Bat selection is never given as much concern as it should. I have not used a bat in many years so I can't speak to any current brands. I do think the bats they used last year were horrible. As a hitter you should find the bat that best fits you. I would not care in the least what bat we were provided by the school. When I was there my first year we were supplied by Worth (Tennessee Thumpers) and I absolutely could not find a bat I liked. I was first using a Wilson Indestructo then found the green Easton and used that throughout my time at MSU. Now other guys used Thumpers and loved them. So if it is the bat, it is ultimately the players fault. I would fight the coaches or administration if they tried to force me to use a tool I felt was inferior.
When I went to the minors all those years ago they asked us what bat we wanted ordered for us. I was like, I have not used a wood bat in 4 years how can I possibly tell them that. It was even an after thought for a professional team. I don't accept a good hitter can hit with anything. There is a tool that fits them best and they need to find it.
Ted Williams told a story in his book The Science of Hitting how he used a 35in/33oz bat of a certain model. Here is an excerpt describing his thoughts on the subject:
"I think you will find as we go along that much of what I have to say about hitting comes down to your own self-education: thinking it out, learning the situations, knowing your opponent and, most important, knowing yourself. You, the hitter, are the greatest variable in this game, because to know yourself takes dedication. Today that's a hard thing to have. Today ballplayers have a dozen distractions. They're always on the run. In the old days we didn't fly, we rode the train. We might be 10 to 12 hours on a train, and much of the talk was hitting. We didn't have television, we didn't have a lot of money to play around with. We lived in an atmosphere of baseball. We talked it, we experimented, we swapped bats. I was forever trying a new stance, trying to hit like
Hank Greenberg or
Jimmy Foxx or somebody, and then going back to my old way. I recommend that for kids. Experiment. Try what you see that looks good on somebody else. Try different bats, a bigger handle, a bigger barrel, anything.
My preference was a light bat. I treated my bats as though they were babies. I boned them. I used to take them to the post office to check their weights. I ordered 33-ounce bats, but they'd come to 33 1/2 ounces, maybe 34, so I always checked. I'll never forget, Mr. Hillerich of Hillerich & Bradsby Co., the
Louisville Slugger company, put six bats on a bed one time. One was half an ounce heavier than the others. He had me close my eyes and pick out the heavier bat. I picked it out twice in a row."
Bat selection is critical to hitting.