Fire Franklin. This is coaching malpractice!/Combined complaints post UCLA

MaconNitt

All-Conference
Oct 18, 2016
1,093
2,029
113
Franklin has mentioned Sunday scrimmages a couple times. My only guess about Singleton is that our tackling (and specifically our LB play) is so bad that it’s possible Singleton breaks a lot of long runs during practices and scrimmages. Maybe our coaches see that and expect it in games.
I believe the Sunday scrimmages are for the players who didn't play on Saturday.

They have invested in playing 2 RB's. They already are some what predictable on offense. Lets only put Singleton in on obvious passing downs and make the offense even more predictable, that'll fix it 🙄
 
  • Like
Reactions: Psu00

NitneLiun

Junior
Oct 4, 2003
253
391
63
What are the chances the AD can negotiate a new buyout price and structure and persuade Franklin to resign at the end of the season?

Even Franklin must realize at this point that his position at Penn State is untenable.
 

Midnighter

Heisman
Jan 22, 2021
10,956
17,612
113
The podcast with Audrey Snyder hinted that it wasn’t all Sandy’s doing on the 10 year deal; hinted that is was the wish of the BOT Chair at the time and Sandy just made it happen. Can’t recall who that was or more importantly, why they felt the need to extend Franklin right after his loss to Illinois. USC may ave been kicking the tires, but that ended once 8 OT’s went south.
 

RolexKong

Freshman
Aug 15, 2025
66
55
18
The podcast with Audrey Snyder hinted that it wasn’t all Sandy’s doing on the 10 year deal; hinted that is was the wish of the BOT Chair at the time and Sandy just made it happen. Can’t recall who that was or more importantly, why they felt the need to extend Franklin right after his loss to Illinois. USC may ave been kicking the tires, but that ended once 8 OT’s went south.
Matt Schuyler. For some reason, Franklin had him twisted around his finger. Who knows? Maybe Franklin had a set of pictures before the people at Hilton did.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Midnighter

m.knox

Senior
Aug 20, 2003
520
572
93
Once again, Franklin throws the players under the bus. Blames them for doing uncharacteristic things. Like he has coached them and they failed to carry out their assignments. I'm a bit tired of his lack of transparency.

He did it early on here. "The plays work better with better players." He's a f'ing idiot.

He should have been fired the second he stepped off the plane. He had it all this year, and HE didn't execute.
 

BobPSU92

Heisman
Aug 22, 2001
41,133
30,346
113
Meanwhile Belichek buyout is under $30 million. Thanks Sandy. I hope JF sent you to Tahiti after he signed the contract

 
  • Like
Reactions: Bwifan

MrTailgate

All-Conference
Oct 19, 2021
923
1,732
93
Why would Franklin and his agent renegotiate a buyout and lose money? He holds all the cards here.
He does and I hope this doesn’t happen but I could see that any adverse reaction to his family would make him seriously consider stepping aside. He’s a good man from everything you see and rightfully will not take any blowback that his family receives.

Penn St is such a fishbowl and it has to be really difficult on family members of the coach and staff.

There are things that come with the territory but saying things to him when he’s with family is off limits.
 

LB99

Heisman
Oct 27, 2021
8,143
11,070
113
He does and I hope this doesn’t happen but I could see that any adverse reaction to his family would make him seriously consider stepping aside. He’s a good man from everything you see and rightfully will not take any blowback that his family receives.

Penn St is such a fishbowl and it has to be really difficult on family members of the coach and staff.

There are things that come with the territory but saying things to him when he’s with family is off limits.
Yeah. I see where you are coming from. If anyone does anything stupid towards him or his family they are low life with serious mental issues and should be lawfully punished to the fullest extent of the law.
 

Ram20

Senior
Jul 29, 2013
464
892
93
He does and I hope this doesn’t happen but I could see that any adverse reaction to his family would make him seriously consider stepping aside. He’s a good man from everything you see and rightfully will not take any blowback that his family receives.

Penn St is such a fishbowl and it has to be really difficult on family members of the coach and staff.

There are things that come with the territory but saying things to him when he’s with family is off limits.
NvM
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
1,995
1,339
113
A couple seasons ago I got lambasted on the board for posting JF was the worst game day coach in FBS....how about now?
He's one of the worst with time management (pretty sure he took lessons from Tomlin)
Worst game day coach is tough--But I wouldn't have attacked you for it. I think he's in that discussion. Dabo's pretty awful too these days if we're just talking good programs.
 

baltimorened

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
1,625
1,230
113
I’ve defended James, but I now believe he must be replaced. The lack of effort is indefensible. That “Jim Knowles” defense disappeared. Allar played his *** off. The rest of the offense? Meh. There is no fight in James. He shows no fire at all.
I don't think the Knowles defense works with our personnel. We don't have the Dtackles like Ohio state. You can't win if you're giving up 5 yard up the middle on first down
 

Wilbury

Freshman
Oct 28, 2021
45
51
18
Baloney. The schoool will hemmorage $ by leaving him in place. He should have been flown home separately from the team.

I think Singleton is completely checked out - so move him down the depth chart.

And get Grunk ready. For IHC, Terry Smith.
Kraft isn't making this decision with a $50 mil buyout on the line.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SkiSkiSki

bwc

Freshman
May 22, 2014
57
82
18
" Hey Terry, Pat here, how does Pegula Stadium sound to you? I was thinking $60 million for the naming rights guaranteed for the next 5 years, with right of first refusal after the original 5 year period. We could really use your help getting out from under a bad contract extended by our former visionary AD."
 
  • Like
Reactions: 84lion

Calabrin

All-Conference
Oct 16, 2022
1,487
1,771
113
Franklin has mentioned Sunday scrimmages a couple times. My only guess about Singleton is that our tackling (and specifically our LB play) is so bad that it’s possible Singleton breaks a lot of long runs during practices and scrimmages. Maybe our coaches see that and expect it in games.
That might hold up early in the season, but after three, four games of it not carrying over to Saturdays, and meanwhile the other guy is tearing it up, you have to yield to empirical evidence.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Psu00

Calabrin

All-Conference
Oct 16, 2022
1,487
1,771
113
The team's performance has absolutely nothing to do with the fan base. Most of the fan bases of top schools are no different and their teams aren't consistently underperforming their talent this bad because of their fan base's entitled attitudes. So comments about the fan base are completely off target and serve no purpose.
I confess I feel entitled to beat 0-4 teams that average 14 points a game when my team has National Championship aspirations and the highest paid coaching staff in college football.

I'm definitely being unreasonable.
 

84lion

Senior
Oct 7, 2021
552
908
93
" Hey Terry, Pat here, how does Pegula Stadium sound to you? I was thinking $60 million for the naming rights guaranteed for the next 5 years, with right of first refusal after the original 5 year period. We could really use your help getting out from under a bad contract extended by our former visionary AD."
"Now, this, class, is a superb example of creative thinking!"
 
May 11, 2012
357
471
63
How does that work in the NIL era?
You can have strong DLs and OLs while not playing smashmouth football
The issue is the scheme--how much of that is on AK vs CJF is the real question--thought given the past OCs it sure feels like it's Franklin
For the record, I'd love to run Georgia's offense for example
Every D1 player dreams of a NFL career....will the NFL speak nice and soft when you screw up and get penalties at critical time? Will you stay in the game if you lose down after down to the man across from you? NIL simply means the players are semi-pro....only thing the current players care about is playing time and winning, reason tOSU, Georgia, and a few others get the best players to develop them for the NFL. We don't have the speed on the OL to run counters and sweeps....defense flows faster. Why we never switch to zone blocking, hat on hat, and run straight at them with KA amazes me....Best teams are able to switch their attack to confuse the defense.
As for AK vs CJF....we have had successful OCs join the staff and the song remains the same....and ..the one constant is.......
 
May 11, 2012
357
471
63
I am of the opinion that a team's collective emotional efficacy is impacted by a program's fan base. We disagree; no worries.
In my opinion.....the fact we are conversing without name calling is good. There simply is no absolute perfect game plan...the plan that wins today was best for that opponent... but may fail the following week. That is why putting your players in their best position to win is essential. In reality, every play is a mini game...you win enough plays you win the game.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
1,995
1,339
113
Every D1 player dreams of a NFL career....will the NFL speak nice and soft when you screw up and get penalties at critical time? Will you stay in the game if you lose down after down to the man across from you? NIL simply means the players are semi-pro....only thing the current players care about is playing time and winning, reason tOSU, Georgia, and a few others get the best players to develop them for the NFL. We don't have the speed on the OL to run counters and sweeps....defense flows faster. Why we never switch to zone blocking, hat on hat, and run straight at them with KA amazes me....Best teams are able to switch their attack to confuse the defense.
As for AK vs CJF....we have had successful OCs join the staff and the song remains the same....and ..the one constant is.......
To be clear, I agree with you regarding most of this. Kaytron should get 20-25 carries a game. couldn't agree more and about the constant.
The difference is college players are always free agents--they can literally just redshirt if they want until they've exhausted it and walk away from the team. They can portal in a moment.
And, yes, this is semi-pro which is why Dejuan Lane shouldn't have a scholarship today if we truly practiced for the onside kick as the insiders claim.
some NFL coaches (see Tomlin) are players coaches and don't get in their face which explains a lot unfortunately about the Steelers lack of real success
 

12375CAT

All-Conference
Feb 15, 2012
87,717
1,249
113
You shoulda seen what they were posting on the Wolverine & Nut boards before they each turned it around. Even our Cat board if filled with discontent now just 3 seasons removed from the B12 championship. Pile on him all you want to it is only just a matter of time before HCJF (also) gets it done @ Beaver Stadium. I'll be so happy for HCJF just like I was for HCRD @ the Shoe((y))
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: MacNit