Toggle sidebar

OT Dallas advances on controversial flag pick up

K

KWilt43atbuzz

All-American
Nov 18, 2012
17,050
6,848
0
Wow! How much did JJ have to pay to get that blatant pass interference flag picked up?
Easily the worst call/no call in NFL history!
Won't matter because Packers will roll them in Green Bay.
 
T

TrueBlueMGH

All-American
Apr 12, 2009
109,878
5,901
28
I felt dirty watching the rest of the game. The second that flag was picked up you knew Dallas would somehow win.
 
U

UKfan2151

All-American
Oct 1, 2003
14,064
8,372
113
I hate the Cowboys as much as anyone, but IMHO that was a flag that should never have been thrown to begin with.
 
Deeeefense

Deeeefense

Heisman
Staff member
Aug 22, 2001
43,969
50,642
113
Pete Morelli is the worst NFL official in history. I've seen his crews make several very controversial calls/no calls over the years, especially not enforcing oblivious rules infractions like his crew did today.

The pick-up was nothing short of shameful and even the retired league official commented on how bad that no-call was.

This post was edited on 1/4 8:18 PM by Deeeefense
 
L

louisvillesux

Junior
Feb 22, 2008
1,134
324
0
Lions had plenty of chances to win, they didn't. That is a twitter made controversy that we all fall for.
 
T

TrueBlueMGH

All-American
Apr 12, 2009
109,878
5,901
28
Originally posted by bananapants:
Lions had plenty of chances to win, they didn't. That is a twitter made controversy that we all fall for.
Click to expand...
Nothing Twitter made about what I sat and watched with my own eyes.
 
L

louisvillesux

Junior
Feb 22, 2008
1,134
324
0
No Idea why it got picked up, but would have been a fine no call. Alot of calls on that game I would question.
 
D

dmaso44

Sophomore
Feb 25, 2007
103,991
186
0
Dez Bryant ran out and got in refs face after the call. Isn't that a flag itself, an offensive player running onto the field and arguing a defensive penalty.
 
L

louisvillesux

Junior
Feb 22, 2008
1,134
324
0
Don't know, but if they throw flags every time a player steps on field without his helmet on... I wanna be in the flag business.
 
A

ArtSmass

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2014
1,174
1,567
66
On replay from other angle, you can see Lions receiver hand fighting (and even facemasking) Dallas defender. Refs will rarely give an interference call if there's hand-fighting by both O and D.
 
B

bigblue02_02jw

Redshirt
Apr 24, 2009
219
5
0
Originally posted by brian.mikeson:
On replay from other angle, you can see Lions receiver hand fighting (and even facemasking) Dallas defender. Refs will rarely give an interference call if there's hand-fighting by both O and D.
Click to expand...
But, but, but it's the Cowboys and the guys on tv said it was PI lol.

People just need something to be mad about. Should have never been thrown to begin with.
 
S

Saguaro Cat

All-American
Apr 27, 2008
15,749
6,398
113
Yeah, the Lions really got screwed over on penalties that got reversed after the fact




This post was edited on 1/4 9:06 PM by SaguaroCat
 
G

goingpostal72

Redshirt
Dec 3, 2009
590
26
0
first it was holding on the dallas player he had a handful of jersey, second before the ball arrived he pushed with his left hand and what is totally lost is Dez Bryant ran onto the field to argue with the official. That is a very easy unsportsmanlike penalty
 
B

Bill Derington

Heisman
Jan 21, 2003
21,401
39,402
113
Defender never turned to make play on the ball, he was face guarding which is automatic pass Interference in nfl, bad call.
 
B

bigblue02_02jw

Redshirt
Apr 24, 2009
219
5
0
Originally posted by Bill Derington:
Defender never turned to make play on the ball, he was face guarding which is automatic pass Interference in nfl, bad call.
Click to expand...
No such thing in the NFL.
 
A

anon_013cn8yrfncx2

Guest
First of all he didn't face guard .. second as to the Morelli crew being one of the worst (by another in this thread) did you watch the game. They explained it was not Morelli's normal crew but an all-star crew which eventually got the call right.

Boys probably lose at Lambeau but clearly better than the Lions.
 
B

Bill Derington

Heisman
Jan 21, 2003
21,401
39,402
113
I don't follow you sec, you can't face guard in the nfl, if you must be making a play on the ball in order for that to not be called pass Interference. College it's allowed
 
G

goingpostal72

Redshirt
Dec 3, 2009
590
26
0
we can debate whether it was PI or not but what stinks is the flag was throw and it was relayed to the head official who announced to the world that it was pass interference. Once the announcement was made it should stand period. The other blatant thing was Bryant running on to the field which is a easy penalty to make
 
B

bigblue02_02jw

Redshirt
Apr 24, 2009
219
5
0
It isn't a rule. As long as you're not all over the guy then you don't have to play or even look for the ball. There was very little contact and they made the right call when they picked it up.
 
G

goingpostal72

Redshirt
Dec 3, 2009
590
26
0
faceguarding is not a penalty if no contact is made. However if any contact is made than the defender must be making a play on the ball.
 
A

ArtSmass

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2014
1,174
1,567
66
Originally posted by SaguaroCat:
Yeah, the Lions really got screwed over on penalties that got reversed after the fact




This post was edited on 1/4 9:06 PM by SaguaroCat
Click to expand...
Had no care about who won this game, but given what you've posted, the 60 other classless things Suh has done in his career, and the stomp another Lion had on the defenseless Bears guy earlier this season made me in hindsight LOVE that the Lions lost on a controversial call. Especially given they overturned Suh's game suspension.

What goes around comes around.
 
B

Bill Derington

Heisman
Jan 21, 2003
21,401
39,402
113
You can't faceguard In the nfl if the balls In the air, dude ran straight thru him and had no idea where the ball was. It's allowed In college, but it's not legal in the pros.
 
B

Bill Derington

Heisman
Jan 21, 2003
21,401
39,402
113
I stand corrected sec, you're right about faceguarding, the defender was not making a play on the ball though.
 
G

goingpostal72

Redshirt
Dec 3, 2009
590
26
0
the former VP of officials in the nfl flat-out said it was pass interference as well as defensive holding.
 
W

weused2luvhim2

Senior
Mar 2, 2008
4,656
851
0
Pettigrew grabbed Hitchens facemask, so you can quit crying about that. The running into the kicker on Dallas in the first half was bs. Also how about those 2 sacks Suh got and shouldn't have been in the game? Fact is Garrett finally proved he has a sack and went for it on 4 th and 6. That was the game winning move. Ive never seen one team winning an opening round playoff game against a team nobody likes outside of Detroit bring out so many cry babies.
 
C

Catapult_rivals218351

All-Conference
Dec 31, 2002
3,472
1,705
0
Originally posted by no_neutrality:

First of all he didn't face guard .. second as to the Morelli crew being one of the worst (by another in this thread) did you watch the game. They explained it was not Morelli's normal crew but an all-star crew which eventually got the call right.

Boys probably lose at Lambeau but clearly better than the Lions.
Click to expand...
Defender clearly hit the arms of the receiver before the ball arrived and just as clearly wasn't making a play for the ball.
Your niece said you would defend your precious Cowboys!
 
B

bigblue02_02jw

Redshirt
Apr 24, 2009
219
5
0
Originally posted by goingpostal72:

the former VP of officials in the nfl flat-out said it was pass interference as well as defensive holding.
Click to expand...
You're right he did but I'm guessing he goes along with whatever is called 99% of the time as you could throw a flag on just about every pass and find enough to justify it and 100% of run plays because someone is getting their jersey held.

It's been made out to be way bigger of a deal than it should have been.


The head linesman who had a better angle overturned the call per Pete Morelli (head ref I believe).
This post was edited on 1/4 10:29 PM by secrules2
 
P

Pharmboy007

All-Conference
Jan 10, 2003
6,803
2,814
82
Originally posted by secrules2:
Originally posted by goingpostal72:

the former VP of officials in the nfl flat-out said it was pass interference as well as defensive holding.
Click to expand...
You're right he did but I'm guessing he goes along with whatever is called 99% of the time as you could throw a flag on just about every pass and find enough to justify it and 100% of run plays because someone is getting their jersey held.

It's been made out to be way bigger of a deal than it should have been.


The head linesman who had a better angle overturned the call per Pete Morelli (head ref I believe).
This post was edited on 1/4 10:29 PM by secrules2
Click to expand...
The question has to be why was it picked up? You don't see that happen with that type of call.

GO CATS
 
K

KYBallCoach

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2010
3,320
2
0
It definitely was pass interference on Dallas. Very tough call in a critical part of the game. Definitely killed the rhythm on that particular drive
 
M

michaeluk26

All-American
Feb 14, 2013
36,513
5,046
0
The flag should not have ever been thrown. Its gotten ridiculous how much they call pass interference of the defense. At least the NFL has started to sometimes call offensive pass interference that usually happens on most long balls thrown or fades.
 
L

louisvillesux

Junior
Feb 22, 2008
1,134
324
0
Head ref explained why flag was picked up. Head linesman had a better view of play. Admitted crew should have discussed before he made the announcement. In the end, they got it right no question in my mind. Like I said earlier, this is a twitter made controversy. If you think that was a bad call, there were certainly worse calls in the game.
 
V

vhcat70

Heisman
Feb 5, 2003
57,418
38,482
0
Which is why replay reviews are a complete waste of time. Doesn't matter how many more you get right by them if you miss even one that changes the game anyway.
 
B

Bill Derington

Heisman
Jan 21, 2003
21,401
39,402
113
What do you expect the head ref to say? It was a bad call, especially since it had already been called.

The defensive player never turned to see the ball and ran right through the offensive player, I'm not sure how you can take anything else from the play.
 
U

UKWildcats#8

All-American
Jun 25, 2011
30,327
9,337
0
What really annoyed me is the refs helping Dallas continue their final drive when the Lions held on 3rd down a couple of times to force a field goal attempt.

The refs were not going to allow it to be a 20-20 game with Detroit having a chance to win it with a field goal. It was comical. All you can do is laugh,.

That said, next week the fantasy ends in Green Bay. The Cowboys are a fraud and a pretender. They may have went 8-0 on the road in the regular season, but this is the post-season and Green Bay is not going to bow down to the "mighty" Cowboys.
 
A

Anon1713320623

All-Conference
Oct 6, 2014
3,074
4,304
0
Anyone who says that was not PI or at the least defensive holding or even unsportsmanlike conduct on Bryant for running on the field arguing with the ref ... you are either a Cowboy fan, or know absolutely NOTHING about football. No other way to cut it. The PI was clear, the defensive holding was clear, UC was clear, Detroit should have kept the ball. Doesn't matter though, Cowgirls lose @ Packers next week.
 
C

C1180

Sophomore
Dec 21, 2001
32,443
189
0
I can think of few examples of pass interference more blatant than that play. I just can not understand any legitimate reason for picking up that flag and I pull for the Cowboys. Definitely a prime case of home cooking.
 
W

wbryant316

Junior
Jun 9, 2005
39,743
313
0
The NFL is better with Dallas in the playoffs. Screw Detroit! Cowboys vs Packers will have the highest rating of the year on TV.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom