2026 B1G Tourney Session IV Thread

Dwayne_Johnson33

Redshirt
Jan 22, 2017
27
36
13
I thought Max had the TD on the mat return but listening to Pyles recap he said upon review the official clock was at 0.09 seconds when Rocco’s back first touched the mat on his granby attempt. If that’s a fact then I agree with the no takedown call.
 
  • Like
Reactions: F7Mello

Nitlion1986

All-Conference
Apr 13, 2024
1,228
3,706
113
that was a correct call on the illegal hold. No surprise that it was upheld on the independent review.

Manning is an idiot to challenge that, and then to bark at the refs.
I was watching the replay on the screen and it was obvious as heck. What surprised me was that Snyder was still screaming at the mat judge, who called it initially, after the review and the review left no doubts.

Heck Snyder was still screaming at him after the match.
 

WV lion

All-Conference
Oct 17, 2021
1,234
1,578
113
I was watching the replay on the screen and it was obvious as heck. What surprised me was that Snyder was still screaming at the mat judge, who called it initially, after the review and the review left no doubts.

Heck Snyder was still screaming at him after the match.
I think manning is a joke, general like Snyder, not sure from where they were sitting, they had the angle to see the figure 4
 

JoeBagobagels

Senior
Jun 24, 2025
682
797
92
This. From the time they hit the mat with 1 second left to the time the clock expires, McEnelly was in a control position. The entire time no matter where you stop it.

This is a classic bad official understanding of control (something you used to see mostly only at the lower levels of wrestling). You don't have to completely stop your opponent's movement to be in control. You have to gain control criteria beyond reaction time. Behind both arms, supporting points down, on top for a full second here. Welsh trying and failing to roll underneath does nothing to disrupt McEnelly's control.

Again, I retract the PSU slander. This is only the latest example of this problem, not the entire problem. Next time it may burn you guys and I will be just as mad!
Duke/Taylor last time, it happens. Ben asked that something to say about this. Just get your offense on early and don't depend on one last second call.
 

watoos

All-Conference
Oct 31, 2021
588
1,063
93
I have followed Penn State wrestling since 1969, travelled all across the country, mostly driving in the early years. I just watched one of the greatest semis and finals in Penn State history, I was off the couch watching most of the matches, yelling.

I click on this site and 90% of what I see is a bunch of whiners, you would have never made it through the Sunderland years, toughen up.

I'm still celebrating so that means I'm staying away from here for a couple of days, too much negativity gets contagious. Carry on, see you at nationals.
 

ElDuce

All-Conference
Oct 29, 2022
1,524
3,236
113

Not to dig up the Dead Horse. ☠️🫏
But Pyles states around 1146 mark that the replay official told him there was less than a second (0.9 seconds officially) when Rocco shoulders hit the mat. No takedown, disclaimer: the opinions of the host or the content of this episode, Don't necessarily reflect the opinions of the poster
 

GregPickel

Heisman
Staff member
Jul 25, 2021
43,492
93,326
113

Not to dig up the Dead Horse. ☠️🫏
But Pyles states around 1146 mark that the replay official told him there was less than a second (0.9 seconds officially) when Rocco shoulders hit the mat. No takedown, disclaimer: the opinions of the host or the content of this episode, Don't necessarily reflect the opinions of the poster

Ha, I just wrote this in a story that's about to be published. I feel like the argument for most is centering on whether or not it was a takedown, not whether or not there was any time left on the clock. Good for Pyles for getting an explanation.
 

gimb14

All-American
May 3, 2022
3,825
6,872
113
Sooooo Forrest only has 13 matches which means no RPI. Does that take him out of 1 seed discussion?
 

Shifty15

Junior
Nov 4, 2016
163
314
63
Simple question: what happens to Welsh if you take away that hand in that second. Does he fall on his face or does he magically levitate?

People with your mindset are killing the sport. This really isn’t about PSU at this point. It’s about the state of the sport. This is just one example out of a hundred this year where those idiots are butchering the sport.
Meanwhile you make it all about PSU. Man up and admit your bias!
 

PAgeologist

All-Conference
Oct 19, 2021
1,281
2,553
113
Tried multiple times to score PSU wrestling tix this year and each time tickets were into the hundreds of dollars per seat. Sure, tournament tickets dipped some in the last few week due to oversaturation of the resell market, but we had already made other plans for watching. I’m sure there are other people in the same boat, high interest in attending, but not dropping hundreds of dollars for one event.
I got my tickets for 125 ish a piece for the BIG tournament. They were upper deck, but still in the building.

I got 2 for the Nebraska match 4 rows back from the mat, just off center for around 100 each. We were right beside the Nebraska bench.

I know everyone has their different price points. I am simply putting out my experience.

I have to say, my wife and I both enjoyed the dual meet more than the tournament. The finals were nice to see in person, the remainder I would be perfectly happy to watch on TV.
 

Nitlion1986

All-Conference
Apr 13, 2024
1,228
3,706
113
This problem is happening precisely because the officials DONT want to live with human error. They’re trying to legislate tough calls out of the sport. That’s why we have the edge stall rules which suck. It’s why they’ve expanded reaction time to the point if the call is even close they can just say “reaction time” a punt on it.

They’re afraid of being yelled at. They’re afraid to do their jobs and that makes them unqualified to continue.

Do we really want to live in the world where you can plant someone on their shoulder with a mat return with a second left on the clock and it not be a takedown because of some theoretical reaction time that very clearly had no effect on the position? It helped you guys today. It might cost you a title tomorrow. So just evaluate it on the actual merits.
Good God, stop it. Penn State fans aren't the ones who changed the rule and don't have a say on the merits of it. Penn State kids (see Duke v Taylor or Mirasola v Feldman) have been on the receiving end of reaction time BS this year. The reaction time was a problem waiting to happen, but the behind standing caused an uproar so this is what we got.
As far as the OOB calls, go all in. If the wrestlers go OOB someone should be called, period. It seems as though 80 percent of most matches are wrestled at the edge. If I had been reffing that match I would have given the 3. But I also would have given Duke and Mirasola their TDs, as well several other ridiculous reaction time calls I have seen this year.
However, I wasn't at any meetings this year to hear what the emphasis is to be. Not awarding that TD seems to fall in line with the way they have called things this year.
 

NittanyChris

All-Conference
Dec 3, 2001
293
1,248
93
Marcus question... obviously the kid is All-World and I think he has a fantastic chance to win it all this season. That said, what are people's best guesses as to his reluctance to shoot on Davino? Was it too much respect for Davino's scrambling ability, too much reliance on his own amazing counterattacks, Davino's defense too strong, or something else?
 

El_Jefe

Heisman
Oct 11, 2021
2,859
10,567
113
Marcus question... obviously the kid is All-World and I think he has a fantastic chance to win it all this season. That said, what are people's best guesses as to his reluctance to shoot on Davino? Was it too much respect for Davino's scrambling ability, too much reliance on his own amazing counterattacks, Davino's defense too strong, or something else?
He's no more reluctant to shoot on Davino than on Ayala.

Blaze is primarily a counter wrestler. The best guys only give you so many counter opportunities. See also: Rocco Welsh.
 

Anon1683312534

Sophomore
May 5, 2023
150
141
43
I think manning is a joke, general like Snyder, not sure from where they were sitting, they had the angle to see the figure 4
Snyder=Manning Jr. Manning starts crying and one second delay Snyder starts crying.
He seems calm, but you dont

They are 1-1 but tbh Davino messed up last time. Can’t go to TB vs him
Davino messed up,I think Marcus had something to do with it. That's wrestling.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dogwelder

Anon1683312534

Sophomore
May 5, 2023
150
141
43
The truth is that Marcus should have lost his first match with Davino also. I don't think he actually has the offense to get to Davino, so I think if he wants to win the next one it's time to make that leap of faith and win a scramble or two. Right now Davino has a blue print: get a leg in each period, hang out there with it, and kill 30 to 60 seconds in each period and not allow Blaze to get his timing off. The next one to hang out on a leg in each period needs to be Marcus. These matches are RAZOR thin so you need that one little thing that Dake had against Taylor. In the first match that was Marcus winning that scramble to get that reversal. It goes to ride outs and it's not going to happen without a hail Mary
 

Anon1683312534

Sophomore
May 5, 2023
150
141
43
The truth is that Marcus should have lost his first match with Davino also. I don't think he actually has the offense to get to Davino, so I think if he wants to win the next one it's time to make that leap of faith and win a scramble or two. Right now Davino has a blue print: get a leg in each period, hang out there with it, and kill 30 to 60 seconds in each period and not allow Blaze to get his timing off. The next one to hang out on a leg in each period needs to be Marcus. These matches are RAZOR thin so you need that one little thing that Dake had against Taylor. In the first match that was Marcus winning that scramble to get that reversal. It goes to ride outs and it's not going to happen without a hail Mary
Reversals are part of wrestling not hail Mary's
 
Jun 26, 2025
869
763
93
This. From the time they hit the mat with 1 second left to the time the clock expires, McEnelly was in a control position. The entire time no matter where you stop it.

This is a classic bad official understanding of control (something you used to see mostly only at the lower levels of wrestling). You don't have to completely stop your opponent's movement to be in control. You have to gain control criteria beyond reaction time. Behind both arms, supporting points down, on top for a full second here. Welsh trying and failing to roll underneath does nothing to disrupt McEnelly's control.

Again, I retract the PSU slander. This is only the latest example of this problem, not the entire problem. Next time it may burn you guys and I will be just as mad!

I'm not saying "reaction time" wasn't correctly applied here under current rules (i.e., it's impossible to have a TD with less than 2 seconds on the clock regardless of whether you meet all criteria because it's inside "reaction time"). IOW, once McEnelly met the final portion of criteria by returning Welsh to the mat, the clock was inside a second but had not gone to zeros. McEnelly had firm control of Welsh as demonstrated by returning him to mat from a rear-standing position, Welsh hit mat prior to clock expiring and McEnelly never lost control of Welsh at any point including after they hit the mat (McEnelly was in firm control before and after they hit mat - never lost control in any way). Just don't see why "reaction time" really applies to the the situation.
 

cb1994

All-Conference
Oct 31, 2022
1,841
3,752
113
Reversals are part of wrestling not hail Mary's
It was a Hail Mary in the first match in thr sense that it was the only possible way he could win the match at that point and it required everything to go right in that exact moment including an elite opponent allowing for the opening. I think, as we’ve seen in both matches, that scenario favors Davino and it should be one Marcus takes steps to avoid by changing his approach.
 

Aardvark86

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
999
1,737
93
I’ll gladly take the other side here. Tom doesn’t need to show grace to someone who twice insulted him and then said he would be a coward for reacting accordingly.
Yeah, I don't really care that much about what happens here but I would note what my uncle charlie, who spent about 50 years in pro baseball, once told me about arguing with umpires. You can/should be able to say any word except one: "you". And that line was kinda crossed.
 
Last edited: