Here is the thing about Perkins, which none of you have mentioned.
ITs the difference between he and Robinson...AND Shump.
Perkins has no vision. If there is a hole directly in front of him, he will get his yards and look impressive doing so. He also does fairly well in the option pitch game, again because he doesnt have to make a decision on which way to go. If there is no obvious hole, he will not gain yardage...just straight into the scrum. He is an outstanding pass catcher out of the backfield. He should have always been a 3rd down or long down and distance back. He is not a base running back.
Our insistence on using Perk as the primary the last 2 years has as much to do with our offensive ineffectiveness, if not more, than anything else. We haven't had a base running game in 2 years, since Vick left. We saw a glimpse of it Saturday. Had we gone Robinson and Griffin at RB last year, we would have fared better. Especially with a pocket QB.
Robinson and Shumpert have outstanding one-cut ability and vision to find the lane. The make yardage out of nothing...or chicken salad out of chicken { }
Again, Perkins is a good football player, we are just using him wrong. We seem to have a hard time deciding who our best players are and using them. Find out who your 17ing horses are and ride them. Instead we rotate players randomly all game hoping someone will make a play. Robinson and Shumpert need to get the ball 70/30 on 1st and 2nd downs, and Perk needs to be the 3rd down and 5+ yards back.
DeRunnya needs to be playing 70/30 with Morrow. Jameon all game, spelled by Ross occasionally, and Ross in on 4 WR sets. Rojo and Fred Brown on a 80/20 split. Hopefully RoJo and Malcolm stop dropping the ball, because they are 2 of our better athletes. And I could go on and on about the route running from our WR...but I will save that for another day.