You can trust your experts and i'll trust mine. Mine has delivered results and runs the largest Space Program in the world.
What do you mean by current platform? Only cameras? You are aware they do currently use lidar, just not on the end product? They do use Lidar to train the algorithm. If you don't think they will make it then that is fine, you have put your money where your mouth is by not buying TSLA stock. I have also put my money where my mouth is by being long tesla stock.
You can say too dangerous, but here is what AI has to say:
"In summary, FSD is already safer than the average human in supervised use and could achieve unsupervised superiority (2-10x safer) by late 2025 with v14. Full "better than humans" everywhere? Likely 2026-2027, transforming mobility and saving ~1.3M global road lives/year (WHO estimate). Tesla's real-world AI focus positions it ahead of lidar-dependent rivals like Waymo."
You can vote with your dollars. That’s what I do.
Let's let AI with all the information in the world at its fingertips do the work for us. FYI I took multiple Waymo's in California when I was there a few weeks ago and it was literally perfection:
Waymo vs Tesla Robotaxi: Safety, Scale, and Current Status as of September 2025
Executive Summary
As of September 24, 2025, both Waymo and Tesla are actively deploying autonomous vehicle technologies, but with dramatically different approaches, safety records, and commercial readiness.
Waymo emerges as the clear leader in safety and operational deployment, while
Tesla shows promise but faces significant safety and regulatory challenges in its current robotaxi implementation.
Waymo's Current Position: Proven Safety at Scale
Deployment and Coverage
Waymo currently operates the most mature autonomous ride-hailing service in the United States, with
over 2,000 vehicles across multiple cities. The service covers
720+ square miles across six major metropolitan areas:
- Phoenix: 315 square miles (full commercial operation)
- San Francisco: Full city coverage including surrounding areas
- Los Angeles: 120+ square miles
- Austin: 90 square miles
- Atlanta: 65 square miles (recently launched)
- Silicon Valley: Parts of Menlo Park, Palo Alto, Los Altos, and Mountain View
Waymo provides
250,000 fully autonomous rides per week as of 2025, representing a 25x growth from 10,000 weekly rides in May 2023. The company has completed
over 10 million autonomous rides and accumulated
96 million rider-only miles without safety drivers.
Safety Statistics: Industry-Leading Performance
Waymo's safety record significantly outperforms human drivers across multiple metrics:
- 91% reduction in serious injury or fatal crashes
- 79% reduction in airbag deployment crashes
- 92% reduction in crashes injuring pedestrians
- 82% reduction in crashes injuring cyclists and motorcyclists
- 96% reduction in injury crashes at intersections
These statistics come from
56.7 million miles of autonomous driving data compared against human driver baselines in the same cities. Importantly,
464 incidents involving Waymo vehicles were reported to NHTSA in 2025, but these resulted in only
one fatality, one serious injury, two moderate injuries, and 28 minor injuries. The vast majority of incidents (632 out of 696 total from 2021-2024) involved no injuries.
Technology and Approach
Waymo employs a comprehensive sensor suite including
29 cameras, 6 radar sensors, and 5 LiDAR sensors, combined with high-definition mapping and gradual geographic expansion. This multi-sensor approach provides
redundant safety systems that can detect objects even when individual sensors fail.
Tesla Robotaxi: Ambitious Vision, Safety Concerns
Limited Commercial Deployment
Tesla launched its robotaxi pilot program in
Austin, Texas in June 2025 with a fleet of approximately
10-12 modified Model Y vehicles. Unlike Waymo's fully autonomous service, Tesla's robotaxis still require
safety monitors in the passenger seat with emergency stop capabilities.
The service operates in a
geofenced area of Austin and is currently limited to
invitation-only riders, primarily Tesla supporters and influencers. Tesla plans expansion to Arizona and California pending regulatory approval.
Concerning Safety Record
Tesla's robotaxi safety performance raises significant concerns compared to Waymo:
- Three crashes reported in July 2025 during the first month of operation
- Incidents occurred across approximately 7,000 miles of operation
- One crash resulted in minor injuries and required vehicle towing
- Tesla redacted most crash details from NHTSA reports, citing proprietary concerns
This crash rate represents
orders of magnitude worse performance than Waymo's established safety record. Independent analysis suggests Tesla robotaxis experience
incidents every 2-8 days based on early operational data.
Full Self-Driving (FSD) Safety Issues
Tesla's underlying FSD technology, which powers the robotaxi service, faces ongoing safety investigations:
- NHTSA investigation launched in October 2024 covering 2.4 million Tesla vehicles equipped with FSD
- Four reported collisions involving FSD in reduced visibility conditions, including one fatal crash in 2023
- Recent testing by Forbes documented seven safety-critical errors in a 90-minute Los Angeles test drive, including running red lights and failing to stop for pedestrians
Tesla's broader safety statistics for FSD show
one crash for every 6.69 million miles with Autopilot engaged, compared to
702,000 miles for average human drivers. However, these statistics combine highway-focused Autopilot data with more limited FSD urban driving data.
Current Advantages and Disadvantages
Waymo Advantages
Safety Leadership: Proven track record with statistically significant safety improvements across all major crash categories
Commercial Maturity: Fully operational service in multiple cities with no safety drivers required
Regulatory Acceptance: Established relationships with regulators and transparent safety reporting
Sensor Redundancy: Multi-modal sensor approach provides fail-safe capabilities in challenging conditions
Operational Scale: 2,000+ vehicles providing 250,000 weekly rides
Waymo Disadvantages
Geographic Limitations: Service limited to carefully mapped, geofenced areas
High Vehicle Costs: Each vehicle estimated at ~$150,000 due to expensive sensor suite
Slow Expansion: Methodical city-by-city rollout requiring extensive mapping and testing
Limited Scalability: HD mapping requirements create barriers to rapid geographic expansion
Tesla Advantages
Lower Vehicle Costs: Camera-only approach costs approximately $400