Better

shu67

Senior
Jun 12, 2021
992
727
93
I thought the officials were bad and Sha did not use the press enough in this game. When we used it we rattled them Bigly!
 

SeanieWard

Freshman
Jun 15, 2023
37
54
18
I’ve been calling for Sha to give Dolinski some run. Being that I’ve been worried about your big men, I figured now is the time to find out who’s who and boy am I glad he was forced to play him last night. That was not a fluke people. He’s a keeper. He’s played against pros and it shows. The fact that he’s a freshman makes it all the more impressive and I’d consider him foundational, along with Tyndale coming in next year. He might be our best big man right now along with Williams. Maybe I’m wrong but I don’t think Cope scores, rebounds or defends as good as Dolinski showed

Lastly, as much as we all called for Petro to be our starting PG, his defense is atrocious and he’ll be targeted going forward. Luckily, Trey Parker is a heck of a defender and may have to see extended time at PG depending on the matchup

I think we have a chance to be good folks. Let’s build on that good effort!
 

Seton75

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2001
37,282
3,840
113
This was a very good performance.

We.were roughly 16 point underdogs
Without our Center
With no production from our guards other than Parker
On the road to a top 20 SEC team

A ton to take out of this performance.
We turned them over a ton.
We outrebounded them in 2nd half.
We got a really bad whistle
Early season sub patterns as Sha is trying to figure out combos led to two decisive runs.

Jones cannot continue to play this poorly.
Parker played strong
Parker and Petro play well together

We have options at the bigs which we were all worried about after the first two games
Many players including our leading scorer were apparently illamnd gutted it out.

Petro is very good in pick and roll
WIlliams and Dolinski look good in those sets as well. That can be a real weapon this season.


A lot to take away from this game.
YES. EXACTLY!!!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: mbraue and shurup86

Piratz

All-Conference
Mar 24, 2004
1,831
3,592
113
I’ve been calling for Sha to give Dolinski some run. Being that I’ve been worried about your big men, I figured now is the time to find out who’s who and boy am I glad he was forced to play him last night. That was not a fluke people. He’s a keeper. He’s played against pros and it shows. The fact that he’s a freshman makes it all the more impressive and I’d consider him foundational, along with Tyndale coming in next year. He might be our best big man right now along with Williams. Maybe I’m wrong but I don’t think Cope scores, rebounds or defends as good as Dolinski showed

Lastly, as much as we all called for Petro to be our starting PG, his defense is atrocious and he’ll be targeted going forward. Luckily, Trey Parker is a heck of a defender and may have to see extended time at PG depending on the matchup

I think we have a chance to be good folks. Let’s build on that good effort!
Oh yeah, they hunted Petrovic on defense.
 

shu67

Senior
Jun 12, 2021
992
727
93
I’ve been calling for Sha to give Dolinski some run. Being that I’ve been worried about your big men, I figured now is the time to find out who’s who and boy am I glad he was forced to play him last night. That was not a fluke people. He’s a keeper. He’s played against pros and it shows. The fact that he’s a freshman makes it all the more impressive and I’d consider him foundational, along with Tyndale coming in next year. He might be our best big man right now along with Williams. Maybe I’m wrong but I don’t think Cope scores, rebounds or defends as good as Dolinski showed

Lastly, as much as we all called for Petro to be our starting PG, his defense is atrocious and he’ll be targeted going forward. Luckily, Trey Parker is a heck of a defender and may have to see extended time at PG depending on the matchup

I think we have a chance to be good folks. Let’s build on that good effort!
I think you are way too hard on Petro regarding his defense. He was against a very talented Alabama backcourt and he got little help from his teammates when they drove to the basket. They shot a lot of free throws and it was not all Petro's doing.
 

Seton75

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2001
37,282
3,840
113
Time to start Dolinski at the 4. Move Fischer to the 3 where he belongs and put 2.0 on the bench.
I want to see 2 bigs and also 2 bigs plus Fisher as needed. I dont think I start them. Bama killed us off the biards first half. 2 O rebounds they got (from good bounces) lead to that 2nd chance 3 that always seems to hit). But one of the main things the Bama coach talked about was that we outrebounded them in the second half.

Another good game for the bench with 39 pts. And 16 rebs, almost half the total. And Parker and Jones had 6 of our 13 assists. Great contributions.
 

SPK145

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2001
1,606
3,678
113
This was an encouraging loss, if there is such a thing.

The defense in the first half was extraordinary until the 5-minute mark, then it fell apart.

If Copeland played, Dolinski doesn't get that run and Seton Hall is probably worse off.

This is a bizarro team: Offense is supposed to be better, defense not as good but it's just the reverse.

Also in the bizarro world, Petrovic and Dolinski were not supposed to be that good.

3-point shooting at this point is almost as bad as last year.

Del Jones almost scored, one of his shots even hit the rim.

Wilcher, Brown, and Thomas were supposed to bring 3-point shooting? Um, nope.
 

dehere23

All-Conference
Feb 28, 2015
2,094
2,407
113
I think Wilcher will have a very long runway with Sha. Whether that is deserved will be seen, but I think it is a fact. Sha believes in Wilcher like he believed in Dawes it seems. And as long as Wilcher plays defense he wil get 25 mpg.
Which is exactly why he will play - defense. Many have problems adjusting to what Sha wants, but Wilcher has already played for demanding, defense-focused coaching. Plus why not bet on him starting to look at least like the guy from two years ago. It isn’t like we have a plethora of better options.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Piratz

The_Hall

Senior
Feb 23, 2025
638
510
63
November is a crazy time in college basketball with the era we're living in. Teams are figuring things out. It's a small sample size even for KenPom to be our guide.

But Dolinski just went in there against the 6th biggest team in the country and hand a day. Alabama is crazy athletic and with depth and run you ragged with their style. Very impressive.

Why the guy only played 7 minutes total in the first 2 games (albeit with 6 points scored even in that), IDK. This is the first I've seen him have extended play and he definitely can give us something up front as a rotational piece. Pretty smooth and crafty around the rim.
he could finish, catch, pass, make quick decisions. it was clear within 3 seconds of watching him. meanwhile i saw kabba for far too many minutes vs Charlotte be completely inept.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mbraue

NIL BAD

Senior
Aug 15, 2025
452
412
63
Wilcher's defense is decent but not elite by any stretch. He doesn't rebound or do anything to open up the offense. We need a lot more out of him than the guy from 2 years ago to have a successful year but based on his 4 year stats, he is what he's always been is at this point. Still time to step up though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PirateBlue08

PirateBlue08

All-Conference
Jul 25, 2025
1,388
1,278
113
Petrovic
Anderson
Fisher
Dolinski
Williams

Is this currently our best lineup with Parker as 6th man off the bench?

We lose basically nothing having Wilcher play less minutes aside from some ball handling with Fisher at the 3, but make up for that in having two very capable ball handlers on the court in Petrovic and Anderson. And we add a ton of size, rebounding, and defense up front.

For small ball lineups we can easily switch back to Fisher at the 4.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NolanK13 and shu67

Seton75

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2001
37,282
3,840
113
Why not go cope, williams, fish?? Fish isnt a 4. How much longer do we need to see it. Not his fault but we are so small
I dont start that trio, but I want to see them on the court together if a larger lineup is needed. I think Fisher and DW have enough skills to play away from the hoop, let Cope stay low. On D, could be more of a challenge. But I'd like to see it.
 

Section112

All-Conference
Feb 4, 2003
488
1,201
93
Potter and Sha definitely have it out for each other. It's been going on for a few years and noticeable. Bama was much more aggressive going to the hoop and we had a hard time handling their size and their two stars. I would expect them to have more FTs but that was a big disparity and the phantom foul on Wilcher at the end was egregious.
 

Seton75

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2001
37,282
3,840
113
Also he would have had 10 assists if guys could have made their shots, some were point blank too!
Petro made a dumb drive at a critical time at the end. Parker made a dumb drive leading to Bamas last 1st half points. People miss shots, people make bad decisions. If they dont, they probably didnt play.
 

mbraue

Senior
Mar 2, 2010
268
485
63
As he should, IMO. He has the most talent and big time experience of all the guards and wings. It shows. But he's not assertive offensively and acts like a role player. He needs to be setup better. He's also an excellent defender.

Let’s face it. To date, Wilcher has been an Omega.
Not sure what is going on with his outside shot, really off from 3.
He should attack the basket more, just to get himself going. He is a good free throw shooter.
This was an encouraging loss, if there is such a thing.

The defense in the first half was extraordinary until the 5-minute mark, then it fell apart.

If Copeland played, Dolinski doesn't get that run and Seton Hall is probably worse off.

This is a bizarro team: Offense is supposed to be better, defense not as good but it's just the reverse.

Also in the bizarro world, Petrovic and Dolinski were not supposed to be that good.

3-point shooting at this point is almost as bad as last year.

Del Jones almost scored, one of his shots even hit the rim.

Wilcher, Brown, and Thomas were supposed to bring 3-point shooting? Um, nope.
In fairness, Thomas getting very little playing time. He needs more PT as does Rodney Brown.

Sha made a strange comment to Jerry Carino that he needs to get Thomas to "understand this is big-boy basketball." Sometimes he gets big-eyed out there and that comes with reps." Hoping he gets the reps and more comfortable because we need his shooting. He's an excellent 3-point shooter and driver to the hoop. Among the top 3 Ivy players while at Dartmouth getting to the foul line.

Nice to see Dolinksi getting extended time - you can see the difference in him getting comfortable with how he played yesterday. Hoping the same happens for Thomas and Brown.
 

PirateBlue08

All-Conference
Jul 25, 2025
1,388
1,278
113
Wilcher is a career 5-6 ppg guard. Why does everyone think he should be so much better than that?
He has never progressed and people would rather suppress the playing time of players who are actively breaking out rather than suppress his in hopes he will meet expectations.

I say Parker Petrovic and Anderson have earned their time. And I’d rather see Sha try Fisher at the 3 with two bigs than force Wilcher to be the smallest 3 in the country and Fisher the smallest 4
 

halltheway

Senior
Jan 17, 2003
398
614
93
I like Dolinski....with limited playing time, under his hat, he still was offensive minded.... and didn't mind roughing it up under the boards.
Hope he gets his minutes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NYC Pirate

HallGuy2323

Senior
Jun 3, 2020
1,074
838
113
He has never progressed and people would rather suppress the playing time of players who are actively breaking out rather than suppress his in hopes he will meet expectations.

I say Parker Petrovic and Anderson have earned their time. And I’d rather see Sha try Fisher at the 3 with two bigs than force Wilcher to be the smallest 3 in the country and Fisher the smallest 4

No chance Shaheen makes a change. None.
 
Seton Hall Pirates

Latest

  1. 01 Rivals 4-star PG Javion Tyndale commits to Seton Hall
  2. 02 Rivals Basketball Recruiting 4-star PG Javion Tyndale down to 6 schools
  3. 03 Women's Sports Highly-recruited 2027 prospect Ava Womack breaks down recruitment
  4. 04 Women's Sports Highly-recruited 2027 prospect Eni Oyedeji breaks down recruitment
  5. 05 On3 Basketball LMU transfer guard Rodney Brown Jr. commits to Seton Hall