That's a problem with Crooms recruits - most of them were not talented enough to actually be disappointed in how they've performed. It's hard to criticize 2-star recruits for not playing up to par in the SEC. And with Elliott & McRae coming off major injuries I'll give them a pass.
I'd go with any of our 2nd string defensive guys. Have we seen any quality 2nd string guys, especially at LB? Maybe guys like Mike Hunt (has he even played any), Jamie Jones, Bo Walters... who do we have at LB after our starting 3? Offensively, I'll go with Phillip Freeman. Everyone always complains about OL depth and wants us to sign good JUCO guys - well, has this guy played a snap yet?