So what does the Dem win really mean?

m.knox

All-American
Aug 20, 2003
6,355
6,160
113
This Bluekkake thing is obviously hard for you to take. Which runs entirely contrary to your lengthy time spent in the parking lot of the Ann Arbor Olive Garden.

LOL... Says the guy who gets a train on him weekly by his friends at the bath house.
 

scotchtiger

Heisman
Dec 15, 2005
135,564
24,171
113
I hope they are successful in doing so. Let billionaires who don't want to pay taxes move to Hungary. Or Russia. Maybe they will thrive there.

The billionaires making $400K like Biden and Kamala wanted to tax or actual billionaires?
 

PAWrocka

Heisman
Nov 3, 2008
21,357
28,917
103
Not much IMHO. As an independent, I have a lot of faith in the Dems ability to totally blow this win. I think they are going to go after Trump and company and I think that's a mistake. I think common sense, popular legislation would be in order... try for some things that are bipartisan and can get some Republican votes. I'm HOPING that Trump's grip on the Republican Party is slipping after the midterms and some of the *** kissing that the Republicans are famous for goes away as well. The dems need some republican votes to override a veto, but not that many. Also, putting up good popular legislation (even if it gets veto'd) is not a waste of time and can lead to a 2028 win as well.

Most of Trump's policies and big wins (not all) are by executive order. All it takes to roll that back is for the executive order to be reversed. I look for a LOT of that happening if the Dems win the Whitehouse in 2028.

The biggest result of the win is obviously the Senate. The two most batshit crazy members of the SCOTUS are Thomas and Alito and they are both pretty damn old. After the new congress comes in in January, they can halt any SCOTUS nominations for the next couple of years and as the Republicans were saying at the end of Obama's term... let the American People decide.
long term the win on Tuesday means very little. Nothing is getting done the next 2 years which … I’m fine with. split government is the best Government right now.

The Dems shouldn’t be “spiking the football” like they are. Their message this cycle was “Trump Bad” and the American people agreed … but nothing has really changed, people are still against open borders and all woke BS that are core to the Dems platform now.

I also really think that the Republicans are going to completely abandon Trump now and listening to Trump’s tone now … I think he will just kinda slink away.

it wouldn’t surprise me is Rubio resigns … earlier 2027, to “spend more time with his family”, before he announces a 2028 campaign.

now … 2028 … yeeesh. The Republicans HAVE TO win at least something. Keep that split Government.
 

Dadar

All-Conference
Dec 21, 2003
5,189
3,968
113
Not much IMHO. As an independent, I have a lot of faith in the Dems ability to totally blow this win. I think they are going to go after Trump and company and I think that's a mistake. I think common sense, popular legislation would be in order... try for some things that are bipartisan and can get some Republican votes. I'm HOPING that Trump's grip on the Republican Party is slipping after the midterms and some of the *** kissing that the Republicans are famous for goes away as well. The dems need some republican votes to override a veto, but not that many. Also, putting up good popular legislation (even if it gets veto'd) is not a waste of time and can lead to a 2028 win as well.

Most of Trump's policies and big wins (not all) are by executive order. All it takes to roll that back is for the executive order to be reversed. I look for a LOT of that happening if the Dems win the Whitehouse in 2028.

The biggest result of the win is obviously the Senate. The two most batshit crazy members of the SCOTUS are Thomas and Alito and they are both pretty damn old. After the new congress comes in in January, they can halt any SCOTUS nominations for the next couple of years and as the Republicans were saying at the end of Obama's term... let the American People decide.

markets down substantially on fears the democrats will halt AI...
This market has been built on a "house of cards"
 
  • Like
Reactions: yoshi121374

Dadar

All-Conference
Dec 21, 2003
5,189
3,968
113
yea, I have no major issues with your post. I don't care about Hegseth...he could be the scapegoat, but I believe it's Trump pulling the strings on DoD actions.

I'd rather no messaging bills. It would be better working with trump to pass some thing meaningful. But I understand 2028 campaigning is only 1 year away.

agree on judges..which is a shame. I'd prefer judges decide based on law, but I guess that ship has sailed.

Permitting - good
social security - has to get done
immigration - should have been done years ago

I know one of democrats first messages is taxes on the rich. And since I'm not one of them I'm not impacted...But I would prefer that they use the extra money to pay down deficits and debt. But I'm pretty sure that won't happen

I'm an optimist, and I hope this message brings trump back to reality. There are some really good things happening economically, but for the average American, the day to day environment isn't. Compromise isn't a bad word, but some - not all - democrats aren't starting out that way. But hey, if the shoes were on the other foot you'd have republicans making the same threats.,

I don't think there's as much corruption as people make out...ethical violations yes...so the democrats will spend a lot of time investigating and nothing will come of it ----epstein file revisited - but republicans did it so I guess turn about is fair play

politics suck
The whole butt kissing cabinet is rotten to the core
 

m.knox

All-American
Aug 20, 2003
6,355
6,160
113
This Bluekkake thing is obviously hard for you to take. Which runs entirely contrary to your lengthy time spent in the parking lot of the Ann Arbor Olive Garden.

LOL.. Says the guy who steps in human feces so he can get a train run on him at the bath houses of San Francisco.....
 

scotchtiger

Heisman
Dec 15, 2005
135,564
24,171
113
When you say significantly less wait times you out yourself. 6 month wait times for Neurology, Rheumatology, Endocrinology, dermatology. Health care in America is getting worse by the year while big hospital, big pharma, and big insurance rake in the profits. Negotiating for 350 million is power.

Take it up with Chat. US is clearly better in this regard than peer countries with socialized healthcare. And oh yea, those places tax you to death too. No thanks!

1. Primary care and specialist appointments​

The OECD's Health at a Glance 2025 provides a standardized comparison using the Commonwealth Fund's 2023 international patient survey.

MeasureUnited StatesCanadaUKFrance
Primary care: wait over 7 days18%32%18%20%
Specialist: wait 1 month or longer42%68%62%65%
Specialist: wait 2 months or longer17%48%43%45%
Specialist: wait 1 year or longer2%10%11%2%
Source: OECD Health at a Glance 2025, Figure 5.13, based on 2023 patient survey responses. Specialist percentages are rounded sums of reported categories.

Specialist waits of 2 months or longer​


1793986840097.png

0%15%30%45%60%USUKFranceCanada
2023 patient survey; OECD publication 2025

The key findings:

  • US: About 83% of patients who saw a specialist were seen within two months.
  • Canada: Nearly half waited at least two months, and 10% waited a year or longer.
  • UK: Similar long waits to Canada, with the highest share waiting at least one year.
  • France: Surprisingly similar to Canada and the UK for waits beyond two months, but far fewer patients experience waits exceeding one year.
France is particularly interesting: it performs substantially better than Canada and the UK at avoiding extremely long specialist waits, but its typical specialist access isn't necessarily much faster.

2. Elective surgery wait times​

For non-emergency procedures such as hip replacements, knee replacements and cataract surgery, the differences can be substantial.

0%17.5%35%52.5%70%FranceUKCanada
Commonwealth Fund 2023 survey, as reported by Fraser Institute. US percentage not established in this source.

A separate Commonwealth Fund survey from 2020 found the following shares received elective surgery within four months:

CountrySurgery within 4 months
United States92%
France90%
UK72%
Canada62%


These are historical survey comparisons, not guaranteed current scheduling times. The US does not publish an equivalent comprehensive national surgical waiting-list measure.

3. What about total time from referral to treatment?​

Canada offers an additional measure through physician surveys. In 2024, its reported median time from primary care referral through specialist consultation to treatment was 30 weeks, comprising approximately 15 weeks to see the specialist and another 15 weeks to receive treatment.

That figure is not directly comparable to the specialist-appointment percentages above, nor is there a consistent equivalent for all four countries.

Overall comparison​

CategoryStrongest performerWeakest performer
Primary care appointment speedUS / UKCanada
Specialist appointmentsUSCanada, with France and UK close on 2-month waits
Avoiding year-long specialist waitsUS / FranceUK / Canada
Elective surgeryUS / FranceCanada
Bottom line: The US has a meaningful advantage in specialist appointment speed, particularly compared with Canada and the UK. France does better than those two countries at avoiding exceptionally long waits and generally performs well on elective surgery, although its specialist appointments can still take months.



Estimated annual taxes — 2026​

Illustrative comparison: $150,000 US gross wages vs. €150,000 French gross wages, without currency conversion.

TaxUnited StatesFrance
National income tax$10,940~€15,000
Employee payroll/social taxes$11,475~€30,000–€34,000
Total$22,415~€45,000–€49,000
Effective rate14.9%~30–33%
The US calculation uses the 2026 married-filing-jointly brackets, $32,200 standard deduction, two $2,200 child tax credits, and employee Social Security/Medicare taxes.

France uses its 2026 published income-tax schedule, family tax benefits, and estimated employee social contributions. Actual French taxes depend on salary structure and mandatory contribution classifications.

Bottom line: On this illustrative basis, the US family pays roughly 15% of gross income in federal income and payroll taxes, compared with 30–33% in France.
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,636
6,956
113
He's woefully unfit for office, if nothing else.



They should definitely take advantage of any opportunities that are there. It's mostly up to Trump to determine what they can actually work on (but that's assuming Congress isn't just doing insane stuff).



It's long gone. I'm sure every one of the SCOTUS justices would say they're only deciding "on the law". The problem is there's a lot of law out there and they can pick and chose which ones to emphasize to get the outcome they want when there's wiggle room or if the topic is important enough. That's not a very charitable framing but I'm interesting to know if @Aardvark86 or @LafayetteBear think I'm wrong.



You're definitely rich but, based on my understandings of the nature of your wealth and your being retired, the only impact that I think you'd potentially (and hopefully) see is changes to step up basis and lowering the estate tax threshold.



Yeah, I'm hopeful (but not optimistic) that Trump's narcissism and hatred of losers will let him work with the Democrats to get some stuff done. I doubt he cares much what Mike Johnson thinks about anything anymore.



I'm tired of hearing about Epstein but I'm probably just a hater. I do think there's some stuff that Trump has done that should be illegal (not sure if it is). I think ginning up disgust about Trump's enabling of insider trading and general stock market manipulation would be worthwhile if it generates enough momentum to criminalize this activity. I also think the whole "Swamp" narrative is really overstated but it makes sense to address the real issues (if there are any).
I think the judge thing goes deeper that the SC...to many judges at the lower courts seem to be ruling on politics, then get overturned on appeal..but like I said ship has sailed on decisions based on law...and you pointed out, you can interpret or find case law somewhere to support your position.

I was truly surprised at the hegseth pick. didn't understand it at all. He's done some minor good stuff...bringing back the warfighter ethos, but also some really dumb, disruptive stuff. If I were him, I'd resign and go out with what grace he has left..He wouldn't be missed.

I can go along with hopeful also,,,I don't want to lose another 2 years of finger pointing and name calling. Let's work together on some of our problems. The most difficult decision would be where to start...

don't want to see step up go away...would rather find $$ somplace else...but we need tax increases. We can't keep doing $1.5-2 trillion deficits.

I'm tired, been tired of epstein also...either charge someone or move on...we have a lot of issues that need attention
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,636
6,956
113
I’m assuming you haven’t experienced healthcare in this country?
Costs can be contained easily via a universal healthcare model if the right people are hired. The medical industrial complex is bleeding this country dry.
here's the problem, IMO, premiums are going up because costs are going up...all the things people support higher salaries for doctors and staff, new technology for preventative and necessary care, new drugs at higher cost, more treatments/drugs being covered - like glp1.

We're not reducing costs we're just transferring who pays for them
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,636
6,956
113
When you say significantly less wait times you out yourself. 6 month wait times for Neurology, Rheumatology, Endocrinology, dermatology. Health care in America is getting worse by the year while big hospital, big pharma, and big insurance rake in the profits. Negotiating for 350 million is power.
insurance company profits are not obscene in the 2-5% range...healthcare insurance company profit is not the cost driver
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,636
6,956
113
I hope they are successful in doing so. Let billionaires who don't want to pay taxes move to Hungary. Or Russia. Maybe they will thrive there.
I don't think anyone (who is not a billionaire) has any issue with getting more tax revenue from these folks...question is how do you do it. I'm sure there's a way, but not sure wealth tax at 5% is the way. There is a country, one of the scandanaivan ones I think, that has a successful tax. We might consider taki
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,636
6,956
113
Trump will throw Hegseth under the bus in a nanosecond if he thinks it politically expedient. He doesn't care a whit about being perceived as flip flopping, either. Just prior to Election Day, he was encouraging everyone to "vote like I'm on the ballot." Since Election Day, he's been repeatedly saying "Not my fault. I wasn't on the ballot." LOL.
seriously, we've known trump for at least 6 years...did you expect any different?
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,636
6,956
113
The whole butt kissing cabinet is rotten to the core
who watches those cabinet meetings? I've held a lot of executive meetings and none of my subordinates ever gushed over my actions/decisions like these cabinet secretaries....makes me wonder if I was a good an executive as I thought.
 

TigerGrowls

Heisman
Dec 21, 2001
50,422
39,349
113
Not much IMHO. As an independent, I have a lot of faith in the Dems ability to totally blow this win. I think they are going to go after Trump and company and I think that's a mistake. I think common sense, popular legislation would be in order... try for some things that are bipartisan and can get some Republican votes. I'm HOPING that Trump's grip on the Republican Party is slipping after the midterms and some of the *** kissing that the Republicans are famous for goes away as well. The dems need some republican votes to override a veto, but not that many. Also, putting up good popular legislation (even if it gets veto'd) is not a waste of time and can lead to a 2028 win as well.

Most of Trump's policies and big wins (not all) are by executive order. All it takes to roll that back is for the executive order to be reversed. I look for a LOT of that happening if the Dems win the Whitehouse in 2028.

The biggest result of the win is obviously the Senate. The two most batshit crazy members of the SCOTUS are Thomas and Alito and they are both pretty damn old. After the new congress comes in in January, they can halt any SCOTUS nominations for the next couple of years and as the Republicans were saying at the end of Obama's term... let the American People decide.
The pub senate refused to codify a good bit of Trumps agenda forcing him to use EOs for sure. Im sure you libs are salivating at the thought of opening the southern border wide_ass open again. How long before the immigrants start taking DB admin jobs for half the salary???
 
Last edited:

Aardvark86

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
2,600
3,634
113
So I got an email at work with the d health committee leaderships “priority list”. 98 pages. Good thing they’re prioritizing.
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,636
6,956
113
The pub senate refused to codify a good bit of Trumps agenda forcing him to use EOs for sure. Im sure you libs are salivating at the thought of opening the southern border wide_ass open again. How long before the immigrants start taking DB admin jobs for half the salary???
I don't think your statement is 100% accurate....I've read many posts questioning whether the border was open under Biden...many of the Biden supporter question whether the border was open during his administration...In fact I clearly remember being told the border is secure on multiple occasions
 
  • Haha
Reactions: TigerGrowls

hopefultiger13

Heisman
Aug 20, 2008
11,430
18,410
113
The pub senate refused to codify a good bit of Trumps agenda forcing him to use EOs for sure. Im sure you libs are salivating at the thought of opening the southern border wide_ass open again. How long before the immigrants start taking DB admin jobs for half the salary???
A pretty damn long time, because folks with masters degrees in computer science and 25+ years of db experience aren't exactly streaming in.
 

TigerGrowls

Heisman
Dec 21, 2001
50,422
39,349
113
I don't think your statement is 100% accurate....I've read many posts questioning whether the border was open under Biden...many of the Biden supporter question whether the border was open during his administration...In fact I clearly remember being told the border is secure on multiple occasions
Very true Ned. Thats why I call them the loony libs.
 

Rifler

All-American
Jan 26, 2011
6,679
7,532
113
It means that Republicans were the party to most recently disappoint voters,... Dems' turn coming up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 97ClemsonMac

dpic73

Heisman
Jul 27, 2005
37,268
35,026
113
It means that Republicans were the party to most recently disappoint voters,... Dems' turn coming up.
They'll be competing against the Republican agenda. Can you remind me what their plans are to help the American people the next two years?
 

Rifler

All-American
Jan 26, 2011
6,679
7,532
113
They'll be competing against the Republican agenda. Can you remind me what their plans are to help the American people the next two years?

Dems believe that Trump is bad and everything is too expensive,... Simple things for Dems to address.
 

dpic73

Heisman
Jul 27, 2005
37,268
35,026
113
Dems believe that Trump is bad and everything is too expensive,... Simple things for Dems to address.
I asked about the Republican agenda. I don't think I actually heard one leading up to the mid-terms but I could have missed it. Can you remind me?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knickslions69

Rifler

All-American
Jan 26, 2011
6,679
7,532
113
I asked about the Republican agenda. I don't think I actually heard one leading up to the mid-terms but I could have missed it. Can you remind me?

Sounded like you were asking about the Dem agenda,... Republican's best option is to soldier on and keep trying to move their current agenda forward,... Resolve Iran, grow the economy, control the border.
 

dpic73

Heisman
Jul 27, 2005
37,268
35,026
113
Sounded like you were asking about the Dem agenda,... Republican's best option is to soldier on and keep trying to move their current agenda forward,... Resolve Iran, grow the economy, control the border.
Got it, so nothing that would help the affordability crisis that the voters are screaming about. Man, they are making this way too easy for the new Congress - looks like Dems have 2028 in the bag since they're the only one's trying.
 

kidmike41

All-American
Dec 29, 2005
4,297
6,883
113
Got it, so nothing that would help the affordability crisis that the voters are screaming about. Man, they are making this way too easy for the new Congress - looks like Dems have 2028 in the bag since they're the only one's trying.
Ending the war and growing the economy will help with affordability. Reducing government spending will help with inflation, but neither party seems to want to do that. What else can be done? Healthcare is the only thing out there. You can't legislate cheaper groceries.
 

Rifler

All-American
Jan 26, 2011
6,679
7,532
113
Got it, so nothing that would help the affordability crisis that the voters are screaming about. Man, they are making this way too easy for the new Congress - looks like Dems have 2028 in the bag since they're the only one's trying.

Actually, all of those things help with affordability,... How does a Dem congress accomplish positive things towards affordability?,.. As was just demonstrated, lots of things can change in 24 months,... Nothing is in the future bag.
 

dpic73

Heisman
Jul 27, 2005
37,268
35,026
113
Ending the war and growing the economy will help with affordability. Reducing government spending will help with inflation, but neither party seems to want to do that. What else can be done? Healthcare is the only thing out there. You can't legislate cheaper groceries.
I haven't heard those plans or anything really to address affordability, have you? I know one thing, healthcare costs are about to reach crisis stage in January when the bad parts of the BBB kick in.

Dems can put pressure on the admin to end the war sooner if there really is a war, I can't tell because they don't give us any information so we have no idea what's happening at the moment. We'll need answers there first.

Along with the below agenda that they have previously laid out.


Core Priorities

  • Healthcare: Lower costs by reinstating ACA tax credits, blocking Medicaid cuts, capping prescription drug and insulin prices, and addressing medical debt.
  • Tariffs & Trade: Roll back Trump-era import tariffs—starting with Canadian goods like steel and dairy—and reassert congressional oversight over trade taxes.
  • Wages & Family Support: Raise the federal minimum wage to $15 per hour, expand the Child Tax Credit and CDCTC, and advance paid leave and universal pre-K.
  • Groceries & Consumer Protection: Curb supermarket price-gouging and algorithmic pricing, protect SNAP benefits, and restore programs like the Affordable Connectivity Program.
  • Housing & Energy: Expand housing tax credits, penalize large private equity home-buying, and lower utility and gas bills via permitting reform and rate protections.

 
Last edited:

Rifler

All-American
Jan 26, 2011
6,679
7,532
113
Lower costs by reinstating ACA tax credits...

Question on this item,... Why would Democrats want to reinstate enhanced ACA tax credits that they scheduled to sunset as an element of their own legislation?
 

LafayetteBear

Heisman
Nov 30, 2009
35,378
10,802
113
It's long gone. I'm sure every one of the SCOTUS justices would say they're only deciding "on the law". The problem is there's a lot of law out there and they can pick and chose which ones to emphasize to get the outcome they want when there's wiggle room or if the topic is important enough. That's not a very charitable framing but I'm interesting to know if @Aardvark86 or @LafayetteBear think I'm wrong.
FLaw47: I just now noticed your invitation to comment on this subject, so I have composed this post.

Supreme Court justices are now FAR more political (and partisan) than they were in the past, because the process for nominating and confirming them has gotten much more political and partisan over the last several decades. But it's not like the Justices were never political. It's just more obvious (and recurring) than it used to be. Justices on both sides of the aisle reflect this.

I don't know whether you encountered this in law school, but my Constitutional Law classes included substantial discussion of the "judicial hunch" theory of jurisprudence. Boiled down, this simply refers to a judge deciding at the outset what kind of ruling he or she wants to make in a given case, and THEN crafting a legal argument to fit/support that ruling. That flies in the face of the typical judicial statements about "following the law" and "respecting legal precedent," but it nevertheless happens. Some court opinions suggest that more clearly than others.

Supreme Court justices have more leeway to ignore legal precedent because the Court is the ultimate judicial authority in this country and, unlike lower courts, it is not bound by existing case law precedent. The Justices can simply decide to overrule prior cases if they deem it necessary or expedient. The only negative to that is that doing so with any frequency causes the Court to lose some legitimacy in the eyes of not just other judges, attorneys and politicians, but of the general public.

Overruling (or simply ignoring) case law precedent is less likely to happen when the Court is evenly split between conservative and liberal justices, or when the issue under consideration is less political in nature, We just happen to have a distinctly conservative Court right now, and conservative activists who are inclined to exploit that by seeking out and creating "cases or controversies" that they can hopefully take to the Supreme Court.
 

FLaw47

All-American
Dec 23, 2010
4,052
5,717
113
FLaw47: I just now noticed your invitation to comment on this subject, so I have composed this post.

Supreme Court justices are now FAR more political (and partisan) than they were in the past, because the process for nominating and confirming them has gotten much more political and partisan over the last several decades. But it's not like the Justices were never political. It's just more obvious (and recurring) than it used to be. Justices on both sides of the aisle reflect this.

I don't know whether you encountered this in law school, but my Constitutional Law classes included substantial discussion of the "judicial hunch" theory of jurisprudence. Boiled down, this simply refers to a judge deciding at the outset what kind of ruling he or she wants to make in a given case, and THEN crafting a legal argument to fit/support that ruling. That flies in the face of the typical judicial statements about "following the law" and "respecting legal precedent," but it nevertheless happens. Some court opinions suggest that more clearly than others.

Supreme Court justices have more leeway to ignore legal precedent because the Court is the ultimate judicial authority in this country and, unlike lower courts, it is not bound by existing case law precedent. The Justices can simply decide to overrule prior cases if they deem it necessary or expedient. The only negative to that is that doing so with any frequency causes the Court to lose some legitimacy in the eyes of not just other judges, attorneys and politicians, but of the general public.

Overruling (or simply ignoring) case law precedent is less likely to happen when the Court is evenly split between conservative and liberal justices, or when the issue under consideration is less political in nature, We just happen to have a distinctly conservative Court right now, and conservative activists who are inclined to exploit that by seeking out and creating "cases or controversies" that they can hopefully take to the Supreme Court.

Thanks for your perspective! I didn't got to law school, btw. I'm a Mechanical Engineer by education and work in Business Intelligence now. I just have a layman's interest in some of this stuff.
 

dpic73

Heisman
Jul 27, 2005
37,268
35,026
113
Question on this item,... Why would Democrats want to reinstate enhanced ACA tax credits that they scheduled to sunset as an element of their own legislation?
Because healthcare costs have sky-rocketed since then and neither admin has done much to bring them down, and now that Trump has intentionally caused prices for everything else to go up, tens of millions will lose coverage because they simply can't afford it. If they were going to allow the subsidies to sunset, they should have had something to replace them first - they've had two years and not a word about how to help these people.

Why would Republicans want to reinstate the tax cuts that they scheduled to sunset as an element of their own legislation?
 

fskillet

All-Conference
Mar 26, 2026
1,037
2,692
113
Have you experienced healthcare or taxation in other countries? I wouldn’t want to trade places in either category.
Best friend's wife broke her femur in switzerland skiing. Immediately medevacced by chopper to the hospital where she spent 5 days being worked on/stabilized. When they left they got a bill for ~$8k, and they didn't have travel medical insurance.

Meanwhile, it took me 5 months to see a specialist here in the US for a mass on my liver and then I got a bill for $2k.

Now, of course that's anecdotal and Switzerland has a much different tax structure than the US, but that's what I know.
 
  • Like
Reactions: yoshi121374

scotchtiger

Heisman
Dec 15, 2005
135,564
24,171
113
Best friend's wife broke her femur in switzerland skiing. Immediately medevacced by chopper to the hospital where she spent 5 days being worked on/stabilized. When they left they got a bill for ~$8k, and they didn't have travel medical insurance.

Meanwhile, it took me 5 months to see a specialist here in the US for a mass on my liver and then I got a bill for $2k.

Now, of course that's anecdotal and Switzerland has a much different tax structure than the US, but that's what I know.

I’d say Switzerland is a tough comparison. Only 9M people and an affluent country. 12% obesity vs 40% in US.

I may take a carve out if we want to design a government program that only allows 12% of the people to be obese, a median income 20%+ more than the US, caps enrollment at 9M people and only covers a geographic region 1/238th the size of the US. I bet you could design a decent healthcare program here given those parameters.

Now I’m not sure what you do about the other 340M people, 139M fats or 237/238ths of the physical country. And I don’t really want to be part of it, because that program probably wouldn’t be very good.
 

FLaw47

All-American
Dec 23, 2010
4,052
5,717
113
I’d say Switzerland is a tough comparison. Only 9M people and an affluent country. 12% obesity vs 40% in US.

I may take a carve out if we want to design a government program that only allows 12% of the people to be obese, a median income 20%+ more than the US, caps enrollment at 9M people and only covers a geographic region 1/238th the size of the US. I bet you could design a decent healthcare program here given those parameters.

Now I’m not sure what you do about the other 340M people, 139M fats or 237/238ths of the physical country. And I don’t really want to be part of it, because that program probably wouldn’t be very good.

The obesity comparison is a fair thing to call out, but trying to say they’re a smaller country is pretty stupid. If you know anything at all about risk pools, it’s a lot easier to have a good plan for risk with a much larger population than it is with a small population. This is a thing that works in the United States’ favor versus Western Europe.
 

scotchtiger

Heisman
Dec 15, 2005
135,564
24,171
113
The obesity comparison is a fair thing to call out, but trying to say they’re a smaller country is pretty stupid. If you know anything at all about risk pools, it’s a lot easier to have a good plan for risk with a much larger population than it is with a small population. This is a thing that works in the United States’ favor versus Western Europe.

To a certain point, sure. You would rather have 1000 people over 100 in a risk pool. Or 100,000 over 10,000. But there’s a limit to the benefits of that larger pool. The benefits of risk diversification don’t continue to grow at a linear rate. They taper off dramatically.

And the US wayyyy more than offsets that with a much more unhealthy population. 140 million obese people vs 1 million. Worse diet. Worse exercise habits. More chronic conditions.

Then you mix in a massive land area, which is far more difficult for a provider system to manage. There are so many reasons this would be much harder and more expensive in the US.
 

FLaw47

All-American
Dec 23, 2010
4,052
5,717
113
To a certain point, sure. You would rather have 1000 people over 100 in a risk pool. Or 100,000 over 10,000. But there’s a limit to the benefits of that larger pool. The benefits of risk diversification don’t continue to grow at a linear rate. They taper off dramatically.

And the US wayyyy more than offsets that with a much more unhealthy population. 140 million obese people vs 1 million. Worse diet. Worse exercise habits. More chronic conditions.

Then you mix in a massive land area, which is far more difficult for a provider system to manage. There are so many reasons this would be much harder and more expensive in the US.

Okay, so you're prepared to retract your point about Switzerland being a smaller country because you didn't do anything to say that size is ever worse. ( This is a talking point I see brought up all the time and it's never been correct so I've got to be in my bonnet about it.)
 

scotchtiger

Heisman
Dec 15, 2005
135,564
24,171
113
Okay, so you're prepared to retract your point about Switzerland being a smaller country because you didn't do anything to say that size is ever worse. ( This is a talking point I see brought up all the time and it's never been correct so I've got to be in my bonnet about it.)

No I'm not. It’s not just the risk pool. You have to have a provider system to manage that many more people. The scale of the US adds a lot of complexity that doesn’t exist in a smaller market. And as I said, the risk pool benefits at that scale are negligible. Straight from chat:


There is surprisingly little additional risk-pooling benefit from increasing a population from 9 million to 350 million people, assuming we're talking about health insurance and both populations have reasonably diversified demographic and health risks.


The biggest gains from insurance risk pooling occur when moving from hundreds of people to thousands, and then to hundreds of thousands. By the time you reach several million, most of the statistical benefits have already been captured.


This is particularly relevant when comparing a national healthcare system serving 350 million Americans with one serving approximately 9 million people, such as Switzerland.
 
Tiger Illustrated

Latest

  1. 01 Tiger Illustrated Football Recruiting Tuesday Clemson Football Recruiting Nuggets
  2. 02 Tiger Illustrated Football The days of Clemson rubber-stamping Dabo Swinney's contractual decisions are probably over
  3. 03 Tiger Illustrated Football Dabo Swinney on administration alignment, program rebuild, winning another national championship, injuries, Trent Pearman
  4. 04 Tiger Illustrated Football Tuesday Clemson Football Insider: The blueprint moving forward, player evaluations, when we saw this coming, Brock Bradley
  5. 05 Tiger Illustrated Football TUESDAY CLEMSON FOOTBALL INTERVIEWS: Collin Sadler, Kobe McCloud, Ashton Hampton