Stadium Vote:

ThePennsyOracle

Well-known member
Oct 6, 2021
2,438
5,621
113
He has been giving me some good natured ribbing about how no one wanted to put their name on anything Penn State related except, well, ...lets say he took "Beaver" to mean something else. He was very proud of UW having the best naming deal in college athletics. He had a lot of insight into the process. Its not like that's all we talked about, but the topic comes up a couple of times a year.
So your cousin has a sophomoric sense of humor and also doesn’t know what he’s talking about with UW’s deal?
 

lionJC

Member
Oct 21, 2021
266
200
43
Sorry, but in this day and age the amount should have been 0ne Hundred Million not $50 million. $50 million is peanuts to me. I really expected more.
 

Nittering Nabob

Well-known member
Sep 17, 2024
1,149
971
113
So the largest field sponsorship deal in college sports at $50m wasn’t enough because @lionJC said so. Got it.
Why do I get this feeling that you’re not actually “The Pennsy Oracle” from the old BWI board? 🤷🏼‍♂️🙄

Your posts have a familiar style, especially the start of your responses. Do you actually think you’re fooling anyone? 🙄🤔
 
Last edited:

MacNit

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,395
1,316
113
OK, so I will play Devil's Advocate on this....

The members of the BoT were voted in - so they represent many groups including alumni. So, it is their vote that speaks for the alumni (along with the Governor's office and a host of other groups).

What do the BoT bylaws say? Do they say that naming rights or any other specific subject matter requires the general alumni involvement? If so, then yes, they should have had the alumni involved in the decision. If not - well then this is how governance works. And if you don't like it, you rectify it by making sure not to vote those people in next time. (or push that specific group that is represented to not appoint them).

Just out of curiousity, was the naming of the stadium on a meeting Agenda that was made public? Did it need to be?

If it's not in the Bylaws or mandated to be on an Agenda, I don't see it as a leadership fail. It's how governing bodies operate.

I also don't like the name and wish they would have honored Joe, but the Paterno family is not going to give the University $3.3MM per year for 15 years.

BTW, @Tom McAndrew or whomever, can we join the threads of Stadium Naming Rights and the BoT vote?
Paterno’s (in various forms) have already given MUCH, MUCH more.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alphalion75

MacNit

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,395
1,316
113
And all of that makes sense. If you can keep the $12.5MM in pocket and not give it to a 3rd party search firm, then kudos to you.

I will say something that will probably upset a lot of people-I don't think the BoT did this with the intention of screwing over Joe (as much as it pains me to say that). I honestly don't think they place as much emphasis on the stadium being named after Joe as a lot of alumni do. It would have been nice for them to consider Joe and I would have preferred it, but I don't think that it was in the forefront of their thoughts.
You are giving more grace that they deserve.
 

MacNit

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,395
1,316
113
I don’t see why they would particularly care to the degree that it would motivate them to donate seven figures to name the football field after a coach that they never had a relationship with, no.

If anything, they might view his legacy as making their playing time at Penn State significantly more difficult than it needed to be, what with the scholarship limitations that existed during both of their times at Penn State.
His legacy was trashed by those “leaders” they played under.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alphalion75

MacNit

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,395
1,316
113
What amazes me is the University of Washington signed a deal with Alaska Airlines in 2015 for 41 million over 10 years, clearly better than ours and signed 10 years ago. That deal should be up for renewal this year. It will be interesting to see how that pans out.
BOT was ripped off. Undersold to shower refinshers. Sad.
 

MacNit

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,395
1,316
113
$50M rolled into the football program today, well above comps and the projection from a 3rd party, and the same people ***** about it and say they’re not going to donate.

That’s ok we’re doing just fine without you
Still need a coach that can win a meaningful game (no, Potato State dies not count).
 

MacNit

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,395
1,316
113
National Championship. Mike is dreaming. We can’t even win the Conference. Or any other game against teams with a pulse.
 

ThePennsyOracle

Well-known member
Oct 6, 2021
2,438
5,621
113
Why do I get this feeling that you’re not actually “The Pennsy Oracle” from the old BWI board? 🤷🏼‍♂️🙄

Your posts have a familiar style, especially the start of your responses. Do you actually think you’re fooling anyone? 🙄🤔
Yes, its all a grand conspiracy to make the old Pennsy look bad.

Or…..

I am one and the same and you wear tinfoil hats.
 

SoCalLion

Member
Jun 23, 2022
84
98
18
Stadium field naming vote:
Final tally was 22-8 in favor (6 absentees)

No Votes:

Anthony Lubrano
Jay Paterno

LOL. These two losers --- by my count, their "all-time record going back to November 2011" as regards all things Joe Paterno is now 0-154329.

Even the Washington Generals aren't that bad!

To his credit, Jay hasn't --- at least to the best of my knowledge --- acted as a paid shill for the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia lately.
 

J.E.B

Well-known member
Oct 30, 2021
1,721
2,297
113
What a bloated board. 38 people is insane and excessive.
The BOT is ROT. So it’s a record setting agreement but they have less than 48 hrs to review? As usual, decisions are made behind the scenes. They told Sue that Joe has a Smithsonian display planned at the museum coming. That’s great. WSH is paying $475k a game. Seems cheap and can’t wait to see what else they receive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnJumba

Marshall2323

Well-known member
Aug 7, 2024
1,125
1,826
113
I understand and respect that everyone has an opinion on this. I'm satisfied that the decision makers went with the best financial offer. I fail to see why they would not. I also understand that nothing about "college football" resembles the game I've loved for more than 60 years. I'm not convinced that this process could not have been orchestrated in a manner to be palatable to Joebots like me. Putting Joe's name on the field without an overwhelming financial deal would have been a PR disaster and financially irresponsible. That's hard to dismiss. While I will never understand PSU fans who never took the time to study and understand the false narrative......I do get that the average person only knows what they hear or read.
I would have liked to see a meaningful gesture honoring Sue and Joe come forward in unison with the branding announcement. Something that would assure us Joebots that Joe would no longer be treated as persona non grata .....because there is no way in hell this program or this stadium is even close to where it is without him. Instead, I feel like they slammed the door, once again. Yes, nothing would please Joe or honor him more than winning an NC as Mauti says. But I have a question.....if PSU wins a National Championship, will the bastards even mention who the coach was for the other two?
 

rudedude

Well-known member
Oct 6, 2021
7,071
13,941
113
West Shore Home, a Pennsylvania-based home remodeling company, along with its founder B.J. Werzyn, has committed to a $50 million gift to Penn State University for the naming rights of the field at Beaver Stadium. This agreement, approved by Penn State’s Board of Trustees on March 10, 2025, with a 22-8 vote, designates the field as "West Shore Home Field at Beaver Stadium" for a 15-year period, starting with the 2025 football season and running through 2039.

The payment structure is structured as follows: West Shore Home will make annual payments to finance the field naming, with $10 million paid over the first 10 years (equating to $1 million per year for that initial decade), and the remaining $40 million disbursed over the subsequent 50 years. This front-loaded approach, as noted by Vice President for Intercollegiate Athletics Pat Kraft, is designed to support the immediate financial needs of Beaver Stadium’s $700 million renovation project, reducing the amount the university needs to borrow upfront. The entire $50 million gift is allocated toward this revitalization effort, which began in 2024 and is expected to be completed by the 2027 season.

This donation is the second-largest private gift in Penn State history, surpassed only by Terry Pegula’s $102 million contribution for the campus ice arena and hockey programs. With this commitment, Penn State has raised $130.675 million toward its $134 million fundraising goal for the stadium project. Kraft has described this as potentially the most valuable athletic facility naming gift in the country, emphasizing its significance to the university’s athletic and financial strategy.

so it averages 3.3million/yr but it’s 1 million/year 1st 10 yrs and long tail of $40 million over 50 years, which isn’t ideal. Just in time to rebuild the stadium again. Compare that to what other schools did (like @fairgambit did with U of W).
 
Last edited:

psuro

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
8,411
18,270
113
Paterno’s (in various forms) have already given MUCH, MUCH more.
And there is probably some level of truth to that

But after watching a couple of people who are probably closer than any of us are to the situation, it appears the decision was made based on $50MM being ready and available in cash, right now. This appears to be the second largest gift made to PSU athletics-ever.

I suppose if a concerted group of people who wanted to name the field after Joe, could guarantee and document and have available more than $50MM, it would have been different.

I don't know if this firm gets some sort of tax break for the donation. But, one can assume they did not just do this out of the kindness of their heart.
 

SleepyLion

Well-known member
Sep 1, 2022
1,588
2,118
113
West Shore Home, a Pennsylvania-based home remodeling company, along with its founder B.J. Werzyn, has committed to a $50 million gift to Penn State University for the naming rights of the field at Beaver Stadium. This agreement, approved by Penn State’s Board of Trustees on March 10, 2025, with a 22-8 vote, designates the field as "West Shore Home Field at Beaver Stadium" for a 15-year period, starting with the 2025 football season and running through 2039.

The payment structure is structured as follows: West Shore Home will make annual payments to finance the field naming, with $10 million paid over the first 10 years (equating to $1 million per year for that initial decade), and the remaining $40 million disbursed over the subsequent 50 years. This front-loaded approach, as noted by Vice President for Intercollegiate Athletics Pat Kraft, is designed to support the immediate financial needs of Beaver Stadium’s $700 million renovation project, reducing the amount the university needs to borrow upfront. The entire $50 million gift is allocated toward this revitalization effort, which began in 2024 and is expected to be completed by the 2027 season.

This donation is the second-largest private gift in Penn State history, surpassed only by Terry Pegula’s $102 million contribution for the campus ice arena and hockey programs. With this commitment, Penn State has raised $130.675 million toward its $134 million fundraising goal for the stadium project. Kraft has described this as potentially the most valuable athletic facility naming gift in the country, emphasizing its significance to the university’s athletic and financial strategy.

so it averages 3.3million/yr but it’s 1 million/year 1st 10 yrs and long tail of $40 million over 50 years, which isn’t ideal. Just in time to rebuild the stadium again. Compare that to what other schools did (like @fairgambit did with U of W).
So, if after say 10 years and $10M in payments made WSH goes bankrupt...? It was $1M per year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rudedude

PSUJam

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
11,506
20,831
113
West Shore Home, a Pennsylvania-based home remodeling company, along with its founder B.J. Werzyn, has committed to a $50 million gift to Penn State University for the naming rights of the field at Beaver Stadium. This agreement, approved by Penn State’s Board of Trustees on March 10, 2025, with a 22-8 vote, designates the field as "West Shore Home Field at Beaver Stadium" for a 15-year period, starting with the 2025 football season and running through 2039.

The payment structure is structured as follows: West Shore Home will make annual payments to finance the field naming, with $10 million paid over the first 10 years (equating to $1 million per year for that initial decade), and the remaining $40 million disbursed over the subsequent 50 years. This front-loaded approach, as noted by Vice President for Intercollegiate Athletics Pat Kraft, is designed to support the immediate financial needs of Beaver Stadium’s $700 million renovation project, reducing the amount the university needs to borrow upfront. The entire $50 million gift is allocated toward this revitalization effort, which began in 2024 and is expected to be completed by the 2027 season.

This donation is the second-largest private gift in Penn State history, surpassed only by Terry Pegula’s $102 million contribution for the campus ice arena and hockey programs. With this commitment, Penn State has raised $130.675 million toward its $134 million fundraising goal for the stadium project. Kraft has described this as potentially the most valuable athletic facility naming gift in the country, emphasizing its significance to the university’s athletic and financial strategy.

so it averages 3.3million/yr but it’s 1 million/year 1st 10 yrs and long tail of $40 million over 50 years, which isn’t ideal. Just in time to rebuild the stadium again. Compare that to what other schools did (like @fairgambit did with U of W).
I questioned Nate on this on the pay site and he said it's all going to be paid out in the first ten years.
 

PSUJam

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
11,506
20,831
113
And there is probably some level of truth to that

But after watching a couple of people who are probably closer than any of us are to the situation, it appears the decision was made based on $50MM being ready and available in cash, right now. This appears to be the second largest gift made to PSU athletics-ever.

I suppose if a concerted group of people who wanted to name the field after Joe, could guarantee and document and have available more than $50MM, it would have been different.

I don't know if this firm gets some sort of tax break for the donation. But, one can assume they did not just do this out of the kindness of their heart.
I posted this on the pay site:

"To add to this, don't forget that West Shore Homes has been a significant factor in our recent success through NIL. It's not like they just jumped on board because the team is selling out Beaver Stadium with a great team. They were actually part of drawing in the crowds by stepping up with NIL now they are looking to put us over the top."
 

BobPSU92

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
18,605
27,948
113
West Shore Home, a Pennsylvania-based home remodeling company, along with its founder B.J. Werzyn, has committed to a $50 million gift to Penn State University for the naming rights of the field at Beaver Stadium. This agreement, approved by Penn State’s Board of Trustees on March 10, 2025, with a 22-8 vote, designates the field as "West Shore Home Field at Beaver Stadium" for a 15-year period, starting with the 2025 football season and running through 2039.

The payment structure is structured as follows: West Shore Home will make annual payments to finance the field naming, with $10 million paid over the first 10 years (equating to $1 million per year for that initial decade), and the remaining $40 million disbursed over the subsequent 50 years. This front-loaded approach, as noted by Vice President for Intercollegiate Athletics Pat Kraft, is designed to support the immediate financial needs of Beaver Stadium’s $700 million renovation project, reducing the amount the university needs to borrow upfront. The entire $50 million gift is allocated toward this revitalization effort, which began in 2024 and is expected to be completed by the 2027 season.

This donation is the second-largest private gift in Penn State history, surpassed only by Terry Pegula’s $102 million contribution for the campus ice arena and hockey programs. With this commitment, Penn State has raised $130.675 million toward its $134 million fundraising goal for the stadium project. Kraft has described this as potentially the most valuable athletic facility naming gift in the country, emphasizing its significance to the university’s athletic and financial strategy.

so it averages 3.3million/yr but it’s 1 million/year 1st 10 yrs and long tail of $40 million over 50 years, which isn’t ideal. Just in time to rebuild the stadium again. Compare that to what other schools did (like @fairgambit did with U of W).

A naming period of 15 years paid over 50 years? Is that correct? For f*ck’s sake.

$134 MM fundraising goal for the stadium project? What about the other $566 MM? For f*ck’s sake.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MacNit and Sharkies

Bwifan

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,753
3,128
113
And there is probably some level of truth to that

But after watching a couple of people who are probably closer than any of us are to the situation, it appears the decision was made based on $50MM being ready and available in cash, right now. This appears to be the second largest gift made to PSU athletics-ever.

I suppose if a concerted group of people who wanted to name the field after Joe, could guarantee and document and have available more than $50MM, it would have been different.

I don't know if this firm gets some sort of tax break for the donation. But, one can assume they did not just do this out of the kindness of their heart.
Agree but it's really $50 million over 50 years not $50 million available right now
 
  • Like
Reactions: MacNit

PSUFTG

Well-known member
Nov 1, 2021
1,520
2,475
113
A naming period of 15 years paid over 50 years? Is that correct? For f*ck’s sake.

$134 MM fundraising goal for the stadium project? What about the other $566 MM? For f*ck’s sake.
That is not correct - I do not know if Kraft "misspoke", or someone "heard it wrong".

The time period is 15 year.
For those "quantitatively inclined", that means the total present value of the advertising revenue (assuming all payments are made on schedule) depending on exactly which discount factors one uses, is approximately $25-30 m..... the first $3+ million to come due this year.
 

PSU Mike

Well-known member
Oct 6, 2021
2,609
4,280
113
West Shore Home, a Pennsylvania-based home remodeling company, along with its founder B.J. Werzyn, has committed to a $50 million gift to Penn State University for the naming rights of the field at Beaver Stadium. This agreement, approved by Penn State’s Board of Trustees on March 10, 2025, with a 22-8 vote, designates the field as "West Shore Home Field at Beaver Stadium" for a 15-year period, starting with the 2025 football season and running through 2039.

The payment structure is structured as follows: West Shore Home will make annual payments to finance the field naming, with $10 million paid over the first 10 years (equating to $1 million per year for that initial decade), and the remaining $40 million disbursed over the subsequent 50 years. This front-loaded approach, as noted by Vice President for Intercollegiate Athletics Pat Kraft, is designed to support the immediate financial needs of Beaver Stadium’s $700 million renovation project, reducing the amount the university needs to borrow upfront. The entire $50 million gift is allocated toward this revitalization effort, which began in 2024 and is expected to be completed by the 2027 season.

This donation is the second-largest private gift in Penn State history, surpassed only by Terry Pegula’s $102 million contribution for the campus ice arena and hockey programs. With this commitment, Penn State has raised $130.675 million toward its $134 million fundraising goal for the stadium project. Kraft has described this as potentially the most valuable athletic facility naming gift in the country, emphasizing its significance to the university’s athletic and financial strategy.

so it averages 3.3million/yr but it’s 1 million/year 1st 10 yrs and long tail of $40 million over 50 years, which isn’t ideal. Just in time to rebuild the stadium again. Compare that to what other schools did (like @fairgambit did with U of W).
Where did you get that? I thought I read that it was indeed front-loaded such that all $50MM was coming in semi/annual payments over the first 10 years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Erial_Lion

Bwifan

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,753
3,128
113
That is not correct - I do not know if Kraft "misspoke", or someone "heard it wrong".

The time period is 15 year.
For those "quantitatively inclined", that means the total present value of the advertising revenue (assuming all payments are made on schedule) depending on exactly which discount factors one uses, is approximately $25-30 m..... the first $3+ million to come due this year.
Thank You for qualifying and correcting.
 

rudedude

Well-known member
Oct 6, 2021
7,071
13,941
113
Where did you get that? I thought I read that it was indeed front-loaded such that all $50MM was coming in semi/annual payments over the first 10 years.
Several sources online reported this and there in lies my confusion. If it is a 15 year deal with $1 mil/yr first 10 years, does that mean the $40 mil left gets paid out over the last 5 yrs? I don’t see a lot of clarity with the actual specifics. It’s 15 years so Kraft was misheard in laying out the specifics. 15 vs 50 is a huge difference.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BobPSU92

Midnighter

Well-known member
Oct 7, 2021
10,258
16,308
113
West Shore Home, a Pennsylvania-based home remodeling company, along with its founder B.J. Werzyn, has committed to a $50 million gift to Penn State University for the naming rights of the field at Beaver Stadium. This agreement, approved by Penn State’s Board of Trustees on March 10, 2025, with a 22-8 vote, designates the field as "West Shore Home Field at Beaver Stadium" for a 15-year period, starting with the 2025 football season and running through 2039.

The payment structure is structured as follows: West Shore Home will make annual payments to finance the field naming, with $10 million paid over the first 10 years (equating to $1 million per year for that initial decade), and the remaining $40 million disbursed over the subsequent 50 years. This front-loaded approach, as noted by Vice President for Intercollegiate Athletics Pat Kraft, is designed to support the immediate financial needs of Beaver Stadium’s $700 million renovation project, reducing the amount the university needs to borrow upfront. The entire $50 million gift is allocated toward this revitalization effort, which began in 2024 and is expected to be completed by the 2027 season.

This donation is the second-largest private gift in Penn State history, surpassed only by Terry Pegula’s $102 million contribution for the campus ice arena and hockey programs. With this commitment, Penn State has raised $130.675 million toward its $134 million fundraising goal for the stadium project. Kraft has described this as potentially the most valuable athletic facility naming gift in the country, emphasizing its significance to the university’s athletic and financial strategy.

so it averages 3.3million/yr but it’s 1 million/year 1st 10 yrs and long tail of $40 million over 50 years, which isn’t ideal. Just in time to rebuild the stadium again. Compare that to what other schools did (like @fairgambit did with U of W).

How is this front loaded? 10mm over first ten years then $40mm over an additional 50?! Good lord.
 

BobPSU92

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
18,605
27,948
113
That is not correct - I do not know if Kraft "misspoke", or someone "heard it wrong".

The time period is 15 year.
For those "quantitatively inclined", that means the total present value of the advertising revenue (assuming all payments are made on schedule) depending on exactly which discount factors one uses, is approximately $25-30 m..... the first $3+ million to come due this year.

Thank you. That makes more sense.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnJumba

Bob78

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
1,499
3,440
113
Barry, is there a difference in the approval process for a paid-rights naming, vs. an honorary naming? For example, if PSU wanted to name a building or space for a distinguished alumni or other person who made significant contributions in their field, but with no monetary contributions included, does it need more than the President's ok to do so?
Thanks.
@PSUFTG

Barry, does the President have the authority to ok an honorary naming when no monetary donation is involved? In other words, if Neeli decided to (and I realize she previously said no to naming the field for Joe last year), could she make that happen without BOT approval?
Thanks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnJumba