Lineman grading out question....

gtowndawg

Senior
Jan 23, 2007
2,203
581
113
from bdj....

Biscuit: There has been much debate across Bulldog nation this week about the lack of solid play on MSU's right side of the offensive line. Well, there wasn't any debate by the MSU coaches that grade the film. Only two offensive linemen graded out as champions in the season opener and one was right tackle Addison Lawrence (86 percent grade). The other was left tackle Derek Sherrod (89 percent grade). Lawrence also played more snaps than any other O-linemen with 52 snaps, not bad for his first career start. Lawrence also told me the offense used about 50 percent of their normal plays and formations in the season opener.

Does anyone know what a Randy Thomas or a Floyd Womak would have graded out at? No one gets 100 of course, but I'd like to know how to compare the above numbers to some of the o-line greats. A measuring stick of sorts...
 
Nov 17, 2008
1,519
0
0
Grading is based upon your execution of your assigned duty. Keep in mind that blocking schemes are often based upon a player's ability to execute.

For example, you may have a play where the center and guard are supposed to double-team a defensive lineman. They are double-teaming because the coach doesn't have confidence in his center's ability to single-block the defensive lineman. If successful in their double-team, they have done their job on that play, which helps their grading.

However, if the coach thought the center and guard were worth a ****, he would have the center single-block the defensive lineman and the guard would go block someone else such as a linebacker. Their grade would be based on that assignment.

Therefore, one lineman's 85 grade doesn't always equal the same as another lineman's 85 grade because one could have had a much tougher assignment (lots of single-blocking, very little double-team help).
 

rugbdawg

Redshirt
Oct 10, 2006
5,251
0
0
and center were only supposed to block one man together. The theory is to block that one guy into the linebacker or combo off of the defensive tackle. You are graded that way as well. If you double a guy 4 yards back, but the linebacker makes the tackle in the backfield, you Rule 17ed up.
 
Nov 17, 2008
1,519
0
0
The whole guard/center scenario was purely hypothetical to be used as an example, not some exact play out of the playbook. Nevermind, maybe I'm not explaining it well.
 

rugbdawg

Redshirt
Oct 10, 2006
5,251
0
0
very rare where a coach would design a play for two blockers to only block one defensive player.
 
Nov 17, 2008
1,519
0
0
I don't disagree with you. That has nothing to do with my example. I did a poor job of explaining it. I am trying to show the difference in degree of difficulty in carrying out your said assignment. I could have used the example of 200 MSU football players blocking one Millsaps drum major versus an example of offensive tackle Michael Henig single-blocking Shawne Merriman of the San Diego Chargers. Neither situation will ever happen or is in anybody's playbook.</p>
 
M

msucivilen

Guest
I remember it because he hit the linebacker so hard that he up-ended the guy......and it wasn't one of those blindside blocks...it was head on.

Craig Jenkins did ok....he had a good block where he pulled and bascially took out two defenders on Elliot's TD run.

Anybody notice that Reed Freeman was the snapper for the field goal tries? WTH are we wasting a scholarship on Field then.

Disclaimer: All said blocks or good OL plays were against JSU.