Possible Coaching Options

sct1111

All-American
Nov 30, 2014
6,046
8,237
113
Interesting question. If you get someone who can come in and win and get the upgrades and get the money, why leave? Doesn't Fleck have NJ ties?
Because Rutgers is seen as a mid level program. Why did Urban Meyer leave Utah? Why did Saban leave Michigan State?
 

KJB32812

Heisman
Dec 25, 2008
40,334
82,829
113
Because Rutgers is seen as a mid level program. Why did Urban Meyer leave Utah? Why did Saban leave Michigan State?

Dantonio isn't leaving MSU. Willingham doesn't appear to be leaving Utah. Peterson stayed at Boise forever.
 

cRURah

All-Conference
Nov 13, 2004
4,831
3,779
62
RU had better pony up the money needed to hire a head coach capable of taking the program to the next level.
 

RU4Real

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
50,955
30,733
0
Team wins this Saturday.
Carroo reinstated, he was just protecting his mom
Team goes 5-3 in conference.
Team wins the Peach Bowl
Flood gets 3 year extension at 2 million year.
Abro wins the lottery, and his wife lets Megan Fox move in with them.

This post is funny because of all these things, the last one is the most likely.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUwoz and MikeR0102

seels2662

Heisman
Aug 16, 2005
23,776
15,785
113
Schiano is not coming back. I truly believe the next coach will be one on the cheap. Even Fleck will be too much. Think MAC level coaches.
 

RU2055

All-Conference
Sep 9, 2009
3,582
1,693
0
Sorry to burst you guys bubbles but Flood aint going anywhere.

Towers and the propaganda machine are going to come up with a new defense and it will all be well again, just watch.
 
Oct 17, 2007
69,704
47,620
0
There is nothing to propagandize. There are no wins and no squeaky clean image. There is nothing but total chaos.

They will fire him over that email. If we lose to TTFP should be done a week from today. Bye.
 

Ru-baby

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2001
6,522
2,819
66
Julie here no gs.

The idea he didnt win be makes him bad choice is well beyond laughable. He could have done better but we were in the top 10 during his tenure! With good apr and rep. Stop the nonsense.

He offended some but we dont need a friend to the band, we need a firm ceo.
 

RUChris

Sophomore
Dec 8, 2008
120
114
0
I don't see any scenario where a big time head coach comes to work for Rutgers under the current circumstances (ex: hostile media, perceived lack of support from the administration, tight checkbook). Really, unless there is money and some semblance of control of the athletic department, what coach pines for Rutgers as a dream job?

A simple coaching switch is just not in the cards, unless Rutgers plans to blow up the athletic department or go with another young, unproven (and cheap) option.
 

lighty

All-Conference
Aug 13, 2003
9,935
4,221
0
"There is nothing to propagandize. There are no wins and no squeaky clean image. There is nothing but total chaos."

Exactly. Wasn't the main reason people wanted Flood was because he was "an honorable man?" -- the suspensions and arrested have tarnished that reputation and it's possible RU could use the email situation as justification for termination. If nothing else, doesn't the email situation strongly hint about just how much Flood is over his head as a head coach?
 

RUschool

Heisman
Jan 23, 2004
49,910
14,001
78
"There is nothing to propagandize. There are no wins and no squeaky clean image. There is nothing but total chaos."

Exactly. Wasn't the main reason people wanted Flood was because he was "an honorable man?" -- the suspensions and arrested have tarnished that reputation and it's possible RU could use the email situation as justification for termination. If nothing else, doesn't the email situation strongly hint about just how much Flood is over his head as a head coach?
Everybody forgets that Dave Cohens incident was under Flood watch also, he was the defense coordinator. Flood is responsible for any bad news to the football program. There's just too much bad publicity.

With the Dave Cohen situation, Flood should have been aware and been able to defuse the situation. When you fire someone, you want the person to feel that he failed on the job, be compassionate not that we screwed him.
 
Last edited:

tuffer76

Senior
Sep 19, 2005
1,411
639
113
The key is to identify what qualities we want in a coach. Personally I want: head coaching experience, expertise on one side of ball, I think clean program history will be necessary. Based on that:
Dino Babers
Matt Campbell
Fleck - doesn't have the expertise or winning that I want

My favorite candidate - Mike Stoops
 

sct1111

All-American
Nov 30, 2014
6,046
8,237
113
I think it's most likely Schiano, just because Greg Brown will want him back.
I think Schiano would more likely end up at Miami. He's too cozy down in Florida. His kids go to school down there. I can see him being successful down there too.

I think Fleck is the best option. In reality though I bet Rutgers hires from within and makes McDaniels the head coach.
 

Plum Street

Heisman
Jun 21, 2009
27,306
23,009
0
I think Schiano would more likely end up at Miami. He's too cozy down in Florida. His kids go to school down there. I can see him being successful down there too.

I think Fleck is the best option. In reality though I bet Rutgers hires from within and makes McDaniels the head coach.

How could they seriously hire mcdaniels ? He's on the current , unsuccessful staff . It's time to clean house if this season spirals .
 
  • Like
Reactions: mikershoein

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
238,179
167,911
113
Floods extension was paid by a donor. No doubt Brown and other GS supporters will come out and pay for him to return. Schiano will retun.


exactly. Its going to be all about negotiating. It brings instant healing back to Rutgers to help its tarnished image

the idea we are going with McDaniels or another 750K hire are wrong
 

vkj91

Heisman
Feb 7, 2007
188,031
48,895
98
Assuming 2.5 is out max salary cap then Dino Babers. Rhule is a possibility to. I live Herman but think his buyout is huge. Can't see Schiano back but if he had huge money for an OC and left him alone.....
 

krup

Heisman
Feb 5, 2003
70,133
10,066
0
It has to be killing a few people on this board that people are having new coach threads and timing (as in 0-2 start) won't let them do the usual "we should hire Petrino because all he does is win" ranting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: vkj91

realhoops2

Senior
Jul 8, 2015
972
902
93
Omg this white bus fella doesn't know college football. Tressel won a lot wherever he was. I guess national championships are not good enough for you ?
You do know that Tressel was banned from college football for a few years and run out of Columbus due to player behavioral issues at Ohio State????
 

realhoops2

Senior
Jul 8, 2015
972
902
93
We payed Schiano $3 million a year. We pay Flood so little because he basically had no qualifications to be a head coach. The money thing isn't that much an issue. The issue is whether a coach would WANT to come here. Who wants to work for Julie Herman in a market where the local media jumps at every opportunity to carve up their own state university?

Do we go with a young guy like PJ Fleck? Or is he the type of guy who uses RU as a stepping stone to a more prestigious position?
Fleck is from Illinois and is much more likely to end of there.
 

RU#1fan

Heisman
Mar 7, 2003
23,039
11,815
113
Team wins this Saturday.
Carroo reinstated, he was just protecting his mom
Team goes 5-3 in conference.
Team wins the Peach Bowl
Flood gets 3 year extension at 2 million year.
Abro wins the lottery, and his wife lets Megan Fox move in with them.

Like the New York State Lottery " You never know "
 

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
30,554
15,521
113
Crimedog2 said:
Omg this white bus fella doesn't know college football. Tressel won a lot wherever he was. I guess national championships are not good enough for you ?
You do know that Tressel was banned from college football for a few years and run out of Columbus due to player behavioral issues at Ohio State????

Also is under a show cause until December of 2016. Any school that hires him must show cause for why it shouldn't be sanctioned for hiring him, and could face severe penalties if he commits any further violations while under the show cause penalty .
 
Dec 17, 2008
45,215
16,775
0
Assuming 2.5 is out max salary cap then Dino Babers. Rhule is a possibility to. I live Herman but think his buyout is huge. Can't see Schiano back but if he had huge money for an OC and left him alone.....
As I've said in the past, I always like talking about coaches regardless of whether we're making a hire or not.

My names from the last few years Montgomery/Morris/Herman were all hired this past offseason. Herman's buyout is over 2M if he gets hired away before 2018 so that would probably exclude him from all but the very top programs. I wouldn't be surprised if Morris didn't have something similar. Montgomery I don't know.

This year's crop I wouldn't say there's anyone I'd feel as good about as Herman or the other two. I haven't come across anyone that sticks out but if I had to choose 1, Justin Fuente at Memphis is a name I like. They looked like they were in shambles before he got there like 5 wins total in 3 seasons prior and he won 4 and 3 his first 2 years and last year followed it up with 10 last year with a lost to Ole Miss, a close loss to UCLA away and a close loss to Houston. They finished the year #25 in the polls. Not bad for year 3 for team that looked in total disarray when he came on board. I'd assume he'd run a spread as well which is my preference.

I liked the fact that he worked as co-OC under a good coach like Patterson. They went and lost the Fiesta Bowl but beat Wisconsin in the Rose Bowl. So far this year they're 2-0 with convincing victories against Missouri State and at Kansas. I always worry about flash in the pan so I'd like to see what he could do this year to add to his resume. He'll be facing those 3 guys (Herman/Morris/Montgomery) on his side of the AAC this year. Also will be playing Temple/Cincy/Bowling Green/Ole Miss so if he could have another good year on that type or schedule that would sell me a little more.

If he can repeat what he did last year Fuente would be a name that should be on an athletic director's list. His salary got bumped to that 1.5M range and his buyout is 500K.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MikeR0102

vkj91

Heisman
Feb 7, 2007
188,031
48,895
98
As I've said in the past, I always like talking about coaches regardless of whether we're making a hire or not.

My names from the last few years Montgomery/Morris/Herman were all hired this past offseason. Herman's buyout is over 2M if he gets hired away before 2018 so that would probably exclude him from all but the very top programs. I wouldn't be surprised if Morris didn't have something similar. Montgomery I don't know.

This year's crop I wouldn't say there's anyone I'd feel as good about as Herman or the other two. I haven't come across anyone that sticks out but if I had to choose 1, Justin Fuente at Memphis is a name I like. They looked like they were in shambles before he got there like 5 wins total in 3 seasons prior and he won 4 and 3 his first 2 years and last year followed it up with 10 last year with a lost to Ole Miss, a close loss to UCLA away and a close loss to Houston. They finished the year #25 in the polls. Not bad for year 3 for team that looked in total disarray when he came on board. I'd assume he'd run a spread as well which is my preference.

I liked the fact that he worked as co-OC under a good coach like Patterson. They went and lost the Fiesta Bowl but beat Wisconsin in the Rose Bowl. So far this year they're 2-0 with convincing victories against Missouri State and at Kansas. I always worry about flash in the pan so I'd like to see what he could do this year to add to his resume. He'll be facing those 3 guys (Herman/Morris/Montgomery) on his side of the AAC this year. Also will be playing Temple/Cincy/Bowling Green/Ole Miss so if he could have another good year on that type or schedule that would sell me a little more.

If he can repeat what he did last year Fuente would be a name that should be on an athletic director's list. His salary got bumped to that 1.5M range and his buyout is 500K.
You know I like this stuff as much as you. Lol. I've been told Fuentes would struggle recruiting here and his southern personality wouldn't be a good fit in NJ. I know HS coaches really like Rhule and he's obviously doing A good job At Temple. I love Babers and have for some time. I think he is young enough but has real solid experience and he has won in multiple places. Year 2 at BG is off to a real solid start. I wouldn't want a coordinator unless it's a home run because we see how learning on the job can pan out. That being said, I'm intrigued by the OC at TCU. He's was OC at Houston when they crushed us and has worked under some good coaches.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NickyNewark51

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
120,308
53,055
113
Omg this white bus fella doesn't know college football. Tressel won a lot wherever he was. I guess national championships are not good enough for you ?

Wow dude you need to do some research. WB is spot-on with his comments regarding JT. Yes, he won, but he has actually not been ALLOWED to coach, by the NCAA, for a few years now and another 1 or 2 seasons IIRC.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NickyNewark51
Dec 17, 2008
45,215
16,775
0
You know I like this stuff as much as you. Lol. I've been told Fuentes would struggle recruiting here and his southern personality wouldn't be a good fit in NJ. I know HS coaches really like Rhule and he's obviously doing A good job At Temple. I love Babers and have for some time. I think he is young enough but has real solid experience and he has won in multiple places. Year 2 at BG is off to a real solid start. I wouldn't want a coordinator unless it's a home run because we see how learning on the job can pan out. That being said, I'm intrigued by the OC at TCU. He's was OC at Houston when they crushed us and has worked under some good coaches.
Yea I could see that with personality issues but I'm just talking about possible P5 coaching prospects in general not specifically about us. I think the same culture issues could have popped up for Morris/Montgomery. Herman I think would have been fine here. Besides I'm sure there are coaches that coach in other parts of the country away from their origins and do fine so it's not as much a deal breaker for me.

I'm still not shy about hiring a coordinator just like those 3 but I'm just not enamored with any of the current crop like the mid major HCs. A name like Scott Frost who some have mentioned here would finallly come up on my radar if he can prove he can do it without Mariota this year and still create a high powered offense. If he can do it again next year after the Eastern Washington kids leaves that would really raise his stock in my eyes. Like I say repeat it again and again with new faces then I'm more likely to be sold.

Doug Meacham/Sonny Cumbie are Texas/Oklahoma types so if you worried about personality issues wouldn't that be a concern about them too. Again I don't care about that stuff as much but if you do then I think it would be an issue. I do like that he coached another qb like Okorn? at Houston and not just Boykin at TCU. I don't know what their offenses were ranked at Houston though even though they did seem strong.
 

vkj91

Heisman
Feb 7, 2007
188,031
48,895
98
Yea I could see that with personality issues but I'm just talking about possible P5 coaching prospects in general not specifically about us. I think the same culture issues could have popped up for Morris/Montgomery. Herman I think would have been fine here. Besides I'm sure there are coaches that coach in other parts of the country away from their origins and do fine so it's not as much a deal breaker for me.

I'm still not shy about hiring a coordinator just like those 3 but I'm just not enamored with any of the current crop like the mid major HCs. A name like Scott Frost who some have mentioned here would finallly come up on my radar if he can prove he can do it without Mariota this year and still create a high powered offense. If he can do it again next year after the Eastern Washington kids leaves that would really raise his stock in my eyes. Like I say repeat it again and again with new faces then I'm more likely to be sold.

Doug Meacham/Sonny Cumbie are Texas/Oklahoma types so if you worried about personality issues wouldn't that be a concern about them too. Again I don't care about that stuff as much but if you do then I think it would be an issue. I do like that he coached another qb like Okorn? at Houston and not just Boykin at TCU. I don't know what their offenses were ranked at Houston though even though they did seem strong.
Willie fritz. 144-67 at 3 schools.
I'm not against hiring guys with different cultural backgrounds but that was something a HS coach pointed out to me in that specific instance. Ironically we were talking about this last night without any inkling of the present situation.
 

LevaosLectures

All-Conference
Jun 28, 2015
3,977
3,156
0
Yes Joe Morehead. ..

He was OC for UCONN when they went to the fiesta bowl.

He took a horrible Fordham team and made them one of the better squads in FCS.

Give him a call.
 

vkj91

Heisman
Feb 7, 2007
188,031
48,895
98
Yes Joe Morehead. ..

He was OC for UCONN when they went to the fiesta bowl.

He took a horrible Fordham team and made them one of the better squads in FCS.

Give him a call.
He also signed a big extension though 2021 and I think you need to go bigger or donors will be skittish. Not saying he can't coach but he isn't going to get fans or recruits excited.
 
Dec 17, 2008
45,215
16,775
0
Willie fritz. 144-67 at 3 schools.
I'm not against hiring guys with different cultural backgrounds but that was something a HS coach pointed out to me in that specific instance. Ironically we were talking about this last night without any inkling of the present situation.
Yea from what I see posted here NJ coaches are too provincial and generally what has listening to them gotten us. Just give me a good coach and put some local flavor on the staff.

Fritz is a name I've seen in a few articles here and there but I don't know much about him in terms of what he runs etc..He could be a Paul Johnson/Jim Tressel.....or not. All I see is his record which is good but I don't know much more.