OT: NY Giants 2025 Season Thread

Jul 4, 2025
655
369
63
Giants can be a much better team this year and it will most likely not lead to many wins with the hardest or at least in top 3 hardest schedules this season
 
  • Like
Reactions: koleszar

Fat Koko

All-Conference
Nov 28, 2022
2,614
2,162
73
What’s up with Jude McA?

He is clear kicker #2 behind Graham Gano and Graham just kicked a 53 yarder.

I thought in these preseason situations in which there isn’t really a kicker competition, the #2 gets all the action and hopefully performs well and becomes a trade chip.

Would’ve thought giving Jude the chance to hit from 50+ could have increased his stock.
 
Last edited:

koleszar

Heisman
Jan 1, 2010
35,970
56,035
113
Giants can be a much better team this year and it will most likely not lead to many wins with the hardest or at least in top 3 hardest schedules this season
I agree, they're going to be better, (really can't get much worse) but still suck with the gauntlet they're going to face. The team is still so far away from any playoff contention. I don't see how Daboll can survive yet another debacle.
 

tico brown

Heisman
Oct 16, 2005
43,354
13,394
93
What’s up with Jude McA?

He is clear kicker #2 behind Graham Gano and Graham just kicked a 53 yarder.

I thought in these preseason situation in which there isn’t really a kicker competition, the #2 get all thre press on action and hopefully performs well and becomes a trade chip.

Would’ve thought giving Jude the chance to hit from 50+ could have increased his stock.
He just kicked a 42 Yd FG to give the Giants a 27-25 fourth quarter lead.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Fat Koko

24Babybull

Senior
Oct 15, 2006
1,022
416
83
Was wondering why the announcers were calling him Little Jordan Humphrey. Thought it was a nickname but Lil'Jordan is his name.
 

Postman_1

Heisman
Mar 12, 2017
7,452
12,177
113
Dart again looked good. That being said Jones looked good in his first pre season as well. Still rather them look good than bad.

 

T2Kplus20

Heisman
May 1, 2007
30,543
18,539
113
Dart again looked good. That being said Jones looked good in his first pre season as well. Still rather them look good than bad.


Best preseason fact:

There are only 2 NFL teams ever to go winless in the regular season. Lions and Browns. Both those years these teams went 4-0 in the preseason. The preseason is beyond meaningless.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Postman_1

Postman_1

Heisman
Mar 12, 2017
7,452
12,177
113
Giants wrap up the pre season by crushing the Pats. Now the real games begin. Week 1 vs the Redskins.

Hyatt looked bad again dropping 2 catchable balls. He could've been called for OPI on his 3 deep shots. He even talked smack after his TD, that came after 2 balls that a better receiver catches.

If Evan Neal sees the field at all this year they are in big trouble and he will get a QB injured. He played like garbage the other night and that was vs backups.

Dart looked good again but he needs to learn to slide. His receivers had multiple drops. If they dropped DeVito he will probably get claimed
 

mdk02

Heisman
Aug 18, 2011
26,206
18,541
113
Giants wrap up the pre season by crushing the Pats. Now the real games begin. Week 1 vs the Redskins.

Hyatt looked bad again dropping 2 catchable balls. He could've been called for OPI on his 3 deep shots. He even talked smack after his TD, that came after 2 balls that a better receiver catches.

If Evan Neal sees the field at all this year they are in big trouble and he will get a QB injured. He played like garbage the other night and that was vs backups.

Dart looked good again but he needs to learn to slide. His receivers had multiple drops. If they dropped DeVito he will probably get claimed

What is Winston's cap number? Could be an expensive 3rd stringer, and DiVito has already shown he can handle that roll.
 

Postman_1

Heisman
Mar 12, 2017
7,452
12,177
113
What is Winston's cap number? Could be an expensive 3rd stringer, and DiVito has already shown he can handle that roll.
3M this year and 5M next season. He is a very desirable back up QB with a good arm. He does just wing it though and that leads to a bunch of Int's. They will and should keep him IMO. He is pricey though if he is #3
 

RU05

All-American
Jun 25, 2015
14,527
9,092
113
3M this year and 5M next season. He is a very desirable back up QB with a good arm. He does just wing it though and that leads to a bunch of Int's. They will and should keep him IMO. He is pricey though if he is #3
I feel the argument for keeping Winston is so as to have him next year as the backup.

This year with how Dart has looked I don’t see the need for him.

For me it depends on what you can get back in a trade. I wouldn’t give him away for a 5th.
 

mdk02

Heisman
Aug 18, 2011
26,206
18,541
113
I feel the argument for keeping Winston is so as to have him next year as the backup.

This year with how Dart has looked I don’t see the need for him.

For me it depends on what you can get back in a trade. I wouldn’t give him away for a 5th.

Would you take a 7th for DeVito?