1. They are right about frying it. The simpler recipes with few ingredients are best. Let the meat do the talking. I cut mine 1/2 inch and then cut again in half for bite size pieces. The inside loin is the better cut of meat for this but the tender is great too. I will sometimes flat hammer them for a bit more tenderness.
2. Cast iron skillet method. Do it. You won't regret it. I put some chopped garlic on mine during the sear. I also take the skillet after the steaks have been pulled and caramelize onions in it. This will keep you from cutting the steak when it should be resting.
3. Similar to the jalapeño poppers but a different presentation is making basically the same recipe but butterflying the straps in a way to create pinwheels. This is always a hit. Plus you get more cream cheese in it this way.
4. Backstrap Spiedini. Sorta long description:
- cut a 4 to 5 inch piece of the backstrap. Place the knife lengthwise on the streak about a quarter to a half inch from the bottom and cut and roll the steak to create a flat steak. I tried describing that the best way I can. It is essentially butterflying it as you roll it to make a tube steak flat and even.
- cover with a ziplock bag and hammer it slightly thinner to increase the tenderness
- marinate in olive oil, chopped garlic, Worcestershire, black pepper, salt, and a small amount of cracked red pepper overnight.
- In a bowl mix Italian bread crumbs, fresh grated Parmesan cheese, and chopped garlic.
- pull steak from marinade and place in bowl and mix, making sure to fully coat it
- roll up tightly lengthwise and then roll it around in the bowl's mixture again to fully coat it.
- cut one inch pieces out of the roll and place them on a skewer
- place directly over a 350 to 375 degree fire. Flip every two to three minutes to your desired level of doneness.
- remove from grill
- brush with either a garlic infused olive oil or just melted butter and then lightly salt and pepper again as you plate them and serve (won't need the salt if you use butter here).
This sounds like a lot of work. It is really easy though since you separate the meat cut and marinade with an overnight sit.
I usually make at least two if not three of these at a time. The length of 4 to 5 inches is key because it makes it easier to butterfly.
Thus is a go to recipe for me with deer or chicken when entertaining. It never disappoints.