If you take the maroon glasses off and look at his resume objectively. Not many national championship coaches out there and available.
You also have to objectively look at what time of year it is that they are having to make the hire. Fall practice is over. They are hitting the lull / dead period between fall camp and preseason practices. They have no chance to hire a sitting HC from a high level program at this time, those guys are all pot committed to 2026 at their current schools. This is the same predicament we had when we got stuck rolling the dice with Cannizarro in November 2016.
Devil’s advocate - if they hired Lemonis….and he takes them to 3 straight CWS, maybe wins it or maybe doesn’t (doesn’t really matter) then proceeds to have the exact same last 4 seasons as he had at MSU, there’s no way you wouldn’t still call that a massive success.
An in-house hire who came up under Vitello still might make more sense. But if there’s no one they like…the above scenario also makes sense.