Toggle sidebar

Wrestling Thread

A

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
4,532
2,453
47
Outstanding PPV. Clockwork Carnage might have been the worst match of the night. It was a fun match and I appreciate them trying something different but that’s not an AEW PPV main event caliber match type. Appears I am very much in the minority with that opinion though.
 
A

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
4,532
2,453
47
My dream has finally come true and it’s doing big numbers on online. His debut and his two teaser vignettes each got over 1.5 million views on Twitter.

Will it translate to anything that actually matters business wise though?

 
N

Nightwish

Senior
Jul 10, 2025
711
998
93
American Dragon said:
My dream has finally come true and it’s doing big numbers on online. His debut and his two teaser vignettes each got over 1.5 million views on Twitter.

Will it translate to anything that actually matters business wise though?
Click to expand...
So let's be real here...any debut will get big numbers online unless it's a random from NJPW who Kenny loves or something. Also, if we're being fair, if this were WWE you'd likely discount the Twitter views as "those aren't actual views because you can scroll past a video that automatically plays and that counts as a view." I know this because you've done it before lol.

I'm happy for him and he belongs in AEW but you know the answer already. A talented midcarder in WWE who's probably 5'7, not seen in several months, isn't going to be a game changer or needle mover in AEW. By Thanksgiving he'll be having random matches on Collision while the rest of the country is watching college football. Again, very happy for him but you asked the question. We've seen this about forty times with much bigger names with bigger legacies and none of them did what you're wondering. Pillars, needle movers, mystery Max numbers...it's a lot of hype. I recall SRS suggesting that because Mercedes has over a million followers on IG, they could follow her to AEW. Buddy, most of those are either bots or women who care about her fashion type photos. No one followed her to AEW.

You asked the question, I gave the answer lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Laparkafan
A

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
4,532
2,453
47
Big Bill
Ethan Page
Penta
Hobbs
Miro
CM Punk
Cody Rhodes
Rey Fenix
Ricky Starks
Mariah May
Jade Cargill
Paige
Danhausen
Mike Santana
Lexis King
Shawn Spears
Vikingo
Jack Cartwheel

All signed to one company. Do you really want WWE or do you just want to watch AEW/ROH from 2019-2023?

Now see how stupid that is?
 
A

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
4,532
2,453
47
Nightwish said:
So let's be real here...any debut will get big numbers online unless it's a random from NJPW who Kenny loves or something. Also, if we're being fair, if this were WWE you'd likely discount the Twitter views as "those aren't actual views because you can scroll past a video that automatically plays and that counts as a view." I know this because you've done it before lol.

I'm happy for him and he belongs in AEW but you know the answer already. A talented midcarder in WWE who's probably 5'7, not seen in several months, isn't going to be a game changer or needle mover in AEW. By Thanksgiving he'll be having random matches on Collision while the rest of the country is watching college football. Again, very happy for him but you asked the question. We've seen this about forty times with much bigger names with bigger legacies and none of them did what you're wondering. Pillars, needle movers, mystery Max numbers...it's a lot of hype. I recall SRS suggesting that because Mercedes has over a million followers on IG, they could follow her to AEW. Buddy, most of those are either bots or women who care about her fashion type photos. No one followed her to AEW.

You asked the question, I gave the answer lol.
Click to expand...

How much money have you given to Nigerian princes that have emailed you asking for money?
 
N

Nightwish

Senior
Jul 10, 2025
711
998
93
American Dragon said:
How much money have you given to Nigerian princes that have emailed you asking for money?
Click to expand...
I mean you asked a question and I gave a thoughtful answer. That's how threads work. If you don't like my answer, refute it but don't get snarky if you ask something and the response isn't akin to "oh yes I agree game changer this is really really massive for the industry and AEW. Big big business coming"

I like him, he's very talented. AEW will appreciate him more than WWE did. But he won't move the needle and in a few weeks will just be having random matches. Nothing wrong with that but it's been like 7 years of "OMG THIS IS MASSIVE FOR AEW" and we're still waiting. The only time a move like this will set the industry on fire and mean big things is if MJF, Mox, or Kenny shows up in WWE or about 7-10 top stars in WWE show up in AEW. Ilja isn't one of those names. I love Ciampa but the man fought a pair of pants on PPV last night lol. He's not a big business get either.
 
A

American Dragon

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2020
4,532
2,453
47
Nightwish said:
I mean you asked a question and I gave a thoughtful answer. That's how threads work. If you don't like my answer, refute it but don't get snarky if you ask something and the response isn't akin to "oh yes I agree game changer this is really really massive for the industry and AEW. Big big business coming"

I like him, he's very talented. AEW will appreciate him more than WWE did. But he won't move the needle and in a few weeks will just be having random matches. Nothing wrong with that but it's been like 7 years of "OMG THIS IS MASSIVE FOR AEW" and we're still waiting. The only time a move like this will set the industry on fire and mean big things is if MJF, Mox, or Kenny shows up in WWE or about 7-10 top stars in WWE show up in AEW. Ilja isn't one of those names. I love Ciampa but the man fought a pair of pants on PPV last night lol. He's not a big business get either.
Click to expand...
And your "thoughtful answer" shows you lack any understanding of context, nuance, and AEW, just like they always do. You're so brainwashed by the WWE way that was proliferated by a rapist and a racist that you are completely incapable of understanding anything else.

I never said Ciampa was a big get. I was actually pretty hesitant about AEW adding him.
 
L

Laparkafan

Heisman
Sep 5, 2004
15,183
10,548
93
Nightwish said:
I mean you asked a question and I gave a thoughtful answer. That's how threads work. If you don't like my answer, refute it but don't get snarky if you ask something and the response isn't akin to "oh yes I agree game changer this is really really massive for the industry and AEW. Big big business coming"

I like him, he's very talented. AEW will appreciate him more than WWE did. But he won't move the needle and in a few weeks will just be having random matches. Nothing wrong with that but it's been like 7 years of "OMG THIS IS MASSIVE FOR AEW" and we're still waiting. The only time a move like this will set the industry on fire and mean big things is if MJF, Mox, or Kenny shows up in WWE or about 7-10 top stars in WWE show up in AEW. Ilja isn't one of those names. I love Ciampa but the man fought a pair of pants on PPV last night lol. He's not a big business get either.
Click to expand...
He’s so blinded by tribalism he gives the same basic response over and over
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football "Ball excellence" has been huge for Kentucky this season
  2. 02 KSR Football Kentucky receives another bump in the AP Poll Top 25 rankings
  3. 03 KSR Football Tickets for Kentucky's home game against Vanderbilt next Saturday are already sold out
  4. 04 KSR Football Kentucky continues to climb in latest Coaches Poll Top 25 rankings
  5. 05 KSR Football Kenny Minchey made sure Jordan Castell got the game ball for his first Pick Six
Top Bottom