I didn't read this full thread but the committee members are not aligned on this then and aren't acting like a committee.
Watching the 2 games on CBS today they interviewed a committee member during halftime, I believe it was, on national television (probabaly a clip somewhere) to which he said they DO NOT look into injuries on rankings using UCLA as an example who has now has 2 key players injured.
Why look at injuries as factor for selection but not for rankings in the tourney? Besides , Simpson came alive the last 2 games and should of been noticed.