Toggle sidebar

Jodie Meeks vs. Jamal Murray

L

Louis_Skunt

All-American
Oct 4, 2013
6,312
6,971
66
Murray all day.
Meeks was great, but he wasn't a solid ball handler and had too many turnovers in crunch time. After that UT game you could count on him driving through a crowded middle to get the ball stolen about 5 times a game. They were probably about equal on defense.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DelkBowl
jrpross_rivals

jrpross_rivals

Heisman
Feb 21, 2008
17,592
36,202
113
Murray hands down.

Meeks was a great college player but he also benefited from a much inferior team to Murray's and a coach who ran the offense through him despite his insistence that "this isn't the university of Jodie Meeks."

Jamal was the better ball handler, athlete, rebounder, & passer and their shooting was about a wash.

Love em both though.
 
MdWIldcat55

MdWIldcat55

Heisman
Dec 9, 2007
21,667
87,474
113
Of course we are all comparing freshman Murray with junior Meeks. Even so, Murray was the better overall scorer and player. Loved watching both of them in Kentucky blue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: brianpoe and Nubb16
S

stoneycat_20

All-Conference
Nov 28, 2003
24,212
4,344
0
Hard to compare a Fr to a Jr ..I think Murray would be much much better than Meeks in 2 years...
 
N

Nubb16

Heisman
Jun 30, 2005
128,718
10,043
67
I would take Murray. He's a more versatile player. But Jodi could fill it up, was a great athlete too. His flaw was he wasn't a good ball handler which Murray excels at
 
W

Wall2Boogie

Heisman
Jan 28, 2010
26,239
21,732
0
In cals system I'd take Jodie. Truth be told, there is no wrong answer here both are great. I know murrary had a lot more to work with but with Jodie he only had Patterson. I would of loved to have Jodie his senior year I think we cut the nets had that happened. Jodie's junior yr was incredible I've never seen a guy score like he did
 
S

SpamburgerHamburger_rivals101482

Heisman
Nov 12, 2014
4,807
11,637
0
I don't care what team you play on, or what year player you are, or what abilities you have, if you score 54 in a game you're legit and I'll take Jodie on any team. It's close to a wash if you made me choose who I'd want. Murray has the ability to play the 1 also so that's hard to discount.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Riverslynn010
U

UKvisitor_rivals101449

All-American
Jan 3, 2007
18,099
8,602
0
I can't decide. Meeks going off for 54 against the 1st team I despised (still) was REALLY something. Remember, you don't get 54 with out some assists from the other players that realize it is your night. Did Murray ever get a game like that?
 
S

sluggercatfan

Heisman
Aug 17, 2004
35,953
29,631
0
Louis_Skunt said:
Murray all day.
Meeks was great, but he wasn't a solid ball handler and had too many turnovers in crunch time. After that UT game you could count on him driving through a crowded middle to get the ball stolen about 5 times a game. They were probably about equal on defense.
Click to expand...
No way...Jodie was a much better defensive player and if he come back for his senior year I think he may have become a lottery pick or for certain a 1st rounder
 
G

gossie21_rivals69805

Heisman
Jan 24, 2005
20,352
11,690
0
In the NBA I would definitely pick Murray.

Although keep in mind Murrays college coach didn't order players not to pass him the ball it screen for him.
 
S

School boy

All-Conference
Oct 29, 2007
5,506
3,865
0
Meeks was Kentucky the last 2 season here. Man if Meeks had Ulis while playing here we go to a FF, not lose to a bad IU team in the second round.
 
BlobUK

BlobUK

All-Conference
Oct 28, 2009
1,692
1,724
113
It's probably Jamal but I'd like to see Meeks with Tyler getting him the ball.
 
J

JonathanW_rivals

Heisman
Jan 3, 2003
145,534
15,709
0
I loved Meeks as early as his FR year.
But I might give the slight edge to Murray (better mid-range, attacking the basket, & ball-handling).
 
M

mustnotsleepnow

All-Conference
May 18, 2011
1,922
1,326
57
Shooting: Jamal Murray....this one is close, though. Meeks was a monster.
Scoring in multiple way: Jamal Murray...this one is easier. Murray scored in just about every way imaginable
Athleticism: Jamal Murray...easy here. I don't think I ever saw Meeks posterize someone like Murray did against South Carolina (?)
Defense: Meeks...We all know Murray wasn't the best defender. Meeks wasn't a beast on that end, but I remember him being able to shoot the gaps for a breakaway steal multiple times.

The answer is simple to me. Overall, Murray edges him out.
 
M

MPLGGBB

Sophomore
Feb 13, 2016
111
133
0
Murray had more talent around him and better coaching by far. While Meeks was a junior last time he wore a UK uniform, he was more able to carry a team and was a more consistent shooter. Many times, Murray didn't start hitting until the second half.
 
wcc31

wcc31

Heisman
Mar 18, 2002
27,068
88,876
98
Meeks as a junior was better than Murray as a freshman. Plus, Murray had Ulis setting him up while Meeks had Michael Porter. Think about that for a second.

I think if Meeks would've come back as a senior, he could've put up Hield-type numbers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kyjeff1
Bkocats

Bkocats

Heisman
Jan 2, 2011
80,908
70,033
67
wcc31 said:
Meeks as a junior was better than Murray as a freshman. Plus, Murray had Ulis setting him up while Meeks had Michael Porter. Think about that for a second.

I think if Meeks would've come back as a senior, he could've put up Hield-type numbers.
Click to expand...
not so sure that's would have happened, - the potential would have been there, sure, but maybe not the reality. Part of the reason Jodie did what he did his junior year was because of who else was on that team.
Senior year he'd have been playing with Wall, Bledsoe, Patterson, and Boogie. But I do believe, with Jodie on that team we'd have seen a FF at minimum - probably an NC
 
  • Like
Reactions: dckala2_rivals16641
L

Louis_Skunt

All-American
Oct 4, 2013
6,312
6,971
66
sluggercatfan said:
No way...Jodie was a much better defensive player and if he come back for his senior year I think he may have become a lottery pick or for certain a 1st rounder
Click to expand...
How can you talk about "his senior year" when Murray was barely able to play as a freshman?
 
D

dckala2_rivals16641

All-Conference
Aug 3, 2006
18,541
4,026
0
Jodie holds the single game scoring record. Jamal came and went through one season. Murray was also ice cold in the tourney when it counted.

Man if Jodie was on the wall team...
 
jrpross_rivals

jrpross_rivals

Heisman
Feb 21, 2008
17,592
36,202
113
STL_Cat said:
According to Dick Vitale he was.
Click to expand...
[roll]
wcc31 said:
Meeks as a junior was better than Murray as a freshman. Plus, Murray had Ulis setting him up while Meeks had Michael Porter. Think about that for a second.

I think if Meeks would've come back as a senior, he could've put up Hield-type numbers.
Click to expand...
Not a chance. He may have been the difference in a championship but he wasn't putting those numbers up with Wall & Cousins leading the way.
 
wcc31

wcc31

Heisman
Mar 18, 2002
27,068
88,876
98
Maybe not PPG but I think his metrics and %s would have been similar with Wall/Bledsoe setting him up.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Will Stein will not let Kentucky forget embarrassing loss to Vanderbilt
  2. 02 KSR Football Will Stein Let His Pal Ben Arbuckle Know That He Was Ready for a Trick Play
  3. 03 KSR Football Jordan Castell Loads Up on National Awards
  4. 04 KSR Football UK Fans of the Day want more College Football Playoff Projections
  5. 05 KSR Women's Basketball Kentucky makes AP Top 25 Preseason Women's Basketball Poll
Top Bottom