Auburn should be a better job, and I think they are.
It’s very debatable at present time. When considering all factors, I think its a wash. Again, Hugh Freeze is struggling hard right now, and he’s doing so without Saban at Alabama. He did much better at OM. Now, part of that was OM going above and beyond in the cheating / pay-for-play before it was legal, and now that advantage is no longer there for him. But, he wasn’t the first HC overseeing that operation in Oxford, and still had far more success than anyone else there until Kiffin.
When looking at the whole picture, including expectations, annual schedule, in-state competition / rivalry, salary, and quality of life, it’s really hard to argue that Auburn is the better job. I mean, would you rather have to recruit in-state against Alabama and play them and UGA every year….or recruit in-state against MSU and play them and LSU every year? It’s a no brainer to me.
Even if Auburn was still a better job, its not so much better that it is a great decision to jump from OM. Neither Auburn nor OM are Top 10 jobs. Leaving the #15 job to take the #12/#13 job (at best) isn’t really a great idea for most folks.
Auburn is 50% larger than Ole Miss, and is ranked better, and is realistically better, academically.
Auburn used to be literally double the size of OM as recently as 15-20 years ago. You now have 27,000 undergrad at Auburn and around 19,000 at OM. That number has closed substantially, and enrollment size really doesn’t matter all that much as far as quality of job for a football head coach.
Academic rankings? That means less than nothing to a football coach, and if anything higher academic standards can be more of a hinderance than a benefit to recruiting quality players.
In football, they even have at least two bona fide national championships, and several others that they claim.
Auburn has one bona fide national title in the modern era, again from cheating their asś off to sign the most physically dominant college football player in history. That’s no longer an option that’s on the table for them, so its ancient history at this point. They were still really lucky to get that one, if you think back to the Iron Bowl meltdown with the 25 yard forward fumble from Ingram, Broomfield dropped pick 6, etc.
Overall, they're a much better sports school but are having a dip at the moment. They're temporarily suffering the Freeze Effect.
Their “dip” may be more of a new baseline in the post-portal/NIL world. They’ve never been special without brazen cheating. Look no further than 2010 or their early 90’s teams as evidence of this.