Final roster spot - you taking Griffen or Aberdeen?

[noncomposmentis]

If it comes to that…..

I think I’d prefer Griffen (I’m assuming he’d look more like the Alabama version of himself in this offense), but I think most folks would take Aberdeen…..

 

[*Fox2Monk*]

If it comes to that…..

I think I’d prefer Griffen (I’m assuming he’d look more like the Alabama version of himself in this offense), but I think most folks would take Aberdeen…..

I’d go Aberdeen he is ready to break out and played very well with Championship experience. I know that Griffen has final 4 experience too, but Aberdeen played better last year.

 

[ImTheVillageIdiot]

Easy Griffen.

 

[Wunky]

I’d take Aberdeen by a nose, but would be just as happy with Griffen. They are very similar players.

 

[MdWIldcat55]

Yes.

I’m taking Griffen or Aberdeen. Either one would be a terrific addition, superior to the other realistic options that have floated by in the past couple weeks.

 

[MbergCat]

Whichever one wants to be a Cat.

 

[seccats04]

If we get either of these guys I’ll be pumped because they’re both really good college players.

 

[Tubbyfan78]

I trust Pope, so if he takes them, I’ll get behind it. However, up front, both feel like a step back from Jax or Brea.

 

[Dead Cat Bounce]

Between Aberdeen and Dioubate, we'd have two players with big chips on their shoulders against the SEC teams that recruited over them. Could make for an interesting dynamic.

 

[DaDirtyLeb69]

Griffin fits what we need more for the roster, but I think Aberdeen in a enhanced role could be very good

 

[ImTheVillageIdiot]

I trust Pope, so if he takes them, I’ll get behind it. However, up front, both feel like a step back from Jax or Brea.

Jax’s shooting numbers are almost the same as Griffen’s. Yes, we won’t have a Koby Brea but we also had difficulty getting Brea shots because that’s almost the only thing he did.

 

[bookerfan66]

Jax’s shooting numbers are almost the same as Griffen’s. Yes, we won’t have a Koby Brea but we also had difficulty getting Brea shots because that’s almost the only thing he did.

Griffen had one year he shot well outside. The other 2 were early 30's.

 

[ImTheVillageIdiot]

Griffen had one year he shot well outside. The other 2 were early 30's.

Posted career shooting percentages in my other post

 

[Untouchables22]

Griffen for the likely higher 3 % and better defense. But I’d be happy with either.

 

[ImTheVillageIdiot]

Griffen had one year he shot well outside. The other 2 were early 30's.

https://www.sports-reference.com/cbb/players/jaxson-robinson-1.html



https://www.sports-reference.com/cbb/players/rylan-griffen-1.html

Their career 3 point averages are within 0.02 of each other.

 

[Mattcg]

Both

 

[chasingwildcat]

Both will be starter if comes here

I will take whoever comes first

 

[Tprinceuk]

I take Aberdeen, his defense is great can play backup point and is a good shooter.

 

[BlueWorldOrder74]

We need both right now.

 

[ImTheVillageIdiot]

We need both right now.

I don’t see Pope taking both. Sisk didn’t think so either. You take too many and you get defections

 

[DaDirtyLeb69]

We need both right now.

Nawh they need one. Both would make the roster very overcrowded

 

[jessieshorts8]

Aberdeen is the better defender from I have seen so I would take him. But I am holding out hope for a different guy that is unlikely to happen.

 

[noncomposmentis]

Hmmm. Just saw an NBA scout say he’d take Aberdeen easily over Griffen - says Aberdeen will be all SEC if he ends up at Kentucky…..

 

[DaDirtyLeb69]

Aberdeen is the better defender from I have seen so I would take him. But I am holding out hope for a different guy that is unlikely to happen.

Can I ask a honest question? How can you look at the potential roster, with a dude like Oweh coming back, and think oh this roster is missing a stud or they absolutely have to get one?

 

[ImTheVillageIdiot]

Hmmm. Just saw an NBA scout say he’d take Aberdeen easily over Griffen - says Aberdeen will be all SEC if he ends up at Kentucky…..

Yeah but we aren’t choosing in a vacuum for the better player overall. We need to fill a specific role.

 

[DaDirtyLeb69]

Hmmm. Just saw an NBA scout say he’d take Aberdeen easily over Griffen - says Aberdeen will be all SEC if he ends up at Kentucky…..

Who is said NBA scout

 

[ImTheVillageIdiot]

Can I ask a honest question? How can look at the potential roster, with a dude like Oweh coming back, and think oh this roster is missing a stud or they absolutely have to get one?

Don’t forget Jayden Quaintance. And I think Lowe will be a stud too

 

[jessieshorts8]

Can I ask a honest question? How can look at the potential roster, with a dude like Oweh coming back, and think oh this roster is missing a stud or they absolutely have to get one?

I love Oweh but think the team needs another scorer/shooter. JMO

 

[DaDirtyLeb69]

I love Oweh but think the team needs another scorer/shooter. JMO

They do, but does that shooter have to a stud level player? Or do we need a player who understands the role and can hit timely shots?

 

[DaDirtyLeb69]

Don’t forget Jayden Quaintance. And I think Lowe will be a stud too

True, and people keep forgetting what Jasper can become

 

[Panthur]

We need both right now.

I see it your way. At this point except for Kam Williams who ‘s experience is only one year in a weak conference, we haven’t replaced the perimeter firepower of Jaxson Robinson or Lamont Butler or Koby Brea or Ansley Almonor. Multiple threats get each other open. Single threats, run the weave.

 

[CincinnatiWildcat]

I think Kam Williams will play a similar role to Robinson at BYU before he came here. I would rather have another ball handler like Aberdeen than Griffin personally.

 

[DaDirtyLeb69]

One thing the portal has done for peoples mindsets on roster buildup, is change the way people view the natural progression of most college players. A lot are forgetting dudes like Chandler, Noah, Perry, Oweh, etc make huge jumps in most cases in year 2 in the program. The portal is the new shiny toy, so we think we gotta get something new every time, when in reality the portal should be used to fill holes, instead of be a complete roster building/overhaul technique. I’m guilty of doing all this at times as well. But guys likes Chandler oweh, and garisson make jumps when they have been in the program a couple of years.

 

[Tubbyfan78]

Jax’s shooting numbers are almost the same as Griffen’s. Yes, we won’t have a Koby Brea but we also had difficulty getting Brea shots because that’s almost the only thing he did.

That's not true at all. Jax's shooting splits were all significantly better. And Breas were even better. Again, I trust Pope so if he thinks those guys can do it, all good.

 

[senonesy]

I’m taking the guy that was in the game at clutch time in the National Championship game just a couple weeks ago.

 

[DaDirtyLeb69]

This dude acting like he has a damn clue what’s going on is hilarious

 

[justin_uk_5]

Aberdeen 100%.

 

[noncomposmentis]

I would rather have another ball handler like Aberdeen than Griffin personally.

Is the difference in handle significant? I agree, without a clearcut backup 1, another dude comfortable with the ball would be useful

 

[ImTheVillageIdiot]

That's not true at all. Jax's shooting splits were all significantly better. And Breas were even better. Again, I trust Pope so if he thinks those guys can do it, all good.

Dude I literally posted their career shooting numbers and they were within 0.02 of each other, even after Jax’s 37.4% 3pt career season this year. Go look at it yourself.

 

[Coach Marrow]

This dude acting like he has a damn clue what’s going on is hilarious

I love that guy