Prior to MR taking over at OSU, going back to 1972, the number of wins per season for OSU was as follows:
2,2,3,1, 2, 2, 3, 1, 0, 1, 1, 2, 2, 3, 3, 2, 4, 4, 1, 1, 1, 4, 4, 1, 2.
Then, in 1997 Riley took over and he went 5-6 by his second year. While that sounds bad by NU standards, one has to remember that it was the biggest win total in nearly 27 years at OSU. Then he goes to the NFL and comes back. After coming back he posts 8 winnings seasons between 2003 and 2014. And this also completely ignores the course MR put OSU on that led to decent success under Erickson (which Erickson quickly piddled away by year 3).
Again, not necessarily impressive in absolute numbers for an NU fan. However, people cannot be blind to context. I don't think many understand just how horrible OSU was before MR got there. OSU was basically K. State pre-Bill Snyder. Riley built them up and made them competitive. One has to wonder what would have happened had Riley not left in 1999.
The whole "he didn't have the players" line isn't BS. It is the truth.
That all said, I'm not completely sure he will have success here. My worry, however, isn't that he can't coach. My worry is that he will be too loyal to certain defensive coaches. I think the offense turns into a highly productive unit once he gets his QB in place. I'm not certain about the defense. However, given MR's track record we owe him a few years. I know people like to blabber on about his lack of titles and etc., but he took a horrible horrible program and made them relevant and competed for the Pac-10 title.
Is he perfect? Absolutely not. But can we please just stop dealing in rhetoric and stick with facts?
The other aspect that people at NU don't really get...mainly because we haven't had it in a long long time is elite QB play. That is how you win titles. You can still be "good" with high end defense and a solid running game but I challenge anyone to list a national title team (or even a conference winning team) that didn't have elite QB play. In this era, with the talent pool so evenly dispersed, you absolutely have to have it. We don't have that. That is the one area that I do trust MR in. He at least deserves the opportunity to run the ship with his QB. You give him an NFL-caliber QB (even a late round or FA type) and this season looks a whole lot different. Bo left the cupboard bare and that is compounded by moving to a new offensive system.