Napier / Stricklin Theory

BulldawgFan

Senior
Oct 7, 2013
293
615
93
If all of the rumors are true regarding the inevitable firing of Napier, why would Stricklin wait to pull the trigger until after our game?

It's simple. Stricklin is throwing a bone to his alma mater.

Florida winning or losing appears to have no bearing on Napier's firing so Stricklin is allowing the uncertainty to fester. This only benefits Mississippi State.

I don't actually believe this, but apart from Stricklin just bungling this whole situation (likely), it's a possibility.

And 17 Cohen for good measure.
 

Drebin

Heisman
Aug 22, 2012
21,490
25,034
113
If all of the rumors are true regarding the inevitable firing of Napier, why would Stricklin wait to pull the trigger until after our game?

It's simple. Stricklin is throwing a bone to his alma mater.

Florida winning or losing appears to have no bearing on Napier's firing so Stricklin is allowing the uncertainty to fester. This only benefits Mississippi State.

I don't actually believe this, but apart from Stricklin just bungling this whole situation (likely), it's a possibility.

And 17 Cohen for good measure.
If Stricklin wanted to help his alma mater, he would've fired Napier last week. That would've created more opportunity for the team to quit. As it stands, they may come out fired up to win for their coach.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
56,705
26,039
113
I’m glad you don’t actually believe that. They’re firing him Sunday because of the bye week. I think this decision was made before they beat Texas and before Penn St fired Franklin too. Should have just done it last year. And yeah Stricklin has bungled this pretty badly.
 

BulldawgFan

Senior
Oct 7, 2013
293
615
93
If Stricklin wanted to help his alma mater, he would've fired Napier last week. That would've created more opportunity for the team to quit. As it stands, they may come out fired up to win for their coach.
I could be wrong but it seems like teams play with more fire under an interim coach as opposed to a lame duck. At least short term.

Our baseball team certainly played better once Lemonis was fired. The record didn't show it but it seemed like the football team played with more fire once Arnept was gone.
 

BulldawgFan

Senior
Oct 7, 2013
293
615
93
I’m glad you don’t actually believe that. They’re firing him Sunday because of the bye week. I think this decision was made before they beat Texas and before Penn St fired Franklin too. Should have just done it last year. And yeah Stricklin has bungled this pretty badly.
This actually makes the most sense. I didn't consider the upcoming bye week for them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog

Drebin

Heisman
Aug 22, 2012
21,490
25,034
113
I could be wrong but it seems like teams play with more fire under an interim coach as opposed to a lame duck. At least short term.

Our baseball team certainly played better once Lemonis was fired. The record didn't show it but it seemed like the football team played with more fire once Arnept was gone.
Not if they love their coach. Florida has continued to play hard throughout the drama about Napier's job security. Obviously in the Lem situation he didn't have respect of the team.
 

Villagedawg

All-Conference
Nov 16, 2005
1,973
1,931
113
Of course this is correct. This is part of our master plan of putting the Mississippi State Cabal in place to be in control of the SEC and national college football, working the long game to manufacture a MSU national championship domination. Professional coaches, athletics and University administrators, and on field officials always do their well paying jobs with the intention to secretly benefit the high school or college they attended 20 to 30 plus years ago. That's why Jackie always sabotaged the Alabama game, Dabo would never really TRY to beat Alabama, Stricklin is secretly using Florida to help Mississippi State. They never just try to focus and do their best at the job they have. They are just like Freddie Fan and make every decision based on what's best for the school they attended. Why do you think Saban never scheduled Kent State? I think we all know why!*
 

onewoof

Heisman
Mar 4, 2008
14,886
12,992
113
I want to be in the room when the Cohen epic powerpoint rant happens to explain why he should be hired and not fired.
 

o_Hot Rock

Senior
Jan 2, 2010
1,833
761
113
I do not think it has anything to do with Stricklin or us... It's just the right time.. Bye week next week for Florida which gives interim coach a chance to reset somewhat. If you look at roster construction of both teams, they should beat us by a 3 scores easily but no win is good enough to save him. He gone
 

johnson86-1

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
14,301
4,814
113
I’m glad you don’t actually believe that. They’re firing him Sunday because of the bye week. I think this decision was made before they beat Texas and before Penn St fired Franklin too. Should have just done it last year. And yeah Stricklin has bungled this pretty badly.
He has, but I'm not sure how much of the last couple of weeks are his fault. He completely 17ed up firing Mullen without having a good backup plan. Too bad he didn't have experience from earlier in his career, possibly in a different sport like basketball, where he could have learned the dangers of firing a solid if not great coach without having good candidates ready. Give a good AD a learning experience like that, and he won't 17 it up the same way again but I guess loafers never had the opportunity to learn a very painful lesson like that.

Then, because he 17ed up firing Mullen without a plan, he let Sunbelt Billy's agent bend him over a barrel and gave him a 7 year, $50M+ deal with a stout buyout.

Then, because he got bent over a barrel by Billy's agent, he didn't want to pull the trigger after year 3 because of the buyout, so he convinced boosters to put that money to NIL instead. In fairness, Florida has had some brutal schedules, and there were signs Billy was going in the right direction last year, beating a ranked Ole Miss and LSU, at the end of the season before beating up on a terrible FSU team and then Tulane in a bowl game. On the other hand, the margin of victories in the losses to good teams probably shouldn't have been outweighed by beating Ole Miss and LSU teams that had some solid wins but just weren't top tier teams.

The rumors getting out this week may realistically not be in his control. He's got to get commitments from boosters, and it's hard to hammer the people ponying up millions for your mistakes for having loose lips. If I was being asked to donate 7 figures because Scotty was over his head, I'd probably be bitching and moaning about it to people too.

So I get trying to line everything up to transition during the bye week to save what they can of the rest of the season, and I get those rumors getting out publicly before they should. But that bed was probably made by his prior decisions, not anything he 17ed up in the last week. Hell, the boosters may be blabbing because they are pissed at him and want him to look bad so there is pressure to get somebody else in charge of the firing process.
 

MStateU

All-Conference
Nov 15, 2009
933
1,926
93
If he wanted to throw a bone to his alma mater he could have not left in the middle of a football season costing us our baseball coach and us hiring an incompetent AD who held the school back and allowed one of the best coaches ever to walk out the door.
 

Chile

Freshman
Oct 30, 2023
56
90
18
Cohen about to be in his own coaching search.
I wonder if he will get to use his 50 point checklist, that the Auburn writers talked about prior to offering Kiffin and Freeze. Seems item number on on that checklist was "call yella fella". Point number 2, was "do what he says and throw the other 48 items away".
 

Bulldog from Birth

All-Conference
Jan 23, 2007
2,492
1,061
113
If I’m Billy, when I get asked about all this by sideline reporters on the Saturday telecast, I’m claiming “the AD and President both gave by me their complete and total support and backing just last night. I’m grateful to have it, and it meant so much to me.”
 
  • Like
Reactions: Villagedawg

L4Dawg

All-American
Oct 27, 2016
10,266
7,120
113
If Stricklin wanted to help his alma mater, he would've fired Napier last week. That would've created more opportunity for the team to quit. As it stands, they may come out fired up to win for their coach.
Yep
 

mcdawg22

Heisman
Sep 18, 2004
13,169
10,768
113
If Stricklin wanted to help his alma mater, he would've fired Napier last week. That would've created more opportunity for the team to quit. As it stands, they may come out fired up to win for their coach.
Agreed, especially in the portal era. How many of them would have checked out and went straight to the portal.