Some very questionable character of some hires over these years have added up to a big mess we are seeing being played out in the media. I am not sure how Michigan or even if they should go after Jesse Minter, Jay Harbaugh, or John for that matter. I strongly believe it is time for Michigan to do a full reset within the Michigan Football program. We need to earn back some respect from the college football world. Just compare the Men's and Women's Basketball Programs, not too mention the current Hockey program and you will see a drastic difference between them and Michigan Football today.
Our head basketball coach was attacking other coaches 2 years ago. Shit happens, and the vast majority of harbaugh drama was the ncaa attacking him for less than what 99% of what other teams do. He just made some terrible hires and it has potentially sunk the progrum. Bottom line there are only 2 people to blame, sherrone moore and warde manuel.
Avatar

jameshgale

Dec 11, 8:01 PM

I think that JH is an ethical guy and great football coach who has blind spots, which at Michigan proved very problematic.

Thanks for checking out this free message board preview.

Join the full discussion at The Fort