Sitkowski: My answer.

zebnatto

All-Conference
May 7, 2008
5,071
3,818
0
Art is gaining nothing under the current philosophy. If the coaches are truly committed to the kid, quit starting him. Early in the game, give him time on the sidelines to discuss what’s going on on the field, re: quarterback play, with Gio (if he’s not the qb) or with the qb coach. Give him a shot on the third or fourth series, and have him focus on a particular aspect of his game: not locking on receiver (even if initially he does this in a mechanical way, on prepared routes and sequences), moving within the pocket, breaking the pocket for a five-yard gain rather than throw away or sack. Throughout the game continue to put him in situations where there is a great likelihood of one of two options: learning/development or on-field success.
 

miketd1

Heisman
Sep 26, 2006
59,714
13,916
66
Some players just see the field better innately. You see this in basketball and soccer, especially at youth level when the parents are screaming to pass it to the open man.

No doubt in my mind that if Art can improve his QB vision if he works on it. Most people can improve at pretty much anything when they apply the 10,000 hour rule (of dedicated, focused practice). However, I'm not sure where he's going to find the time required to fix this.

Like in basketball and soccer, it's just easier to just plug in the guy who can see the field "naturally" at point guard or #10 rather than trying to teach a kid how to "see".
 

zebnatto

All-Conference
May 7, 2008
5,071
3,818
0
Some players just see the field better innately. You see this in basketball and soccer, especially at youth level when the parents are screaming to pass it to the open man.

No doubt in my mind that if Art can improve his QB vision if he works on it. Most people can improve at pretty much anything when they apply the 10,000 hour rule (of dedicated, focused practice). However, I'm not sure where he's going to find the time required to fix this.

Like in basketball and soccer, it's just easier to just plug in the guy who can see the field "naturally" at point guard or #10 rather than trying to teach a kid how to "see".
I think too much has been asked of the kid and dont want to give up on him. He’s playing what’s arguably the toughest position in sports.
 

AntiG

All-Conference
Jan 27, 2012
4,527
3,581
113
Too bad we can't just fire Flood, and bring back both Schiano and Shea lol

Shea would do wonders for every QB on the roster in terms of long-term development.
 

miketd1

Heisman
Sep 26, 2006
59,714
13,916
66
IMO, he needs a dedicated QB coach who has 1.) actually played QB at a high level and 2.) can teach.
 

batts

All-Conference
Jun 6, 2001
6,929
1,339
113
I know that he didn't start for his high school prep team. Was he injured or was he beaten out by another QB?
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
88,731
86,728
113
I know that he didn't start for his high school prep team. Was he injured or was he beaten out by another QB?
Both. Got injured, then never recovered his position as the starter. The QB for Minnesota surpassed him.