First for HD6: Thank you for the kind offer, however I actually like Stansbury and wouldn't want people to confuse me with the current holder of the name.
For others (e.g., Patdog, etc),
I have no problems with a conversation starting along the lines of "hey, the BC is great and has these benefits...", but I have a problem with the "real fan" comment.
A couple of things I would like to point out: First, I am a current member, but that does not mean prior to 3 months ago I was not a "real fan." Understandably, paying dues and what not is NOT the only way to support a team. Since becoming an Alumni, I have yearly contributed to MSU's dept of Psychology and ROTC (the two associations I spent the most time in.)
MSU is not an athletic program where people attend school. It is a school that has an athletic department. To say that you must contribute even a penny towards an athletic club is your ticket to fan-dom is silly! You can be a huge, die-hard fan of the entire university! Hell, when I pursued a law degree and PhD in Clinical Psychology, I left the state because I refuse to attend "that school in the north."
In the Army, I occasionally come across Soldiers who say things like "well, if they really were patriotic, they would enlist too." I vehemently disagree with that statement also. And the you didn't vote so don't ***** analogy is flawed too. I did not contribute to the <span style="font-style: italic;">Breast Cancer Society</span> so I guess I can be called an advocate FOR the disease since I am not financially contributing to the fight. Judging someone's beliefs and values based on how much money/time they contribute is a very slipperly slope and I urge everyone to steer clear of that. Does the fan that contributes 8.34/mo more of a fan than 8.33/mo?
Long and short of it, the "real fan" comment was silly and uncalled for. I bleed Maroon and White and have made emotional sacrifices many on this board never will (e.g., do you have any idea how hard it is to be an MSU fan while being in command of a 99% Arkansas unit!!! Those a-holes are crazy!!)
Last question: Of the hundreds of student-athletes at MSU, how many of their parents are BC members? Guess those who are not cannot be considered fans.
TD
---------
PS-I'm not the short one.