40 Million Americans Receive SNAP Benefits To Help With Food - Many Not American Citizens

Rastafarian

Junior
Aug 21, 2025
352
350
63
It’s not fake news. Are you denying illegals and non-citizens are on tax payer funded subsidies and programs?
No. Just like I’m not denying that billionaires and corporations get massive tax breaks and often never fulfill their requirements.

Are you equally as concerned about those who cheat on their taxes and rob this country of half a trillion dollars annually?
 

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
20,639
19,146
113
4.4% of SNAP (Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program) recipients are not U.S. citizens.This figure comes from the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Characteristics of SNAP Households report for Fiscal Year 2023, based on a quality control sample of about 40.1 million participants. It includes:
  • Refugees: 1.1% (434,000 people)
  • Other non-citizens (such as lawful permanent residents and other eligible immigrants): 3.3% (1.33 million people)
These groups total 1.76 million non-citizens, or 4.4% of all recipients. For context, 89.4% are U.S.-born citizens and 6.2% are naturalized citizens. Undocumented immigrants are ineligible for SNAP and not included.This is the most recent detailed breakdown available as of October 2025; participation rates can vary slightly by year, but citizenship distributions have been stable.
 
  • Like
Reactions: UrHuckleberry

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
20,639
19,146
113
so 4.4% of the program is for people that are not US citizens.

Let's start there. Then let's start by making it illegal to sell your snap benefits.

I hope this shutdown continues and this issue becomes front and center. It needs reform as do many of our other social programs.
 

MTTiger19

All-American
Sep 10, 2008
3,702
6,415
113
No. Just like I’m not denying that billionaires and corporations get massive tax breaks and often never fulfill their requirements.

Are you equally as concerned about those who cheat on their taxes and rob this country of half a trillion dollars annually?
There’s a big difference between a corporation that employs people getting a tax break and a lazy person that doesn’t want to work having everything paid for by taxpayers. Those aren’t the same. The billionaires and corporations are at least making an effort. I’m ok with providing subsidies to people IF they are trying. It’s obvious through SM and the numbers that we have a huge swath of people not even trying. They just take and take, I’m not ok with that. There’s a 1000 videos on SM of welfare recipients demanding their free stuff, exclaiming I work for them, showing off their 1000$ grocery trips, etc. Enough man.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TigerGrowls

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
20,639
19,146
113
No. Just like I’m not denying that billionaires and corporations get massive tax breaks and often never fulfill their requirements.

Are you equally as concerned about those who cheat on their taxes and rob this country of half a trillion dollars annually?

The tax cheats get me. I know people who are democrats and firmly in the upper class that will do shady **** to avoid taxes (Many republicans too I'm sure, I just don't have first hand knowledge of it).

Personally i advocate for a flat tax because the loopholes are just ridiculous. You have fatboy Pritzker that removed toilets from a house so he didn't have to pay taxes on it. He is a billionaire and wants everyone else to pay their fair share, but he pulls shenanigans so he doesn't have to live by the rules that he makes. The whole thing is ridiculous. Just make it a flat tax.
 

MTTiger19

All-American
Sep 10, 2008
3,702
6,415
113
so 4.4% of the program is for people that are not US citizens.

Let's start there. Then let's start by making it illegal to sell your snap benefits.

I hope this shutdown continues and this issue becomes front and center. It needs reform as do many of our other social programs.
Where’s the 4.4% coming from? Just haven’t seen that. Still too high imo. We aren’t in a position to be handing out things to anyone.
 

Rastafarian

Junior
Aug 21, 2025
352
350
63
There’s a big difference between a corporation that employs people getting a tax break and a lazy person that doesn’t want to work having everything paid for by taxpayers. Those aren’t the same. The billionaires and corporations are at least making an effort. I’m ok with providing subsidies to people IF they are trying. It’s obvious through SM and the numbers that we have a huge swath of people not even trying. They just take and take, I’m not ok with that. There’s a 1000 videos on SM of welfare recipients demanding their free stuff, exclaiming I work for them, showing off their 1000$ grocery trips, etc. Enough man.
So corporations and billionaires stealing from the govt is ok but poor people stealing from the government is not. Gotcha.
 

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
20,639
19,146
113
Where’s the 4.4% coming from? Just haven’t seen that. Still too high imo. We aren’t in a position to be handing out things to anyone.
4.4% of SNAP (Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program) recipients are not U.S. citizens.This figure comes from the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Characteristics of SNAP Households report for Fiscal Year 2023, based on a quality control sample of about 40.1 million participants. It includes:
  • Refugees: 1.1% (434,000 people)
  • Other non-citizens (such as lawful permanent residents and other eligible immigrants): 3.3% (1.33 million people)
These groups total 1.76 million non-citizens, or 4.4% of all recipients. For context, 89.4% are U.S.-born citizens and 6.2% are naturalized citizens. Undocumented immigrants are ineligible for SNAP and not included.This is the most recent detailed breakdown available as of October 2025; participation rates can vary slightly by year, but citizenship distributions have been stable.
Got that from GROK when i asked it directly what percentage of SNAP benefits got to non citizens.

Numbers come from US dept of Ag
 

Rastafarian

Junior
Aug 21, 2025
352
350
63
The tax cheats get me. I know people who are democrats and firmly in the upper class that will do shady **** to avoid taxes (Many republicans too I'm sure, I just don't have first hand knowledge of it).

Personally i advocate for a flat tax because the loopholes are just ridiculous. You have fatboy Pritzker that removed toilets from a house so he didn't have to pay taxes on it. He is a billionaire and wants everyone else to pay their fair share, but he pulls shenanigans so he doesn't have to live by the rules that he makes. The whole thing is ridiculous. Just make it a flat tax.

Yeah, it’s ridiculous. All of it is bad and hits us honest hardworking tax payers.
 

MTTiger19

All-American
Sep 10, 2008
3,702
6,415
113
Got that from GROK when i asked it directly what percentage of SNAP benefits got to non citizens.

Numbers come from US dept of Ag
Ok. This is what it gives me. That’s why I asked.
• % of SNAP caseload that is non-citizen: ~6% (USDA).


• % of SNAP households with a non-citizen adult: Higher (~15-20%), but still not 59%.


• Total SNAP spending on non-citizens: <10% of $120B annual budget.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rastafarian

MTTiger19

All-American
Sep 10, 2008
3,702
6,415
113
So corporations and billionaires stealing from the govt is ok but poor people stealing from the government is not. Gotcha.
I said different. Not ok. Those people aren’t stealing from the government. They’re stealing from you (if you work) and me. Many of them can work, and should. This is why I don’t agree with most liberals. I don’t believe in transferring wealth like that. Just because you had a kid here doesn’t mean I have to pay for it. Personal and individual responsibility and accountability. That’s what we want. Not nanny state.
 

Rastafarian

Junior
Aug 21, 2025
352
350
63
I said different. Not ok. Those people aren’t stealing from the government. They’re stealing from you (if you work) and me. Many of them can work, and should. This is why I don’t agree with most liberals. I don’t believe in transferring wealth like that. Just because you had a kid here doesn’t mean I have to pay for it. Personal and individual responsibility and accountability. That’s what we want. Not nanny state.
You conveniently omitted anything about the half a trillion dollars of tax evasion annually. That is a much bigger number than welfare fraud. And it’s also committed by those who already have significant means, versus those who are struggling. Neither is ok, but focusing your energy on the poor guy stealing $100 and not the billionaire stealing a few million seems misguided.
 

MTTiger19

All-American
Sep 10, 2008
3,702
6,415
113
You conveniently omitted anything about the half a trillion dollars of tax evasion annually. That is a much bigger number than welfare fraud. And it’s also committed by those who already have significant means, versus those who are struggling. Neither is ok, but focusing your energy on the poor guy stealing $100 and not the billionaire stealing a few million seems misguided.
Why not both. I say let’s team up and fix both of them. I’d gladly fight along side you to make sure corporations are paying their fair share if you’d fight with me to rid ourselves of waste and abuse. Honestly that would truly benefit you and I the most. But we are so divided and the powers that be intend to keep it that way.
 

MTTiger19

All-American
Sep 10, 2008
3,702
6,415
113
PPP loan forgiveness fraud was horrible. Of course IMO the economy should have largely remained open through Covid.
The crazy thing is I didn’t even know what that was. That’s how little I give a **** about those programs. That’s how much I think they will help me lol. I’ve heard some crazy stories about it recently though. Robbery.
 

Rastafarian

Junior
Aug 21, 2025
352
350
63
Why not both. I say let’s team up and fix both of them. I’d gladly fight along side you to make sure corporations are paying their fair share if you’d fight with me to rid ourselves of waste and abuse. Honestly that would truly benefit you and I the most. But we are so divided and the powers that be intend to keep it that way.
Hell yeah brother. 💯
 
  • Like
Reactions: MTTiger19

bdgan

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
3,104
3,103
113
without all the numeric gymnastics, isn't the question "should people in the country illegally be receiving federal benefits?" If the state wants to provide, that's fine and state taxpayers can ante up. Next up would be "should non citizens be receiving federal benefits" that's a tougher debate IMO.
The problem is they are given protected status which in the minds of many means they are not illegal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TigerGrowls

UrHuckleberry

Heisman
Jun 2, 2024
6,773
14,159
113
The crazy thing is I didn’t even know what that was. That’s how little I give a **** about those programs. That’s how much I think they will help me lol. I’ve heard some crazy stories about it recently though. Robbery.
100% robbery. I liked the general idea of helping people through a hard time, making sure that small companies kept their doors open, and kept their people paid, kept rent paid for bigger corps, etc etc etc, but there are so many stories of super in your face fraud. Like, drug dealer type ****. Pisses me off. Like, this is why we can't have nice things ha.
 

bdgan

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
3,104
3,103
113
No. Just like I’m not denying that billionaires and corporations get massive tax breaks and often never fulfill their requirements.

Are you equally as concerned about those who cheat on their taxes and rob this country of half a trillion dollars annually?
Tell us about the massive tax breaks that billionaires get.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TigerGrowls

bdgan

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
3,104
3,103
113
so 4.4% of the program is for people that are not US citizens.

Let's start there. Then let's start by making it illegal to sell your snap benefits.

I hope this shutdown continues and this issue becomes front and center. It needs reform as do many of our other social programs.
It's already illegal to sell SNAP benefits. That doesn't stop it from happening.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TigerGrowls

bdgan

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
3,104
3,103
113
Understood. Maybe we could have some stricter enforcement, harsher penalties if caught etc.
I think the penalties are harsh but I also think enforcement is difficult. IMO the problem could be solved by requiring people who use EBT cards to also show a government issued photo ID. We can't even require an ID to vote so I don't expect that to happen anytime soon.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TigerGrowls

bdgan

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
3,104
3,103
113
Went through this a couple weeks ago with you and you ran and hid. Feel free to look up my old posts if you want to re-engage.
IIRC correctly I received a copy and paste list from an internet search that was mostly about corporations and they weren't what most people would consider massive tax breaks anyway. So I asked to show pick one or two that we could discuss and I got nothing but crickets.

I suspect the bottom line is that you don't know.
 

Rastafarian

Junior
Aug 21, 2025
352
350
63
IIRC correctly I received a copy and paste list from an internet search that was mostly about corporations and they weren't what most people would consider massive tax breaks anyway. So I asked to show pick one or two that we could discuss and I got nothing but crickets.

I suspect the bottom line is that you don't know.
No, you are not recalling correctly. And yes, I do know. Some I will even use this year.
 

Rastafarian

Junior
Aug 21, 2025
352
350
63
You just can't remember any examples that you're willing to discuss? In other words you've got nothing.
No, I already gave you a bunch of examples. You can stop being lazy and search my history. It’s not my responsibility to keep feeding you info.
 

bdgan

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
3,104
3,103
113
No, I already gave you a bunch of examples. You can stop being lazy and search my history. It’s not my responsibility to keep feeding you info.
You can't point out one or two items and discuss them because you don't understand them.

Billionaires don't own qualified small businesses. They can't simply hold their investments in overseas brokerages and avoid U.S. taxes.

Face it. You've got nothing.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: TigerGrowls

Rastafarian

Junior
Aug 21, 2025
352
350
63
You can't point out one or two items and discuss them because you don't understand them.

Billionaires don't own qualified small businesses. They can't simply hold their investments in overseas brokerages and avoid U.S. taxes.

Face it. You've got nothing.
You clearly have no idea what you are talking about.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dpic73

baltimorened

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
1,762
1,384
113
No. Just like I’m not denying that billionaires and corporations get massive tax breaks and often never fulfill their requirements.

Are you equally as concerned about those who cheat on their taxes and rob this country of half a trillion dollars annually?
you used the term "cheat" rather loosely. Are you referring to those that actually lie on their returns on those who follow the tax laws and take all the allowances allowed? There's a big difference.
 

TheValley91

Heisman
Jan 20, 2013
20,337
17,351
97
Imagine blaming poor people for all of the countries problems and not those with the most power/money.

Some of yall probably root for owners in sports labor battles as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rastafarian

Clemblack

Heisman
Aug 6, 2008
7,361
13,668
56
Imagine blaming poor people for all of the countries problems and not those with the most power/money.

Some of yall probably root for owners in sports labor battles as well.


imagine being a proponent of buying votes while stealing from people their dignity and will to support themselves.
 

TigerGrowls

Heisman
Dec 21, 2001
38,485
28,787
113
They've already been here for 5 years, and I would think the great, great majority are here working and providing for their family. I mainly just think it is a non-issue, but don't care for creating a second class of citizen (even if for a specified period, and not trying to be antagonistic and say you're being cruel or elitist by saying second class citizen. But I mean just that, a citizen without all the rights or fully being considered a citizen).
Illegal aliens are not citizens.