OT- 9mm vs 45ACP

summersatthelake

Freshman
Jan 24, 2006
448
68
0
"summersatthelake, post: 2697728, member: 8064"]About 4 years ago I started selling/trading my handguns in various calibers and then purchased handguns (all Sigs) in 9mm..."

I also find Sigs addicting, especially the German made Sigs.

There is a clinical work for that addiction...it is called Signess
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tarheelhusker

summersatthelake

Freshman
Jan 24, 2006
448
68
0
:Cool: ok, ok, perhaps the wrong terminology(tumble) the first time I shot a 45 the bullet missed a stump I was shooting at by 20 feet going up through a canopy of trees. the hillbilly that owned the gun said they will do that once in while. maybe you should just not go target practicing with me. my second shot went right between two knots.

You must have been shooting a Glock :)
 

inthedeed

Sophomore
Mar 28, 2009
6,752
193
63
Hmmmm, were you anticipating recoil or limp wristing? Bullets go straight, may not hit the target but straight. I've never heard of them going up unless the muzzle is pointed up.

What make does the Hillwilliam own?
sorry, it has been over 20 years. I'll never forget the look in his eyes though.
 

rez dog 70

Heisman
Sep 11, 2011
156,596
36,863
113

Here's a stock photo of my baby.
 

Tarheelhusker

All-Conference
Mar 28, 2003
21,599
1,109
3
sorry, it has been over 20 years. I'll never forget the look in his eyes though.

Understood! I shouldered my buddies 10 gauge about 20 years ago. Like you, I'll never forget the look in his eyes or that I spun about 80 degrees to the right. I thought my shoulder fell off. I grabbed my 870 12 ga wingmaster & spent the rest of the hunt firing from my hip. My shoulder looked like a defibrillator had been on it overnight.
 

Tarheelhusker

All-Conference
Mar 28, 2003
21,599
1,109
3
Say, that's sweet red rover. Bet she's a smooth shooter also!
What type of holster does she ride in?
 

rez dog 70

Heisman
Sep 11, 2011
156,596
36,863
113
Love the CZ lineup also! Great Offerings.

I best go to the gun forums before the mods run me off.
Thanks fellas

No worries. Everybody's pretty cool.
Hey, I found a real pic of my baby...

https://vault.myvzw.com/webcs/app/share/invite/HCaUXtWw4B

And she shoots great. The trigger is crisp and lite. I was at the range a few days ago and put five rounds inside a 4 inch group @25 yards. I got a whole magazine center mass in the 10's (A) @50 yards. It's a great shooter.
 

Tarheelhusker

All-Conference
Mar 28, 2003
21,599
1,109
3
That's terrific red! I knew that 1911 trigger would be smooth, I didn't know you were that good sendin' 'em down range!! Great results becoming one with your weapon.

Before I forget, that holster is tailor made for your pistol, looks great. With a good belt, she probably snugs right up to your body. Thanks for sharing!
 
  • Like
Reactions: rez dog 70

rez dog 70

Heisman
Sep 11, 2011
156,596
36,863
113
That's terrific red! I knew that 1911 trigger would be smooth, I didn't know you were that good sendin' 'em down range!! Great results becoming one with your weapon.

Before I forget, that holster is tailor made for your pistol, looks great. With a good belt, she probably snugs right up to your body. Thanks for sharing!

I had a good instructor. My father was a Marine after all. Smokin

Here's at the 7 yard range...
https://vault.myvzw.com/webcs/app/share/invite/IjgZICPaO1
 
  • Like
Reactions: newAD

candid

Sophomore
Sep 5, 2004
87,316
115
0
Right now i carry a .40 s&w. Imo that is too big. I'm looking at either a 380 or 9mm. Just because my 40 cal is so big and bulky let me know what you think
The 1911 came out after the Span/Amer war, Rebs were so hopped up that the 38 then carried req 2 or more hits to bring some down. The 45, hit him anywhere w one shot and the dude is out of the game. Cop friend of mine, yrs ago, said cops didn't carry the 45 to replace the 38 because they were to deadly and unforgiving. Made sense to me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sparky4986
A

anon_umk0ifu6vj6zi

Guest
Nope. Glocks only. .45 or 9mm now. We went away from 40 cal quite a few years ago for a few reasons.
Care to share why? I like the .40. SA SDS in 40 is my new every day carry. I carry an XDM in 40 when hunting the mountains, or anywhere where there may be predators not scared of challenging a human if they feel threatened.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sparky4986

newAD

All-American
Oct 14, 2007
15,429
5,006
0
Care to share why? I like the .40. SA SDS in 40 is my new every day carry. I carry an XDM in 40 when hunting the mountains, or anywhere where there may be predators not scared of challenging a human if they feel threatened.


First I what I typed before, I should clarify. Officers who had 40s can still carry them, but the most recent recruit class had to choose between the 45 and 9, and that is the way it will be until it changes......(when I got hired, we couldn't carry the 45 because they were worried about the cost of that ammo) An officer that already had a 40, can not replace it with a new 40.

I can't give you the exact reasons why, as I wasn't on the committee that made that recommendation that was approved. With a governmental agency, cost (of ammo) is always an issue, and it seems our department always wants to get down to only having to buy 2 types of ammo. The cost of the weapons is not an issue as each officer has to buy their own.

I have heard of some people having issues with the Glock 22 and 23s (40 cal models). I've had it explained to me that these frames are basically the same frame as the 9s, and they wear faster due to the increased pressure of that round. Again, just something I've been told but can't confirm.

So as to exactly why my department made that decision, I can't give you the specific reasons why, I just remember hearing there was more than one. I'll ask one of the guys who would know and reply when I get the chance to talk to him.

I'd imagine that this article would likely be some of the reasons:

http://www.tactical-life.com/firearms/7-reasons-cops-choose-9mm-40/
 
A

anon_umk0ifu6vj6zi

Guest
First I what I typed before, I should clarify. Officers who had 40s can still carry them, but the most recent recruit class had to choose between the 45 and 9, and that is the way it will be until it changes......(when I got hired, we couldn't carry the 45 because they were worried about the cost of that ammo) An officer that already had a 40, can not replace it with a new 40.

I can't give you the exact reasons why, as I wasn't on the committee that made that recommendation that was approved. With a governmental agency, cost (of ammo) is always an issue, and it seems our department always wants to get down to only having to buy 2 types of ammo. The cost of the weapons is not an issue as each officer has to buy their own.

I have heard of some people having issues with the Glock 22 and 23s (40 cal models). I've had it explained to me that these frames are basically the same frame as the 9s, and they wear faster due to the increased pressure of that round. Again, just something I've been told but can't confirm.

So as to exactly why my department made that decision, I can't give you the specific reasons why, I just remember hearing there was more than one. I'll ask one of the guys who would know and reply when I get the chance to talk to him.

I'd imagine that this article would likely be some of the reasons:

http://www.tactical-life.com/firearms/7-reasons-cops-choose-9mm-40/
Thanks. Was just curious.
 

BigBL87

Senior
Sep 11, 2006
3,853
452
0
I personally went 9mm, the main reason being cost of ammo. I can afford to practice alot more with 9mm than with .45 ACP. All the handguns I own (S&W Shield, CZ P07, and CZ-75B) are in 9mm for commonality of ammo, but I do hope to get a 1911 in .45 ACP in the future. Just love 1911's, and if I'm going to get one it is going to be in the "original" caliber.

I wouldn't feel undergunned with either caliber. With quality defensive ammo (Speer Gold Dot, Federal HST, Hornady Critical Duty/Defense, etc.), the 9mm is more than adequate when it comes to stopping ability. Yes, the .45 makes a bigger hole, but with modern ballistic technology the gap really has closed in stopping ability to the point where it really is personal preference, especially when you consider the benefit of capacity with 9mm.

I'm waiting for my concealed carry license to come in, once it gets here my Shield and P07 will share carry duty. My CZ-75B has nice wood grips, and I think it'll stay on show and range duty. We'll see how long it takes, Illinois likes to drag it's feet, I'm at 20 days or so, probably going to be 40-80 more days if I'm lucky
 
Last edited:

newAD

All-American
Oct 14, 2007
15,429
5,006
0
I practically have chick hands, so I carry a Glock 22 .40 cal. I absolutely love shooting it. I shot a Springfield 1911 .45 and Beretta 9 mm when I was in the Marines, and I hated them both. I shot expert somehow with the Beretta, but it felt giant in my hands. I have used the same Glock for 18 years now, and it feels like an extension of my hand when shooting. I have never had one misfire in 18 years. I even carry in in the small of my back while off duty. Not an ideal off duty, but it will certainly work very well if ever needed.

I am probably gonna replace it with a new Glock this year. I would never shoot another gun. Somebody else mentioned the Sig. I have a Sig Sauer and H&K and they both feel like a tank in my hands. Very heavy compared to my Glock. Just some thoughts to think about.

Never had an issue with Glocks either. Personally I love them especilly for this line of work.

As I get older, I could see me switching to a 9mm. I don't have the biggest hands either. Also, in my 20s and I to my 30s, the state shoot was an easy 100%. I'm starting to slip a little, which could just be a lack of practice. But I'm no spring chicken any more, and if I were to go back to overnight shirft again, I'd probably seriously consider going to a 9. Sucks getting old.
 

BigBL87

Senior
Sep 11, 2006
3,853
452
0
I won't fault Glocks, they are reliable as hell and pretty darn simple to maintain. I just can't get used to the grip angle on them and I like the feel of a heavier, all metal gun. But, I also don't carry it for a living. As they say of working in corrections, " No guns, just guts," haha.

I got my Shield out of the need for a smaller carry gun, almost splurged and got a Sig 938 but decided if I was going to carry it I wanted something I'd be a little less upset to lose for awhile should I ever have to use it to defend myself. I'll be honest though, the CZ lover I am, if they made a Shield sized single stack my Shield would be gone in a heartbeat.
 

otismotis08

All-Conference
Jan 5, 2012
12,535
2,652
113
I won't fault Glocks, they are reliable as hell and pretty darn simple to maintain. I just can't get used to the grip angle on them and I like the feel of a heavier, all metal gun. But, I also don't carry it for a living. As they say of working in corrections, " No guns, just guts," haha.

I got my Shield out of the need for a smaller carry gun, almost splurged and got a Sig 938 but decided if I was going to carry it I wanted something I'd be a little less upset to lose for awhile should I ever have to use it to defend myself. I'll be honest though, the CZ lover I am, if they made a Shield sized single stack my Shield would be gone in a heartbeat.

Another CZ fan. Years ago, I was all set to purchase a 1911 or Beretta until I put a the CZ-83 and CZ-85 in my hand. Fit like a glove. Done deal.
 

rez dog 70

Heisman
Sep 11, 2011
156,596
36,863
113
Another CZ fan. Years ago, I was all set to purchase a 1911 or Beretta until I put a the CZ-83 and CZ-85 in my hand. Fit like a glove. Done deal.
Have you held a 1911? That firearm literally does become an extension of your hand.
 

TruHusker

All-Conference
Sep 21, 2001
11,969
2,222
98
A little thread drift here - went from 9 vs 45 to handgun preference. hmm

I have one 1911 - it is fine, not an expensive brand, a 45 that shoots great and is reliable.

Glocks are very reliable but simply do not fit me, I pass on them. Grip, angles and triggers all seem wrong for me for some reason. Don't even pick them up anymore.

Love CZ. I have the SP 01 Phantom which is not made anymore. Hey BigBL how do you like the P 07? I am looking at one right now. Seems to have nice features and a nice size to it. The only thing about CZ's is if you reload your own ammo. They have a very tight throat. A few people complain about the trigger pull on a CZ but I understand the newer models have addressed that issue.

Guns are like clothes, they have to fit you and you have to try on several to find the right ones.
 

summersatthelake

Freshman
Jan 24, 2006
448
68
0
I personally went 9mm, the main reason being cost of ammo. I can afford to practice alot more with 9mm than with .45 ACP. All the handguns I own (S&W Shield, CZ P07, and CZ-75B) are in 9mm for commonality of ammo, but I do hope to get a 1911 in .45 ACP in the future. Just love 1911's, and if I'm going to get one it is going to be in the "original" caliber.

I shoot a lot and the cost of ammo was one of the reasons I went to all 9mm handguns.
1000 rounds of Blazer Brass 124 gr delivered to my house on Wednesday for right at $230.00

 
  • Like
Reactions: Tarheelhusker

BigBL87

Senior
Sep 11, 2006
3,853
452
0
Hey BigBL how do you like the P 07? I am looking at one right now. Seems to have nice features and a nice size to it.

I like it alot. It's Glock 19-ish in size, so it's right in that sweet spot for comfort in the hand and concealability. For carry, it is a bit fatter than I expected so it's not quite as easy to carry as I had hoped, but nothing that you can't dress around. The trigger is fantastic, and with some parts from Cajun Gun Works you can improve it even more. For anyone that isn't familiar, CGW is THE place for parts and work on CZs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: otismotis08

otismotis08

All-Conference
Jan 5, 2012
12,535
2,652
113
I like it alot. It's Glock 19-ish in size, so it's right in that sweet spot for comfort in the hand and concealability. For carry, it is a bit fatter than I expected so it's not quite as easy to carry as I had hoped, but nothing that you can't dress around. The trigger is fantastic, and with some parts from Cajun Gun Works you can improve it even more. For anyone that isn't familiar, CGW is THE place for parts and work on CZs.
I'm fortunate to be near the CZ-USA headquarters. There's a strong contingent of CZ folks in Kansas City.
 

BigBL87

Senior
Sep 11, 2006
3,853
452
0
I'm fortunate to be near the CZ-USA headquarters. There's a strong contingent of CZ folks in Kansas City.

Jealous! I'm about an hour drive from the HQ of Springfield Armory in Geneseo, IL. I don't own a Springfield, sadly, but wouldn't mind having one. I'd love a Springfield 1911, actually. The XD line is nice, I just like keeping a somewhat consistent manual of arms (similar to the CZ, which the Shield doesn't fall under but it does have a manual safety like a CZ), so while I'd definitely take one it's not on my must buy list at the moment. I'm also about an hour or so away from Plano Molding, which is the company that makes gun cases. Didn't realize it until I bought a case and had to contact them about getting some keys it was missing.
 

bigboxes

All-American
Sep 4, 2004
45,849
6,132
113
Hermann Göring's Walther PPK is up for auction. Who here is going to own it?