The "deal" was murky from the start and the rules kept changing, but forgiveness was based on certain requirements. PPP was intended for small businesses to keep people on the payroll, yet there was very little done on the enforcement side to verify that was the case before 'forgiving" billions in "loans:"
Government officials acknowledge that the program was rife with fraud and did not weed out undeserving applicants. But there was a way to remedy those early errors: Deny forgiveness. That could have thwarted scam artists and forced businesses that prospered to repay the money.
Yet nearly three years after the rollout of PPP, the vast majority of loans have been forgiven.
...
In the frenzied early days of COVID, as PPP was created in great haste to keep businesses from potentially collapsing, the loans were simple to get: Companies simply had to pledge that the economic threat of the pandemic made the funding necessary. But what it would take later to qualify for forgiveness was hazy.
"It was entirely unclear at the beginning," said Eric Lichatin, a commercial loan officer at Centreville Bank in Rhode Island, which was inundated by calls from customers wanting PPP loans. "The SBA really rushed to get this program out there, which I think they should be commended for ... but a lot of the details were very unclear to businesses and banks."
As the program evolved, its rules became increasingly complicated, and even experts struggled to make sense of them. At one point, the SBA published a list of frequently asked questions on loan forgiveness that was 11 pages long. One consulting firm issued a client advisory with the headline "Fast and furious: The rules for the PPP ... continue to emerge at a brisk pace, often updating previous guidance."
The benefits of the landmark small-business relief program designed at the height of the pandemic mostly went to business owners rather than its employees, a...
www.marketwatch.com
Put another way, between 23% to 34% of PPP dollars went directly to workers who otherwise would have lost jobs, the study found. The program also was highly regressive, with three-quarters of PPP funds accruing to the top quintile of households.
The bottom line is many of the same politicians grandstanding about student loan forgiveness -- which is comparatively minor -- didn't give a damn about government handouts when it came to enriching their donors and, in some cases, themselves.