Would a 16 team CFP bracket really solve it?

No

The 17th team would be the new controversy

It won’t fix anything, IMO

RTR251 said:

With this year as an example, would the top 14 P4 teams satisfy everyone or would folks still be cryin?

Only if it’s best 16. Group of 5 needs their own championship.

You would be adding Notre Dame, BYU, Texas, and Vanderbilt. No one would have complained.

We are headed to a top 25 bracket unfortunately imo. They’ll start with 16 but we know they won’t stop.

There is no solving complaints about the bottom of the bracket. No matter how large the field is.

#s 69-75 cry every year in the basketball tournament

I mean, I really already know the answer but I’m just curious how far we would have to go in order to satisfy everyone.

Keep 12 and make it not have any AQs. Only way to fix it.

No

423Bama said:

We are headed to a top 25 bracket unfortunately imo. They’ll start with 16 but we know they won’t stop.

They won’t stop

RTR251 said:

With this year as an example, would the top 14 P4 teams satisfy everyone or would folks still be cryin?

No

JMU and Tulane had no business in. However TBH should’ve stayed at the BCS or 4 team

RTR251 said:

I mean, I really already know the answer but I’m just curious how far we would have to go in order to satisfy everyone.

136 Though then FCS teams 1-4 would start complaining.

ND vs Ole Miss and Vandy vs Oregon works for me

All you have to do is get rid of Tulane and James Madison and put in Notre Dame and Vanderbilt and it would be a great playoff. Every game would be good.

I think 12 is the number, but FBS does not get an invite. They need to have their own CFP.

HCBanker said:

All you have to do is get rid of Tulane and James Madison and put in Notre Dame and Vanderbilt and it would be a great playoff. Every game would be good.

Vandy wasn't getting in. It wouldve been ND and BYU.

Easye921 said:

Vandy wasn't getting in. It wouldve been ND and BYU.

I am not predicting what would have happened. lol. Obviously, James Madison and Tulane got in. I am saying what should have happened. BYU is not anywhere near as good as Vanderbilt and Oregon would crush BYU. I’m saying that Ole Miss versus Notre Dame would be a good game. Vanderbilt vs Oregon would be a good game. that’s what should have happened.

Nope nothings gonna solve it until the group of 5 is out of the discussion.

Tulane was an embarrassment. JMU was not even worthy.

Lol. It's too many at 12. Go back to 4.

No keep it at 12 just put the best 12 in Group 5 I’m sorry this is a sad situation i really hope the ratings sucks so the networks can force a change bc this is a disgrace to the fans.