why we do have some good hitters- like Conner Powers, Russ Sneed, Duffy, etc. and why we have so few power hitters. The answer: Russ McNickle.
If you remember, MSU had a pitcher named Matt Lea, whose Dad used to pitch for the Expos and Twins and was a big time prospect. He was one of the best freshman pitchers I have ever seen at MSU, and I thought he would be a very high- maybe even first round type pick.
McNickle was simply incompetent as a pitching coach- his methods, or in some cases lack thereof- anyone remember the SPS on ice?- were making parents upset.
And sure enough, Lea was injured his Fr. year at State. His Dad was pissed off. He went to Polk and wanted McNickle fired, and Polk refused to do it. He instead offered to allow Lea to play first base instead of pitch. Lea then transfers to Louisville, where I believe he still plays. Of course a guy that has pitched in the Big Leagues for several seasons- I think Charlie Lea even threw a no-hitter- can have a lot of influence in the small baseball community. Basically, this incident sparked a reaction where MSU and Russ McNickle in particular got a reputation for ruining pitchers arms. That is NOT something you want to be known for. I don't care how good the bar-b-que in the LFL is.
And sure enough, more and more pitchers started to get hurt. In 2008, MSU's top three starters and their closer went down with injuries within the first three weeks of the season. The only pitchers MSU was able to get were guys like Devin Jones- who was a die hard MSU fan, and then you are left with getting the David Hayes of the baseball world.- guys with no other offers except from people like Samford.
As far as the rest of the baseball world- it was leaving Polk behind. He was hitting the threshold where he was forgetting more baseball than he knew. Polk was still recruiting exclusively out of his camp- and I truly believe that he forced Raffo to do so based on how Tommy is recruiting at Arkansas State. Most players are now going to showcases, although many still go to the school camps, but you can not exclusively recruit out of a camp. Hence, you miss a guy like Louis Coleman because "you never saw him pitch". Even LSU has to go out and find players- they normally don't come to you. Even if they did come to you, why not look around to see if you can find the best?
Notice that Cohen is recruiting a lot of athletes- lots of SS, CF types. Once those players get on campus, they will compete for a position in the lineup and Cohen will find spots for the best nine. Polk recruited differently in that he wanted someone that was specifically a third baseman, and would be the third baseman come hell or high water for four years- see Micheal Rutledge. You can't do that in college. Positions were promised and there was no competition. You simply had to "wait your turn". When you have guys that know that they are going to play if they make 40 errors and hit .150, they tend to not work as hard. With Cohen's method, you either perform or sit. And that includes defense to.