He wanted to play both and OM was his first choice. He was dating Jill Rosamond, Micheal Rosamond's sister (I realize I probably don't have to tell you Todd, but for those that don't know, Micheal played BB at OM). She was at OM, he had every intention of following. I am pretty sure he had an opportunity to play baseball at OM but when he tanked during his senior year, his football offer was pulled. I half jokingly mentioned MSU to him and he was pretty quick to dismiss it. Memphis told him he could do both.
JWS didn't choose anyone over Beaver. Beaver just wasn't coming to MSU.
As for Skelton, to say he had some academic issues is like saying Dontae Walker had some drug issues. Skelton literally made a 7 on his first test at MSU. Great guy, but not bright.