Who are your Top 5....and does Ralph crack the list?<div>
</div><div>1) Don Smith</div><div>2) Bond - really could be 1A</div><div>3) Madkin - definitely production over talent - but he went to Atlanta and holds a lot of records.</div><div>4) Relf - boom. Similar to Sleepy, if his career ended today he would be the all time leader in passing efficiency. If he plays this season like he did the last 3 games of 2010, he would likely end up #3 on this list...or 1C.</div><div>5) Sleepy - I surprise myself to put him below Relf...but Relf's numbers are better - Sleepy makes it in over the honorable mentions based on talent over production.</div><div>
</div><div>Honorable Mention: Rocky, Pharr, Taite, Fant (victim of circumstance), and Parker</div><div>
</div><div>I feel like I have to put Smith and Bond at the top, like it is a MSU fan law, but that was before I was old enough to really appreciate what they were doing - their rushing totals were impressive though. I remember hating and loving Madkin during those years, but I have to give him the 3 spot because he was our QB when we went to Atlanta, and they did it while I was in school - and only now do I realize how lucky I was to be there during those years. </div>
</div><div>1) Don Smith</div><div>2) Bond - really could be 1A</div><div>3) Madkin - definitely production over talent - but he went to Atlanta and holds a lot of records.</div><div>4) Relf - boom. Similar to Sleepy, if his career ended today he would be the all time leader in passing efficiency. If he plays this season like he did the last 3 games of 2010, he would likely end up #3 on this list...or 1C.</div><div>5) Sleepy - I surprise myself to put him below Relf...but Relf's numbers are better - Sleepy makes it in over the honorable mentions based on talent over production.</div><div>
</div><div>Honorable Mention: Rocky, Pharr, Taite, Fant (victim of circumstance), and Parker</div><div>
</div><div>I feel like I have to put Smith and Bond at the top, like it is a MSU fan law, but that was before I was old enough to really appreciate what they were doing - their rushing totals were impressive though. I remember hating and loving Madkin during those years, but I have to give him the 3 spot because he was our QB when we went to Atlanta, and they did it while I was in school - and only now do I realize how lucky I was to be there during those years. </div>
