What does getting a guy that was a Heisman darkhorse last year have to do with Mackey's abilities?
You do realize that Mackey showed up in August, right? We all know that, in most cases (with Cam Newton not being one of those cases), it takes a JUCO several games before they can get adjusted to the speed of the SEC. And if it wasn't hard enough, add to the fact that he's a JUCO QB, which is even tougher in most instances.
Add to all of this the fact that he has a slight speech impediment (stuttering) that is and has been worked on. He has also never taken snaps under center (shotgun in HS, shotgun at JUCO).
The kid was an All-American in HS and would've been highly recruited if he had a chance in hell of qualifying (he had zero chance). He was a two-time All-American in JUCO and led the nation in passing, completion percentage, and pass efficiency last year (yes, the same year Cam Newton played in JUCO). He has won at every single level he has played in (38-0 in the highest classification of LA football, 19-3 in two years at EMCC which hadn't been to the playoffs in a few years before, yet went to the playoffs back-to-back for the first time in school history while he was QB).
The kid may amount to nothing, and I know there is a long line of JUCO QBs who haven't done ****. But to say that going after Masoli shows that Mackey isn't very good is just plain stupidity. Ole Miss had 2 scholarship QBs on campus, one being a JUCO transfer that arrived in August and the other being a kid with something like 5 career passes. If you know you can get a guy with the talent of Masoli, and you have this QB situation, why the hell wouldn't you?
By the way, Mackey will most likely be the starter next year.
If you have anything that points to the contrary, by all means, show it.