Toggle sidebar

Question for the board - What would you do? Important question.

W

WVPATX

Freshman
Jan 27, 2005
28,197
91
38
Trump has promised to round up the roughly 2,000,000 felon illegal aliens and deport them. He has promised deport those already in prison when their sentences end. It seems that most on this board agree with that policy, certainly most Americans agree.

The question is, how does he do it? As I see the options, they include:

1. Expand ICE greatly to round up criminal aliens starting in big cities and with the gangs. They are the most dangerous. Work with local law enforcement to the extent they will help. (Sanctuary cities will be a big problem).
2. Expand ICE so that when a felon alien is arrested, starting in big cities, ICE can take immediate control. Don't wait on the local police to notify ICE since many sanctuary cities won't do that.
3. Use the national guard to back up ICE in the round up, starting in big cities and with gangs.
4. Take a softer approach. Give the illegal aliens a year to register/apply for a green card. If they meet certain criteria (have a job, no felony record, won't use our social safety net, pay a fine, no pathway to citizenship, etc.), give them a green card. After that year, any illegal arrested is subject to immediate deportation. Station ICE agents starting in big cities to take control upon these arrests.

Any others?
 
M

moe

Sophomore
May 29, 2001
32,532
150
63
WVPATX said:
Trump has promised to round up the roughly 2,000,000 felon illegal aliens and deport them. He has promised deport those already in prison when their sentences end. It seems that most on this board agree with that policy, certainly most Americans agree.

The question is, how does he do it? As I see the options, they include:

1. Expand ICE greatly to round up criminal aliens starting in big cities and with the gangs. They are the most dangerous. Work with local law enforcement to the extent they will help. (Sanctuary cities will be a big problem).
2. Expand ICE so that when a felon alien is arrested, starting in big cities, ICE can take immediate control. Don't wait on the local police to notify ICE since many sanctuary cities won't do that.
3. Use the national guard to back up ICE in the round up, starting in big cities and with gangs.
4. Take a softer approach. Give the illegal aliens a year to register/apply for a green card. If they meet certain criteria (have a job, no felony record, won't use our social safety net, pay a fine, no pathway to citizenship, etc.), give them a green card. After that year, any illegal arrested is subject to immediate deportation. Station ICE agents starting in big cities to take control upon these arrests.

Any others?
Click to expand...
White House says AP report on National Guard mobilization is false, NBC reports
http://www.cnbc.com/2017/02/17/trum...oops-to-round-up-unauthorized-immigrants.html
They're fleeing into Canada now.
Migrants Choose Arrest In Canada Over Staying In The U.S.
 
W

WVPATX

Freshman
Jan 27, 2005
28,197
91
38
M

moe

Sophomore
May 29, 2001
32,532
150
63
WVPATX said:
Moe, in all seriousness, I know you hate Trump. That's fine. Are you in favor of deporting criminal felon illegal aliens? If so, how do you think we should go about doing it knowing it will save lives?
Click to expand...
Criminals belong in jail.
 
W

WVPATX

Freshman
Jan 27, 2005
28,197
91
38
moe said:
Criminals belong in jail.
Click to expand...

Deflection again. To arrest gang bangers you need evidence for a court. No such evidence is needed for this. Just a criminal record. Other felons were in jail and now out of jail, roaming the streets.

Are you afraid to answer? Of do you not have a clue what to do?
 
WVex-pat in GA

WVex-pat in GA

Junior
Dec 17, 2007
14,537
359
83
WVPATX said:
4. Take a softer approach. Give the illegal aliens a year to register/apply for a green card. If they meet certain criteria (have a job, no felony record, won't use our social safety net, pay a fine, no pathway to citizenship, etc.), give them a green card. After that year, any illegal arrested for a felony is subject to immediate deportation. Station ICE agents starting in big cities to take control upon these arrests.
Click to expand...

#4 as modified plus 4A. ICE to round up criminal aliens starting in big cities and with the gangs. They are the most dangerous. Work with local law enforcement so that when a felon alien is arrested ICE can take immediate control.
 
D

D. Denzil Finney

Redshirt
May 29, 2001
9,391
14
0
WVPATX said:
Trump has promised to round up the roughly 2,000,000 felon illegal aliens and deport them. He has promised deport those already in prison when their sentences end. It seems that most on this board agree with that policy, certainly most Americans agree.

The question is, how does he do it? As I see the options, they include:

1. Expand ICE greatly to round up criminal aliens starting in big cities and with the gangs. They are the most dangerous. Work with local law enforcement to the extent they will help. (Sanctuary cities will be a big problem).
2. Expand ICE so that when a felon alien is arrested, starting in big cities, ICE can take immediate control. Don't wait on the local police to notify ICE since many sanctuary cities won't do that.
3. Use the national guard to back up ICE in the round up, starting in big cities and with gangs.
4. Take a softer approach. Give the illegal aliens a year to register/apply for a green card. If they meet certain criteria (have a job, no felony record, won't use our social safety net, pay a fine, no pathway to citizenship, etc.), give them a green card. After that year, any illegal arrested is subject to immediate deportation. Station ICE agents starting in big cities to take control upon these arrests.

Any others?
Click to expand...

Items 1 & 2 - Good ideas, but must tailor, the duties and jurisdiction of ICE to align with those allowed for the FBI.

Item 3 - The National Guard approach won't work unless the Governor allows it or the POTUS calls the NG to active duty. All State Adjutants General are State employees and are not included in the callup. The called up National Guard personnel are accessed into the Military where they are prevented from acting via The Posse Comitatus Act. I believe the only way around that would be Martial Law.

Item 4 - Completely disagree, deport them. If we allow them to stay they will revert to their old patterns.
 
R

roadtrasheer

Junior
Sep 9, 2016
16,710
389
83
I think they should start in Chicago,can't hurt much, remove all illegal aliens in gangs asap ! Then any illegal aliens who has committed a felony or multiple misdemeanor. Don't know how or if this would slow the death rate but it couldn't hurt
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom