Let me give a little perspective from my little corner of the world. I am about to retire from a civil service job that went sour so I will be retiring at a lower-than-expected income with my military retirement check, taking early social security, and then the civil service check. After taxes I will take home around $3000 maybe $3,100 a month. My mortgage is around $1,550 a month. That's about half of what I'm taking home. Then, when you factor in the other bills, I will be doing a part-time job still paying taxes into the system to make ends meet. If you give me two thousand more dollars a month for a basic income, I will not do that part-time job therefore not giving into the system. Is this anecdotal? Yes but, I will bet there are a lot more people out there like me who will do that so, you will have a lot more of them taking than giving.