Several interested posters asking questions, so I thought I would put some information out.
One of the major issues that is plaguing the non-athletic issues at MSU is how we distribute scholarships. Here are the issues that I believe are hurting us.
Ayers Admission Requirement
Nothing we can do about it, but you need to understand it. The Ayers decision states that all MS public universities have to have the same admission requirements. Obviously, this brings us down rather than brings others up. The big one to me is the 3.2 GPA on CPC courses and no ACT is needed. "Well, that's a B average," you say. When this was established, only about 25% of high school students in MIssissippi graduated with a 3.2 GPA. Now with rampant grade inflation, floor grades, etc., nearly 64% of students in MS are graduating with a 3.2 GPA or better.
No one would argue that a 3.2 GPA at high school A is different than a 3.2 GPA at high school B, but this universal requirement is allowing more students that aren't ready for college to go to college. MSU has several sections of remedial math and remedial English every semester. These are classes that do not count toward a degree. So we get these students that aren't ready for college, and they flunk out, which hurts our graduation rate.
But Ole Miss gets these students as well, you say?
Scholarship Matrix
We start giving scholarships to students who have a 21 ACT. Ole Miss doesn't give anything until a 23 ACT. There are a ton of students between a 21-23 ACT that end up at State because they get something. A 21 ACT with a 3.6 GPA at Mississippi State receives $14,000 in scholarships and they would receive $0 at Ole Miss. So if we have 500 freshmen in this zone, we commit $7 million of scholarship money to students. That's not even counting $4000 and $6000 offers for a 21 ACT with lower GPAs.
Mississippi State Promise
This sounds good on the surface, but it is attracting a less quality student. The Mississippi State Promise is a program that pays the balance after grants to Pell eligible students. This is regardless of academic excellence, so you have several students that get in without college ready ACT scores. If we have 500 freshmen in this program, we are committing $6 million to these students.
That's $13 million of scholarship money going to students that Ole Miss is giving $0 to. I would suspect that the graduation rate is significantly lower amongst these students as well. The 4 year graduation rate at MSU is 41% and the 6 year is 63%. OIe Miss is 68% and Auburn's graduation rate is 82%. Both Ole Miss and Auburn are giving out significantly more scholarship money and we are giving millions to students that hurt our academic ranking, and are a strain on our resources because they are having to take 6-12 hours of remedial classes.
Outside Competition
Not only is Ole Miss attracting the best and brightest in Mississippi, there are four schools that are really doing well getting students that MSU would have normally attracted.
Mississippi College - Has a program that guarantees free tuition for Mississippi residents
Louisiana Tech - waives out of state tuition for 24+ ACT, has a good engineering program + very generous with scholarships
South Alabama - waives out of state tuition for MS residents, has become a top three choice for Coast students and is now advertising heavily in Rankin and Madison Counties
Arkansas - SEC school that waives 90% of out of state for MS residents and has a good scholarship program for 25+ ACT
What Can We Do?
Here are some things I think that would help.
1. Match our scholarship matrix closer to what Ole Miss does. A 4.0 ACT/29 ACT student has a balance at Mississippi State, and they get a refund at Ole Miss. Many students and their parents are surprised about this. The reason we give less to higher achievers is that we are giving more to marginal students.
2. Put some sort of academic requirement on the Mississippi State Promise. Even if its a 21 ACT. Many students in this program are below 18 ACT and are not college ready. Our community colleges can help get them ready.
3. Waive out of state tuition for children of alumni. LSU does this and it keeps generations going to LSU.
4. Consider waiving out of state tuition for Memphis area students, and having a program that waives it for high achievers in border states.
One of the major issues that is plaguing the non-athletic issues at MSU is how we distribute scholarships. Here are the issues that I believe are hurting us.
Ayers Admission Requirement
Nothing we can do about it, but you need to understand it. The Ayers decision states that all MS public universities have to have the same admission requirements. Obviously, this brings us down rather than brings others up. The big one to me is the 3.2 GPA on CPC courses and no ACT is needed. "Well, that's a B average," you say. When this was established, only about 25% of high school students in MIssissippi graduated with a 3.2 GPA. Now with rampant grade inflation, floor grades, etc., nearly 64% of students in MS are graduating with a 3.2 GPA or better.
No one would argue that a 3.2 GPA at high school A is different than a 3.2 GPA at high school B, but this universal requirement is allowing more students that aren't ready for college to go to college. MSU has several sections of remedial math and remedial English every semester. These are classes that do not count toward a degree. So we get these students that aren't ready for college, and they flunk out, which hurts our graduation rate.
But Ole Miss gets these students as well, you say?
Scholarship Matrix
We start giving scholarships to students who have a 21 ACT. Ole Miss doesn't give anything until a 23 ACT. There are a ton of students between a 21-23 ACT that end up at State because they get something. A 21 ACT with a 3.6 GPA at Mississippi State receives $14,000 in scholarships and they would receive $0 at Ole Miss. So if we have 500 freshmen in this zone, we commit $7 million of scholarship money to students. That's not even counting $4000 and $6000 offers for a 21 ACT with lower GPAs.
Mississippi State Promise
This sounds good on the surface, but it is attracting a less quality student. The Mississippi State Promise is a program that pays the balance after grants to Pell eligible students. This is regardless of academic excellence, so you have several students that get in without college ready ACT scores. If we have 500 freshmen in this program, we are committing $6 million to these students.
That's $13 million of scholarship money going to students that Ole Miss is giving $0 to. I would suspect that the graduation rate is significantly lower amongst these students as well. The 4 year graduation rate at MSU is 41% and the 6 year is 63%. OIe Miss is 68% and Auburn's graduation rate is 82%. Both Ole Miss and Auburn are giving out significantly more scholarship money and we are giving millions to students that hurt our academic ranking, and are a strain on our resources because they are having to take 6-12 hours of remedial classes.
Outside Competition
Not only is Ole Miss attracting the best and brightest in Mississippi, there are four schools that are really doing well getting students that MSU would have normally attracted.
Mississippi College - Has a program that guarantees free tuition for Mississippi residents
Louisiana Tech - waives out of state tuition for 24+ ACT, has a good engineering program + very generous with scholarships
South Alabama - waives out of state tuition for MS residents, has become a top three choice for Coast students and is now advertising heavily in Rankin and Madison Counties
Arkansas - SEC school that waives 90% of out of state for MS residents and has a good scholarship program for 25+ ACT
What Can We Do?
Here are some things I think that would help.
1. Match our scholarship matrix closer to what Ole Miss does. A 4.0 ACT/29 ACT student has a balance at Mississippi State, and they get a refund at Ole Miss. Many students and their parents are surprised about this. The reason we give less to higher achievers is that we are giving more to marginal students.
2. Put some sort of academic requirement on the Mississippi State Promise. Even if its a 21 ACT. Many students in this program are below 18 ACT and are not college ready. Our community colleges can help get them ready.
3. Waive out of state tuition for children of alumni. LSU does this and it keeps generations going to LSU.
4. Consider waiving out of state tuition for Memphis area students, and having a program that waives it for high achievers in border states.
Last edited:
