According to Rolling Stone magazine, here are the greatest guitar players & their rankings: Feel free to agree or disagree!
- Thread starter TheGlovStillRules
- Start date
Best? Favorite? I can’t really evaluate best but I can tell you that David Gilmore is my favorite. I also really enjoy Tom Morello.
That’s one hell of a list. My current favorite is Gary Clark Jr. Johnny Lang is a favorite of mine also. Not saying they belong on this list, just very talented guitarists in modern times.
Tastes obviously vary but it seems to me that he was pretty groundbreaking with his style. Of course, I’m sure somebody in here will show me somebody that did Morello before Morello did Morello. And then somebody will name somebody that guy took from, and so music goes….…….. you would
Rolling Stone Magazine should stick to politics.
Brian May and Frank Zappa belong on that list and I know a lot of people don't like The Grateful Dead but I would add Jerry Garcia.
Big, big fan of Morello. I like guitarists that have a unique style that is easily recognizable, and he definitely has it. I'll add Alex Lifeson and Brian May to that list, among others.
Their #3 is my #1 ( I love Led Zeppelin!)
Their #1 is definitely top five.
Their #4 is good but way too highly ranked. (Joe Perry unranked is better.)
Their #9 made his entire career on one good solo in the Layla intro.
What no Kenny Wayne Shepard? Come on!
I am very surprised that they don't have any Metallica or Nirvana members in there since RS loves those two bands.
Prince should be on there just for his "Let's go Crazy" solo.
Their #1 is definitely top five.
Their #4 is good but way too highly ranked. (Joe Perry unranked is better.)
Their #9 made his entire career on one good solo in the Layla intro.
What no Kenny Wayne Shepard? Come on!
I am very surprised that they don't have any Metallica or Nirvana members in there since RS loves those two bands.
Prince should be on there just for his "Let's go Crazy" solo.
REO Speedwagon would be on my Mt. Rushmore of bands I’d like to put on top of Mt. Rushmore before blowing up Mt. Rushmore.
Richard’s at 4 is absurd. He shouldn’t be listed.
Page is my #1, Zep was my favorite band growing up. Responsible for some of the best riffs of all time! Love George Harrison, but no way he is better guitarist than SRV.
I saw Kenny Wayne Shepard a few years back in a very small venue. It was a great show.
Ritchie Blackmore should be in the top 10. Clapton is my favorite.
Personal note: I started playing guitar 3 years ago (February, 2019) and have played at least a half hour every day since. I am getting pretty decent.
Personal note: I started playing guitar 3 years ago (February, 2019) and have played at least a half hour every day since. I am getting pretty decent.
Last edited:
Sorry...if there is no Rory Gallagher....then the list is officially disqualified....
No argument with Hendrix #1. He was light years ahead of his generation.
After that it falls into personal preference/tastes.
I have long had SRV #2 But you could put Page Clapton EVH in any order and be ok.
Townshend is a great guitar player but his skill as a lyricist storyteller and arranger probably overshadows his raw guitar talent.
One glaring omission-Prince. Dude coukd shred.
After that it falls into personal preference/tastes.
I have long had SRV #2 But you could put Page Clapton EVH in any order and be ok.
Townshend is a great guitar player but his skill as a lyricist storyteller and arranger probably overshadows his raw guitar talent.
One glaring omission-Prince. Dude coukd shred.
Last edited:
Three of their top 20 (Clapton, Harrison and Young) are in this clip with Dylan.
Tony Iomi makes me think he's playing the bass at times, he plays it so heavy.
Prince
Prince
Jeff Beck and SRV are both too low on that list- and Mark Knopfler should be on it
Yeah he needs to be fairly high up on that list
This list doesn't get on my nerves as much as I expected it to, but Derek Trucks has no business being on the list and Alex Lifeson has no business being left off the list.
I could go on but really, that is the main problem.
I could go on but really, that is the main problem.
#9 made his career on the Layla solo? Oh my. You might want to listen to Live at the Fillmore East just once before making that statement, or perhaps know that he was the driving force behind one of the best bands in American music history, Btw, Clapton gives him credit for the genius behind most of the Layla album. #9 is known as the best slide guitar player of all time. One good solo, omg. Prince is a great call.
These lists become silly.
Had the great pleasure of seeing Zappa in 89 or 90 at the Warner Theater in DC. ( I have seen twelve on the aforementioned list multiple times ) The experience was all that and then some. Truly remarkable surrounded by a bunch of jazz and rock talents that just ripped the roof off.
Zappa totally belongs in the conversation along with Garcia. Heck, I could even add in at this point numerous other Jam Band guitarists, Billy Strings, multiple blues guitarists since the list includes a few among others.
Too many for 20 and personal preference ( Van Halen, no ) is different for everyone.
It's all opinions.
I agree Zappa and Garcia both pushed the rock very far up the mountain for others, but not that commercial unfortunately. I cherish them both.
I also think Van Halen is easily top five. He changed the world and brought us 6 multiplatinum smash albums. He wrote hits showcasing his jaw-dropping talent. Destroyed the world on tour. He's royalty. IMO